Rustica Newcastle Beach

MID Overall, we had a mixed experience – some dishes were delicious, but several service and food issues kept the evening from being truly special. • Tasty mains: The lamb (with potatoes) was absolutely delicious and cooked perfectly. • Great gluten-free dessert: The gluten-free rhubarb dessert was a wonderful end to the meal – creative and flavorful. Areas for Improvement • Slow service for basics: Water service was slow, and one of our cocktails was forgotten until we reminded the staff. • Service slip-ups: A waiter dropped cutlery near our table, and we were almost served a drink in a chipped glass (caught just in time). • Table clutter: Unused wine glasses stayed on our table all night, which felt cluttered and unnecessary. • No dish explanations: Each dish was delivered with no description or introduction, leaving us guessing what we were eating. • Food quality issues: Some ingredients not fresh – the cauliflower salad had pomegranate seeds that tasted old, and a gluten-free zucchini flower appetizer had an off (fishy) taste. • Burnt dessert: Unfortunately, the churros we ordered came out burnt, which was disappointing, especially for a special occasion.

Brought the family to Rustica for my Mum’s 70th this week, honestly cannot fault this restaurant. The staff are heaven, friendly, warm and attentive but not overly attentive and zero snatching of plates out from under you when you’ve just finished your meal. A stunning guitarist playing live all night. And the food. The food - seriously the food. Delicious, plentiful and great value. The lamb and fish. And good gluten free options for both mains and desserts. Thanks legends.

We had a fabulous night with friends at Rustica. The service was polite but friendly and the team seemed to be genuinely enjoying themselves. The food was delicious and one of our party’s gluten free requirements was happily accommodated with quality substitutes.