Arrenello's Pizza Highland
7.6 • Pizza restaurant
Pizza restaurant offers only carry-out service with long wait times often exceeding an hour. Atmosphere is minimal, focusing on fresh ingredients and sweet pizza sauce that sets it apart. Busy periods reveal capacity challenges affecting speed and consistency.
View menu
"I always loved their amazing deep dish pizza."
30
"I considered this thin crust pizza the best pizza in NWI."
8
"I drove 25 minutes for this pizza takeout, and it's worth it."
8
Good to know
1
Arrenello's Pizza Highland only offers carry-out service.
2
Expect wait times of 40-90 minutes for pizza orders.
3
Credit card payments incur additional processing fees compared to cash.
2556 45th St, Highland, Indiana, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Squigi's Pizza of Highland
Family-owned pizzeria known for hand-tossed, thin and deep dish crusts with a flavorful red sauce.
Best Buy
Clean, quiet store with gorgeous washer and dryer displays and convenient curbside pickup.
Domino's Pizza
Budget-friendly pizza spot known for low prices but criticized for small sauce portions and poor maintenance.
