Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Indiana

Deep dish pizza

You want a deep-dish pizza that respects the structural integrity of the crust and the depth of the toppings.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Venice Pizza image 1
Venice Pizza image 2
Venice Pizza image 3
View all
Pizza restaurant

Old school building creates a cozy, peaceful atmosphere with a friendly, Christian-focused vibe. Deep dish pan pizza and scratch-made dough and sauce highlight quality and care. Prices stay reasonable while serving some of the best pizza around, especially for party sizes.

Thick, filling slices come with a Chicago-style crust and generous pepperoni topping. The deep dish pizza offers a rich, satisfying flavor that stands out from typical pies.

Deep dish pizza stands out with a thick crust loaded with sausage, pepperoni, fresh garlic, and green peppers. Every pizza offers consistent quality and comes with friendly, last-minute service even near closing time.

People are saying

"The deep dish pizza here is amazing, especially the cheesy, crispy crust."

"The staff here are so friendly, they even gave my son candy."

"I thought the pizza here was amazingly delicious."

Good to know

1

Venice Pizza offers some of the lowest prices in town.

2

The pizza is made with high-quality ingredients and from scratch.

3

There is ample parking available for customers.

02
Jet's Pizza image 1
Pizza delivery

Cramped space fills with heat and lively energy, creating a chill and welcoming atmosphere. Frequented for fresh, crispy Detroit style pizza with carefully weighed ingredients, it draws a diverse crowd seeking quick, efficient service despite limited seating.

Square cheese pepperoni and Detroit style deep dish pizzas come fresh with pepperoni, Italian sausage, mushrooms, onions, and jalapenos.

Detroit style pizza stands out with its thick, crunchy crust and well-done edges. Options like the four corner pizza mix toppings such as hamburger, mushroom, and onion, delivering a flavorful and filling meal with fast, fresh preparation.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was great and flavorful."

"The food here is delicious and served quickly."

"I loved their deep dish pizza; it was surprisingly tasty."

Good to know

1

Jet's Pizza offers a unique text message ordering system.

2

Delivery is available through DoorDash.

3

The restaurant does not offer dine-in service.

03
Edwardo's Natural Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small, quaint space with a cozy, relaxed atmosphere and terrific background music. The vibe feels like a trip back in time with a slightly dated interior. Known for excellent deep dish pizza, it offers a calm break from the outside world.

Unique Chicago-style deep dish pizza features fresh ingredients and a distinct taste. Orders can be placed ahead by phone to have the pizza ready on arrival.

Deep dish pizza stands out with its stuffed spinach and Spicy Buffalo Chicken varieties. Orders come ready on arrival, always hot and delicious, embodying the true Chicago-style experience.

People are saying

"This deep dish pizza is worth the wait."

"The stuffed pizza is a cheese lover's heaven."

"I thought Edwardo's Natural Pizza served the best pizza in town."

Good to know

1

Parents with children who have nut allergies should avoid dining here.

2

The entrance is not made for people using mobility devices.

3

It would be difficult for a lone diner with a mobility device to get in.

04
The Original Noble Roman's image 1

Interior preserves 1980s design with arcade machines and a rocking jukebox creating a nostalgic vibe. Atmosphere stays quiet and cozy, appealing to those who appreciate an old-school pizza experience. Salad bar and deep dish pizza add to the classic feel.

Deep dish crust cooks perfectly with just enough cheese and sauce to complement the toppings. Large Sicilian style pizzas come with customizable toppings and pair well with the salad bar.

Roman-style pizza features cheese on top and comes freshly made to order. Large deep dish Sicilian pizzas with customizable toppings are available, often paired with a salad bar for a special pizza night.

People are saying

"I remembered this pizza from the early 90s and it felt authentic."

"The salad bar here is awesome and always well stocked."

"I found the deep dish pizza to be the best."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials offer 4-5 options for $10, providing good value.

2

The restaurant operates on a counter service model; order first, then sit.

3

The medium cheese pizza costs around $17.

05
Graham's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Family-style restaurant with basic atmosphere and relaxed vibe where children often run freely. Menu features deep dish and hand-tossed pizzas with a focus on unique sauce flavors. Prices range from reasonable to slightly high, with options for dine-in, call-in, or online ordering.

Deep dish pizzas come loaded with sausage, pepperoni, tomatoes, and jalapeรฑos. The crust is thick and hearty, offering a full topping experience that pairs well with wings.

Deep dish specialty pizza stands out with sausage, pepperoni, tomatoes, and jalapeรฑos. The hand-tossed pepperoni and thin crust veggie pizzas also deliver consistent, very good flavors.

People are saying

"This pizza is the best I've ever had."

"The food here is always hot and fresh."

"I thought the deep dish pizza was top notch."

Good to know

1

You can order online, call in, or dine in.

2

Ranch is available as a sauce even though it isn't listed on the menu.

3

The prices are reasonable for everything ordered.

06
Noble Roman's Craft Pizza & Pub image 1

Bright dining room with many TVs shows sports and retro cartoons. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, with glass-view pizza making adding to the experience. Regulars enjoy cozy tall booths and a salad bar alongside cold beer and pizza.

Deep dish Sicilian style pizza comes hot and fresh with options like Alfredo sauce and added spinach. Medium sizes are common, and the crust stands out as a favorite.

Artisan pizza comes out hot and fresh with a delicious taste. Staff provide attentive service and the pizza cook does an extremely great job.

People are saying

"Gabriel was so personable and attentive when he served our pizza."

"The salad bar is always fresh with lots of options."

"This deep dish pizza is hot, fresh, and delicious."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs daily from 4-6pm with specials on drinks and appetizers.

2

The restaurant is handicap accessible for those with mobility needs.

3

A side salad costs $4, while the salad bar is available for $11.

07
Ale Emporium image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant combines live music with multiple sports screens visible from nearly every seat. The loud, energetic atmosphere suits game watching but can make conversation challenging, especially on the climate-controlled patio. Tables sit close together, creating a cozy yet crowded feel.

Deep dish pizza comes with boneless chicken wings and breadsticks. The deep dish is legendary and always satisfying.

Deep dish pizza stands out with its satisfying thickness and consistent quality. Wings come in perfectly cooked styles, including boneless and Hermanaki, pairing well with the superb pizza offerings.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was really good."

"I found the pizza here truly incredible."

"I found the deep dish pizza always satisfied me."

Good to know

1

Parking can be tough on gamedays as the place gets crowded.

2

Expect a wait during game nights, especially on weekends.

3

DMB drink specials are available before the Dave Matthews Band show.

08
Arrenello's Pizza Highland image 1

Pizza restaurant offers only carry-out service with long wait times often exceeding an hour. Atmosphere is minimal, focusing on fresh ingredients and sweet pizza sauce that sets it apart. Busy periods reveal capacity challenges affecting speed and consistency.

Chicago style deep dish pizza comes loaded with delicious ingredients and offers an amazing taste experience. Both deep dish and thin crust options satisfy consistently.

Pizza features a sweet sauce that stands out from typical recipes. Stuffed pizzas, especially with spinach, offer a rich and satisfying option. Consistency and quality remain strong across all locations, making it a frequent craving.

People are saying

"I always loved their amazing deep dish pizza."

"I considered this thin crust pizza the best pizza in NWI."

"I thought this pizza was the best in town."

Good to know

1

Arrenello's Pizza Highland only offers carry-out service.

2

Expect wait times of 40-90 minutes for pizza orders.

3

Credit card payments incur additional processing fees compared to cash.

09
Rosati's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Pizza restaurant offers cozy atmosphere with intimate lighting and a family-friendly environment. Guests often enjoy watching games with a beer while waiting. The place feels clean and quiet, creating a relaxed vibe.

Deep dish pizzas come hot and neatly prepared with a packed filling. Both deep dish and thin crust options exist, but quality can vary from satisfying to disappointing.

Pizza features a thin crust with a balanced amount of cheese and toppings. Sauce is not overly sweet, and sausage stands out as a common topping. Consistency and timely delivery are notable.

People are saying

"Amy's great service makes the pizza experience top notch."

"The takeout food is always fresh, hot, and delicious."

"I loved the Deep Dish pizza with its chunks of sausage and lots of tomato."

Good to know

1

Expect a 20-minute wait for pickup orders, which is usually faster than delivery.

2

Gluten-free pizza options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

3

The restaurant offers a rewards program that provides discounts and special offers.

10
Giordano's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Spacious dining area with clean, modern ambiance and lots of TVs showing sports creates a family-friendly atmosphere. Outdoor seating adds to the inviting vibe, while the pace is relaxed enough to accommodate the 45-minute deep dish pizza preparation. The setting balances casual comfort with a touch of chic style.

Stuffed deep dish pizza features a second layer of dough that adds thickness and richness. The Chicago-style classic comes with pepper and sausage, delivering a hearty, authentic experience.

Chicago classic deep dish pizza stands out with its gooey cheese and rich stuffing. The pizza consistently delivers excellent flavor and a satisfying experience.

People are saying

"This deep dish pizza has a flaky, buttery crust and legendary cheese pull."

"I thought the deep dish pizza was the best."

"I thought the salad was good."

Good to know

1

Lunch meals cost about $11 from 1 pm to 4 pm.

2

Deep dish pizza requires 45 minutes to cook, so plan accordingly.

3

Expect a wait time of up to 2.5 hours during peak hours.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...