View all

New Bethel Ordinary

Pizza restaurant

$$ • Gluten-free options

Delivery

Kid Friendly

Lunch

Take Away

This casual spot offers a homey, small-town vibe with a small bar perfect for unwinding. Known for its exceptional gluten-free cauliflower crust, it caters thoughtfully to gluten allergies, ensuring a welcoming and accommodating atmosphere for those with dietary needs.

164 joined today

View menu

8838 Southeastern Ave, Wanamaker, IN 46239, USA

2.4km

People are saying

Gordon Lewis

Stopped off the interstate. Looking for the drink to unwind and stumbled upon this bar. Pizzas look great. We tried the gluten-free crust. Surprisingly very good gluten free , cauliflower, crust... Also recommend the sausage (crumbled) topping on a pizza.. If you like a hundred cheese with your pizza, basil has the seasoning in your sauce, and high quality ingredients, you'll love the pizza too.

Jenifer Meyer

We just dined in at New Bethel Ordinary and had a wonderful experience. Our three kids were more than a bit unruly and Elizabeth was wonderful with them. She took song requests from our 11 year old and completely made her day. My boyfriend and I both have gluten allergies and he forgot to mention “no croutons” on his salad and she caught it and left them off. She had great suggestions for us. Highly recommend this place, and ask for Elizabeth… you won’t be disappointed!