My wife and I stopped in today. This is a fantastic little spot with some of the best gluten-free crust I have. What was really impressive is that the Clerk asked me right away if it was an allergy or preference and how careful of cross-contamination they should be.
I ordered a gluten-free crust with the Island BBQ, you can have your gluten-free crust made as any of their house specialties or as a build your own. My wife ordered a regular great white.
Both pizzas were amazing. The gluten-free crust was thin and crispy. With just the right amount of bake, the pizza was so good I ate the whole 12" pie in one sitting. My wife's Great White was also perfectly cooked with a light and chewy crust like you would expect in a little corner shop in Brooklyn.
What was extra special, was the staff. Their care and concern was appreciated as well as their friendly conversation. My family and I are in NSB often and will definitely be back.
Update: We were back yesterday and noticed a goat cheese, honey and peaches. You read that right peaches. Now you may have an opinion on pineapple on pizza but this is a must try. The mixture of savory and sweet is unrivaled.
This spot puts a lot of effort into their regular pizzas but also comes up with some incredible flavor combos.
Also a large shout out to their Ceasar dressing. We think it is made in the shop and if it isn't please don't tell me.