Cenarios of Cordelia is great. It's a locally owned shop. The pizza is really well done and they even have a gluten free offering. Inside they have both and "bar" (although I dont think they serve hard liquor, just beer and wine) seating and there is usually a ball game on the t.v..
We order several pizzas from them every year for our business, Revolution Martial Arts, at the end of summer and it's always a big hit! We order a couple days ahead and they're always hot and ready to pick up when we arrive. It's not only a big hit with the kids, the parents like it too! We always get asked where we purchased it from because they are impressed with the flavor, and we always say Cenarios of Cordelia.