Tillies

I'm on a girl's trip and we wanted to have a nice meal. We weren't able to make a reservation but were able to immediately get a table inside or on the beach without a wait at around 7:20 pm on a Saturday. The beach and atmosphere were really great. The service was very infrequent. By the time anyone came over, it had been probably 20 minutes of sitting with the menus. Then he only took our food order and wanted to come back to take our drink order. So, some more waiting happened. Bread arrived and it was incredible! Really soft rolls with soft butter and some other thing that was never explained (but was delicious). The waiter did make a great recommendation for the popular fish Milanese but he also implied that french fries came with the steak burger, but that was in fact not the case. The french fries were an additional $8.75. The food and drinks arrived quickly and together so we didn't get to enjoy our cocktails. The food was REALLY good and we were all happy with our dishes. Then came dessert... One of the main reasons we chose this place was they are a gluten free friendly place and they had an amazing looking desert: miso caramel sundae with gluten free brownie. We ordered it and it was a mountain of mediocre vanilla ice cream that seems like it was pre scooped and sat in the freezer. On top were a few brownie pieces, a small caramel drizzle (tasty!), and quinoa crunch (very tasty!). The ratios were very off and after eating all the toppings with the ice cream we were left with so much ice cream that we just left behind. All in all the food was really great, they were accommodating of celiac, the atmosphere was lovely, the dessert was disappointing, and the service was kind but infrequent at best, frequently leaving us waiting for someone to notice us. We were there for 2+ hours, and we got dinner and drinks (at the same time) and a dessert to share.

Gorgeous restaurant and the vibes are amazing! Food was DELICIOUS and they have wonderful gluten free options!!

Wow! Tillie's is a swanky beachside gem that truly delivers an unforgettable experience. We went just for dessert and were absolutely blown away. The Gluten-Free Coconut Cake was divine, but the real showstopper was the Baked Alaska—a spectacle like no other! The vibe exudes Caribbean beachside luxury, and the genuine, friendly service made it even more memorable. Tillie’s is a must-visit for anyone looking to treat themselves to a slice of paradise.