Carnegie Diner & Cafe

So friendly. Walked in and felt like family. My waiter was very helpful navigating GF for me.

I am newly diagnosed and went here multiple times because they have gluten free items marked and it’s just easier when you’re looking for a late night snack after a Broadway show. On my third visit, I mentioned to the waitress that I had celiacs (which I had done on my prior visits as well) and she said that she would double check my order for me even though everything was labeled gluten-free. Well, thank God for this waitress who took the time to check. The waitstaff/kitchen on this visit told me that the menu was labeled incorrectly, and a lot of the things that were labeled gluten-free weren’t actually gluten-free. They were able to whip something together for me, but it’s insane that their menu is incorrect. And another waiter on my prior visit gave me attitude when I asked about the gluten-free food and said that if it was labeled gluten-free, it would be gluten-free. Be careful with this place!

Excellent experience, food quality, and customer service. We had a group reservation for a student trip (25+ people). Everything from the reservation process, advanced payment, communication, servers, food quality, and accommodations made for a positive and seamless experience. Additionally, the kitchen was able to easily accommodate gluten free options. Atmosphere was clean and comfortable. Highly recommend.