Real NY style pizza is hard to find out here west of the Pecos, and I'm one of those boomer food snobs. [I cooked in upscale restaurants when I was young]. Amazingly, I was really impressed. Excellent thin crust with high gluten flour. A+ on that. Just mozzarella and pepperoni, but good quality. Very little sauce, I would have liked enough to taste it. Served piping hot, a rare thing. Pizza overall 8+. But what a deal! During happy hour (2:30 to 5:30), I had 2 slices of pepperoni and a nice craft beer, all for $9! (Tivoli lager is $2/pint during happy hour). I doubt there is anywhere else in Old town with a deal this good. One note, we went around the block two times trying to find it. Problem is the sign is small, freestyle, and I couldn't read it, even from 10 feet away. The ambience is basic, I would have liked a couple of aging mafiosi lurking in the corners.They need a big sign with red letters saying "Hot NY Mafia Style Pizza!" I highly recommend this college vibe hole in the wall.