Bagel Boss East
5.3 • Bagel shop
Bagel shop offers organized chaos with a comfortable, friendly atmosphere and coffee bar alongside seating. Bagels range from crispy and fluffy to occasionally raw, reflecting varied quality. Crowds gather early but lines are rare at opening.
View menu
"These bagels are fresh, crispy, and fluffy."
75
"Their breakfast bagels and coffee are great."
8
"Kristin was so patient and helpful with my mom's egg allergy."
6
Good to know
1
Expect to pay around $20 for a dozen bagels.
2
The eat-in area often has cleanliness issues, with sticky tables and dirty high chairs.
3
Takeout orders frequently do not include napkins.
555 Montauk Hwy, Bay Shore, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Dairy City Supermarket
Quaint mom-and-pop market known for its excellent deli meats and fresh products, offering quick checkout and fair prices.
Cornerstone Deli
Hidden gem deli run by a proud family, offering outstanding, generous portions at great prices.
Sunrise Bagel
Friendly, quiet deli offering a great selection of fresh bagels, muffins, and hot foods with reasonable prices.
