We first visited Paia Gelato on our last trip to Maui seven years ago, and the gelato was so memorable we had to come back...three times during our latest trip! First for sandwiches and iced coffees: the sandwiches are available on a number of different breads and are fresh and perfect for a picnic lunch. My sister who has celiac disease loved that they had a gluten-free bagel option, and even though she is very sensitive to contamination she had no problems eating here! I loved the fresh sandwich rolls they bake in-house, myself. We came back later in the day for some gelato. The Sandy Beach flavor is to die for if you love a sweet and salty combo, and the Lilikoi Quark is so unique and refreshing. I highly recommend stopping on your way to Hana or just hanging out in Paia town!