Horatio's Homemade Ice Cream

The BEST Ice Cream I’ve Ever Had — Hands Down! If you’re anywhere near Custer, South Dakota and don’t stop at Horatio’s Homemade Ice Cream… you are seriously missing out. I’ve had a lot of ice cream in my life, but NOTHING compares to this place. It’s in a league of its own. Now here’s the twist — I recently had to go dairy-free AND gluten-free, and I was bracing for a life of sad, flavorless “alternatives.” But Horatio’s proved me wrong in the most delicious way possible. Their dairy-free and gluten-free options aren’t just “good for being dairy-free”… they’re just plain amazing. Creamy, rich, packed with flavor — you’d never know they’re allergen-friendly. You can tell this place puts heart and soul into every scoop. The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is cozy and charming, and the quality is out of this world. This isn’t just dessert — it’s an experience. Trust me: whether you’re a classic cone lover or navigating dietary needs like I am, Horatio’s is the place to go. Don’t walk — RUN. 🍦✨

Great ice cream. Knowledgeable about gluten free / celiac. I got an ice cream Sunday and it was pretty good. Fairly priced and walkable area, it was nice to walk around after dinner with a little dessert.