My Sugar Pie
8.6 • Pie shop
Pie shop offers large menu with traditional and unique flavors including standout sugar cream and fruit pies. Interior feels cramped and cluttered with new display cases, while seating is available inside and outside. Prices are high, but pies come with reusable dishes and occasional deals.
View menu
"I thought your sugar cream pie was one of the yummiest slices I've ever had."
15
"I thought the American food, especially the apple pie, was the best I ever ate."
9
"I thought the apple pie was the best I ever tasted."
7
Good to know
1
The price for a whole pie is $47, while a slice costs $7.
2
They offer a $3.14 Pie Day deal for trying multiple flavors.
3
Whipped cream is provided separately upon pick-up.
40 E Pine St, Zionsville, Indiana, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
