Top 35 Gluten-Free Italian Spots to Delight in Sarasota

Colby Troyer

This place exceeded expectations. Excellent food, drinks and service. We started with raw clams and spicy margaritas and then had two pasta dishes for entrees. My partner is gluten free and they offer gluten free pasta which was great! Everything tasted and was presented beautifully. Serving sizes were very generous - I took at least half my entree home! Our server was friendly, professional and quick. We will be back!

Sue Erickson

We ordered 4 pizzas to dine in. One was gluten free. She brings 3 pizzas out. We wait for 25 minutes and ask where the gluten free pizza was. She said this is it. We asked why she put it in front of another couple. It was 3/4 eaten. She said she would order another gluten free. 1/2 hour later I asked another waiter where the gluten free pizza was. I then said give us our bill. Paid the bill and needless to say she got no tip. It was like she didn’t want to be there. Not attentive. Very poor service. She took the pizza off our bill and we never got the one that was reordered.

Karin D

My first time here. The perfect choice and a great evening. The food was delicious. I’m celiac as well as having a dairy allergy. My waitress Julia couldn’t have been more accommodating. She made sure my meal was perfect. Very friendly and professional. Top notch service! Brian the manager was excellent. He too made sure I had the best service as well as making me feel like family while there. I was celebrating my birthday and he went out of his way to make the evening a great one for me. Great restaurant and great staff. Highly recommended :)

Kelvin Guzmán

Awesome pizza, very unique and tasty pizza selection and variety. (Regular classics and Thai/Mexican/etc). The best customer service of any restaurant ive been to, every time i go there. Restaurant manager and servers are super attentive, friendly and pleasant Very consistently excellent food and service, never disappointed. Also gluten-free options for people with Celiac's.

Michael Rogers

Chad was an amazing server! He was very attentive, knew the menu well, and was helpful with gluten-free options for a family member with celiac disease.

Shanna Stevenson (Savvy Snickerdoodle)

Always an amazing food experience. Lots of gluten free options and very accommodating. Their Alfredo sauce is the best I have ever had. So Good.

Mario Mlotkowski, Realtor

The place is really nice inside, and the lake view is amazing. They have an awesome pizza selection — including our favorite gluten-free one. Tons of great salads too, and don’t even get me started on the pastries… so good!

Autumn Dráb

Best pizza in Sarasota! The sourdough crust is incredible and I never want to eat any other pizza! I have gluten sensitivity and this pizza doesn’t hurt my stomach at all!

dgillettlive

I’m gluten intolerant and I love the original margarita (no red sauce, just light olive oil on crust). I asked and was very thrilled to have it the way I like it, even though it’s not on your menu. We go out every Monday for pizza and have “finally” found our pizza place while we are down here for the winter. We are so happy!

Amy B

They sell fresh baked goods. Wonderful and flavorful salads. The gluten free pizza is delicious

Daniela Toro

We had a wonderful dining experience! Everyone was so welcoming and friendly. We asked if they had gluten free options and they said absolutely! I asked if I could have Frutto di Mare pasta when it was only in the menu for the risotto and they that of course! It was DELICIOUS!!! My daughter’s gluten free pasta was amazing too. And my husband loved his pasta too. Thank you so much! We will be back for sure during our vacation! We highly recommend Flavio’s!

Suzanne Amos

Had a fabulous meal at this lovely local restaurant. Located on Main Street in downtown Sarasota, they offer indoor and outdoor dining. Unpretentious and very European feeling with little tables scattered on the sidewalk. The service was prompt and the food excellent. Probably the best pasta I’ve had outside of Italy. As an aside, I noted that most dishes can be made gluten-free should that be a requirement, something seen frequently in Europe but not so much in North America. Overall, a great meal and will definitely return on our next trip to Sarasota.

Jackie Engel

Amber did an excellent job as our server. The food was very good. Lots of gluten free options.

Kaleigh P

Our absolute favorite restaurant! Great service, amazing food, and amazing gluten free food! A must go!

Jenelle Ramirez

Nobody Special

3x I’ve ordered from this place and have done regular crust and gluten free. Toppings are scarce and expensive and pizza is dry. They can say in the comments it’s about picking it up on time but both times it didn’t make a difference. Edit: I dropped it down from 2 to 1 stars because the reply was sarcastic rather than asking questions to rectify, just like the others. People shouldn’t be in business if they can’t take constructive criticism and try to fix it.

Cheree Climer

Brian Baxter

Cheridan Smith

This is such a fun vibe for a group of people! The food was really tasty and a great size portion of pasta, which is hard to find. It was also pretty light on the sauce which made me leave not feeling too heavy or bloated. They have options for gluten free pasta too. My Italian margarita was a 100/10! The best of the best. The drinks took like 50 minutes to come out and the waitress brought us free garlic bread for the wait which was the sweetest thing ever. I will definitely be back! The service was so kind and the food was lovely.

Jennie Williams

Becky Sosa

Authentic Italian food. The owner was so genuine. He obviously has a passion for this type of work. He states he imports the flour from Italy. Pasta and focaccia bread is made in house. I am gluten free and I decided to eat the bread as he stated that the flour was from Italy…. No bloat & no discomfort! I had the grouper special and my mom had the porca puttena pasta which was incredible!!

Natalia Vorobyeva

Best pizza I’ve ever had!! The place welcomes you with cozy atmosphere and attentive service only adds to the experience. I’ve had pepperoni jalapeño and it left me absolutely speechless: perfect combination of home-made red sauce, high quality cheese blend, and other ingredients. Highly recommend to add a Greek salad to your order, they also have plenty of other vegetarian and gluten free options. Definitely will be back many more times with my friends and family!

Jane Maltby

We loved this restaurant! Fun atmosphere and great food! I’m gluten free and they still had choices for me. Ask for Stefan, he will take care of you. Thank you, Stefan!

Lucinda Stokes

Tina B

We have been enjoying the food at Della Nonna's for a few years now and have always been impressed with the fresh quality, portions and variety of options. The new menu now has plant based, gluten free, vegan cheese options! We are ecstatic. They also offer delivery and we could not be more excited to keep enjoying their delicious options. Today we had the meatball pasta and a custom gluten free crust pizza with vegan cheese and multiple toppings. Everything tasted perfect, well cooked and fresh ingredients. This is a hole in the wall location with amazing selections, long time owner who will go out of his way to help you get the entree how you want it and never lets us down. Thank you!

Gaston Dixon

Jady Mendes

Omg! Im in love with pastas and also gluten free pizza, it’s a good try!

Anne Pontiff

Tina B

An empanada lover's happy place! We first met the Empanada Girl at the Lakewood Ranch farmer's market at Waterside. Stefania was the kindest food cart person we had met as she worked the orders and also took the time to chat with us and go over how she came to this fantastic gluten free and plant based recipes. We ordered one of each and honestly loved them all! They are each stamped on the crust with the type and come frozen or you can order one on the spot to be heated up. Stefania shared that she sold her items out of her then parent's store Peperonata Pasta Store. Well fast forward to today, we saw her in person working the store with her little one Ari! She chatted with us about taking on the store from her family and carrying on the tradition of their family and her amazing empanadas. Tips for ordering if you want them warm, call ahead! They take about 15 mins to warm but it's always fun to sit in their cute eatery and meet others who come thru the store. So many regulars and newbies like us! They carry an amazing amount of homemade items including pastas, sauces, desserts, and branded items. Definitely stop by this store and support this wonderful family owned business and their growing family! Thank you Stefania and crew we'll be back!

Carley May

Can’t rave about this place enough. Best gluten free pizza I have ever had!! Service is excellent and it’s always a pleasure coming here. Thank you for what you do!! :)))

Erica Heitke

Wonderful environment and so cute! Always great service and we have enjoyed both listening to live music here and using the Loft! Great food and they always meet my gluten-free and no sugar added needs. Love the charcuterie board with salami, prosciutto, & goat cheese!

Burke LaShell

One of my favorite meals ever! Delicious! Good gluten free options.

Nero Hameed

I can't rave enough about Joey Dee's Pizzeria! This place truly deserves all the praise it gets. First off, the atmosphere is incredible. As soon as you step through the door, you're greeted with the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza. The vibrant decor and energetic music immediately transport you to the lively streets of Chicago. It's a perfect setting for a memorable dining experience. And let's talk about the food! Joey Dee's Pizzeria serves some of the most delectable pizza I have ever tasted. The crust is perfectly crispy on the outside and delightfully chewy on the inside. Each slice is piled high with the freshest ingredients, from the flavorsome tomato sauce to the generous amount of gooey cheese. The menu offers a wide range of toppings to choose from, ensuring there's something to satisfy everyone's craving. But their pizza isn't the only star here. The menu also boasts an array of tantalizing appetizers, mouthwatering pasta dishes, and oh-so-decadent desserts. The buffalo wings are packed with flavor and have just the right amount of heat. The lasagna is a heavenly combination of layers of rich, meaty sauce and perfectly cooked pasta. And as for the desserts, the tiramisu is an absolute must-try. It's velvety, creamy, and simply divine. The service at Joey Dee's Pizzeria deserves special mention as well. The staff is incredibly friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the menu. They are always ready to offer recommendations and make sure that every customer leaves with a smile on their face. Furthermore, Joey Dee's Pizzeria goes above and beyond to provide a comfortable and inclusive dining experience. They offer a variety of options for dietary restrictions, including gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese. It's heartwarming to see a place that caters to all food lovers, ensuring that everyone can indulge in their incredible dishes. In conclusion, Joey Dee's Pizzeria is a hidden gem that will satisfy even the most discerning pizza aficionados. From the inviting atmosphere to the mouthwatering food and exceptional service, it truly delivers a dining experience like no other. Whether you're looking to enjoy a cozy meal with family and friends or grab a quick slice on the go, make sure to pay Joey Dee's Pizzeria a visit. You won't be disappointed!

Kristina “Tina” Peters

Had a dinner to-go order. Added an order of bruschetta when I arrived. The to-go hostess was incredibly friendly and helpful! I was pleasantly surprised at how quickly the order was ready, especially since the bruschetta was added last minute! The bruschetta was Absolutely delicious as was the Gluten-free Margherita pizza!

Max Eisenberg

Good restaurant. Wish they would add gluten-free pasta and pizza for my wife.