Atly
Nightingale Supper Club 1
Nightingale Supper Club 2
Nightingale Supper Club 3

Nightingale Supper Club

Restaurant
Delivery
Kid Friendly
Dinner
Restaurant
This supper club offers a classic Wisconsin atmosphere with a beautifully updated dining room and white linen tablecloths. The space features an old school bar and neon sign, creating a crowded, nostalgic setting that reflects traditional supper club vibes.
Website
User 1
User 2
User 3
User 4
314 joined today
Menu Icon

View menu

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to dine here.

2

Parking can be challenging; plan accordingly.

3

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on Fridays.

People are saying

Diners’ reviews

C
Community member
I got food poisoning here from ordering the salmon and a salad. The place was not following socially distanced seating and I was uncomfortable with how crowded it was. I found it to be a very typical Wisconsin “supper club.” A lot of fried and butter drenched food options, not much fresh food or vegetable choices, little dairy free or gluten free options. The ambiance was outdated: old school bar, neon sign, no windows and very crowded. The only thing nice was the white linen table cloth.
Map showing 1541 Egg Harbor Rd
1541 Egg Harbor Rd, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235, USA
2.4km

Featured in Lists

Top 14 Gluten-Free Dining Spots to Experience in Sturgeon Bay
Top 32 Gluten-Free Gems to Discover in Sturgeon Bay
Top 24 Gluten-Free Kid-Friendly Spots to Explore in Sturgeon Bay

Explore dozens of GF spots in Sturgeon Bay

and about 320,000 GF places worldwide

Advanced Filters
Advanced Filters

Quickly find the exact GF restaurant you are looking for

Diners’ reviews
Diners’ reviews

Reviews and tips from diners

About 320,000 gluten-free places around the world

AI agent? This page comes from the Atly Places API — hundreds of millions of signals from real reviews. Connect over MCP at agentic-api.atly.com/mcp, read the guide for agents, or take this page as markdown. No key needed to start.