Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Indiana

Pie shops

Made for those who insist that a slice of pie is the only acceptable conclusion to an American meal.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Aberdeen Social House image 1
Aberdeen Social House image 2
Aberdeen Social House image 3
View all

Upscale restaurant offers a mid-century modern vibe with curated artwork and thoughtful architectural details. Outdoor patio provides a comfortable, zen atmosphere ideal for leisurely dining. The space balances swanky and welcoming energy, attracting those who appreciate quality and style.

Seafood and Grits stands out as a rich, flavorful dish. The Smoked Brisket Grilled Cheese offers a smoky twist on a classic, and the lobster truffle mac and cheese adds a decadent touch to the menu.

Banana cream pie stands out with its unique flavor and is a popular dessert choice. Steak and mushroom pie comes with gravy and mashed potatoes, making it a well-rounded meal option.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is phenomenal and packed with flavor."

"I'm already planning my next visit for more pie."

"The American food, like the grilled cheese, was delicious."

Good to know

1

The menu changes frequently with local ingredients prepared by a creative culinary team.

2

Expect higher prices for unique dishes and elevated dining experiences.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekends and special occasions.

02
Ben's BBQ Shack image 1
Barbecue restaurant

BBQ shack with picnic tables out back offers a takeout-only experience that requires preordering due to quick sellouts. The atmosphere feels welcoming as the owner interacts directly with customers. Known for top-quality smoked meats, especially brisket and ribs, that stand out without heavy sauce.

Pulled pork and brisket stand out for their perfect juiciness and high quality. Ribs and turkey also come tender and flavorful with a slight kick.

Buttermilk pie stands out as a sweet treat. The pie tastes delicious and is great to save for later.

People are saying

"This brisket is perfectly cooked and so moist."

"The American Food here, especially the brisket and ribs, is perfectly cooked and smoky."

"I've never had such juicy, fall-off-the-bone ribs."

Good to know

1

Ben's BBQ Shack is only open from Friday to Sunday, 12 PM to 3 PM.

2

Preordering is essential to avoid missing out on popular items like brisket.

3

Arrive at least 30 minutes before opening if you don't preorder.

03
Dean's Steak & Seafood Indianapolis image 1

Elegant dining space combines warm decor with luxurious atmosphere and live DJ music, creating a vibrant yet intimate setting. Guests enjoy top-tier steaks and seafood alongside expertly crafted cocktails, making it a standout for high-end dining experiences.

Wagyu pot roast and New York Strip deliver rich, flavorful American dishes. Desserts like key lime pie and cheesecake with blueberry compote stand out as well.

Key lime pie stands out as a signature dessert, often praised for its flavor. The cheesecake with blueberry compote also draws attention for its rich taste and texture.

People are saying

"The steak here is amazing and perfectly cooked."

"The American Food here is great, thanks to D.J.'s amazing service."

"I highly recommend the key lime pie; it's the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The private dining room is available for hosting events.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers during conventions.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

04
Bakes of Carmel image 1

Bakery showcases beautifully decorated cakes and party-ready cupcakes with buttercream icing that impress both kids and adults. Atmosphere feels festive and custom orders are handled efficiently with clear storage instructions. Dedication to quality and artistry stands out in every item.

Apple pie stands out with a nostalgic, rich flavor. Pecan pie offers a decadent, sweet experience. Pumpkin and butterscotch pies add variety with their delicious tastes.

Apple and pecan pies stand out for their rich, nostalgic flavors. Butterscotch pie appears as a special, off-menu treat made fresh on request. Pies arrive beautifully presented and are ready on time.

People are saying

"The cake here is amazing and beautifully decorated."

"The pie here is delicious and tasted amazing."

"The American Food pies here are a smash hit, especially the pecan and apple."

Good to know

1

Bakes of Carmel can accommodate custom cake orders with short notice.

2

Cakes are packaged securely for easy transport to events.

3

They provide clear instructions on how to store and serve cakes.

05
Marilyn's Bakery image 1

Warm aroma fills a clean, inviting space with freshly baked treats and detailed custom cakes that impress visually and in taste. The atmosphere balances consistent quality with special occasion craftsmanship, attracting those seeking memorable desserts.

Blueberry pie and Chicken pot pie stand out as classic American dishes here. Pumpkin pie from Marilyn's Bakery also features as a notable dessert option.

Cherry pie shines in small sizes with freshness and great taste. Coconut cream, chocolate, blueberry, pumpkin, and chicken pot pies also show consistent quality and flavor.

People are saying

"They brought my vision to life with an incredible custom cake."

"I found the pies here to be fresh and tasty."

"You have to try their blueberry and pumpkin pies."

Good to know

1

Prices at the bakery are generally high, costing $$$$.

2

The bakery often runs out of popular items like brisket, soup, and quiche.

3

Custom cake orders require clear specifications to avoid mistakes.

06
Don't Eat The Bone Bbq image 1
Barbecue restaurant

Barbecue spot with a casual setup featuring picnic tables near the smoker and a small waiting area. Atmosphere stays friendly and laid-back, attracting those who appreciate extremely smoky barbecue and hearty sandwiches. Limited open days create a sense of exclusivity around the experience.

Pulled pork stands out with its flavorful meat packed on a sub-sized bun. Mac and cheese, especially the 5 cheese macaroni, scores perfectly alongside green beans, baked beans, and rib tips.

Chess pie stands out with a rich, sweet flavor that draws strong recommendations and lively reactions. Sweet Potato Pie offers a delicious, unique taste that complements the selection well.

People are saying

"The BBQ turkey tips and rib tips were so tender."

"I found the Mac and Cheese to be awesome and satisfying."

"The American food, especially the rib tips, is smokey, moist, and well-seasoned."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is only open about three days a week.

2

Expect a wait but it is worth it.

3

They were out of chicken wings by 1 PM for the day.

07
My Sugar Pie image 1
Pie shop

Pie shop offers large menu with traditional and unique flavors including standout sugar cream and fruit pies. Interior feels cramped and cluttered with new display cases, while seating is available inside and outside. Prices are high, but pies come with reusable dishes and occasional deals.

Apple pie features an insane cobbler top and a perfect amount of spice. Adding vanilla ice cream on top enhances the flavor.

Sugar cream pie stands out with a rich, creamy texture that many find amazing. Traditional flavors like apple pie with a spiced cobbler top and peach pie with fresh, juicy slices also impress with their delicious crusts and fillings.

People are saying

"I thought your sugar cream pie was one of the yummiest slices I've ever had."

"I thought the American food, especially the apple pie, was the best I ever ate."

"I thought the apple pie was the best I ever tasted."

Good to know

1

The price for a whole pie is $47, while a slice costs $7.

2

They offer a $3.14 Pie Day deal for trying multiple flavors.

3

Whipped cream is provided separately upon pick-up.

08
The Kitchen on Main image 1

Small town restaurant with retro decor and a speakeasy bar in the back creates a cozy, chill vibe. Atmosphere shifts from relaxed and friendly in the dining area to lively and loud in the speakeasy. Live jazz music adds to the unique, old-school diner feel.

Desserts like Key Lime Pie, Tiramisu, and pecan pie come with a scoop of ice cream. The menu includes classic American dishes such as grilled cheese with tomato basil soup, cheeseburgers, chicken tenders, mac 'n cheese, and tenderloin.

Pecan pie comes with a perfect scoop of ice cream. Blueberry pie and Nashville Wrap stand out as fantastic choices. Key Lime Pie and Tiramisu get strong praise from the group.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is delicious, especially the Smash burger."

"I thought this place was really cool to chill."

"The American food, like the tenderloin and smash burger, is fantastic."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

The restaurant features a hidden speakeasy in the back for a unique experience.

3

Expect longer wait times during dinner hours, especially on weekends.

09
His Place Eatery - Chicken & Waffles, Ribs & Soul Food (86th & Ditch Rd) image 1

Soul food restaurant offers a clean, bright interior with crowded seating that feels lively and homey. Music and a quirky photo booth add to the welcoming vibe despite some noise from guests. The space balances an upscale design with a casual, packed atmosphere.

Fried chicken and fried catfish come hot and fresh, paired well with sides like mac and cheese and mashed potatoes. Meatloaf, brisket, and chicken pot pie offer hearty, classic American flavors with touches like smoked brisket and extra cornbread.

Peach pie comes with ice cream and stands out for its flavor. Fried chicken pot pie offers a rich, savory experience. Bourbon pecan pie serves as a sweet ending to the meal.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the mac and cheese, is amazing."

"I took the banana pudding to go, it was excellent."

"The fried chicken pot pie's puff pastry was crispy and melt-in-your-mouth."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of about 5 minutes during peak dinner hours.

2

The kitchen may close 15-20 minutes before the posted closing time.

3

Desserts often sell out by 7pm on Fridays, so arrive early.

10
Tipsy Mermaid Conch House & Cocktails image 1

Bright, clean space with coastal decor and a tropical vibe creates a laid-back yet sophisticated atmosphere. Crowds and lively music contribute to a noisy, energetic environment. Regulars enjoy Key West style touches and inventive cocktails that stand out.

Surf and turf tacos feature tender and juicy steak. Seafood options include a warm lobster roll loaded with crab and lobster on a toasted roll. Sides like Gruyรจre grits and appetizers such as Cuban cigars complement the menu. Key lime pie serves as a notable dessert.

Creamy and perfectly balanced, the Key lime pie stands out with its tart flavor and fresh whipped cream topping. It arrives nicely cut and plated, with quick availability even without the usual 24-hour notice.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here feel like a vacation to the Florida Keys."

"You have to try the American Food lobster rolls; they're bursting with crab and lobster."

"I saved room for their famous, creamy key lime pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, leading to potential wait times of about 30 minutes.

2

Happy hour features half-price signature cocktails and $2 oysters.

3

A kid-friendly brunch is available on Saturdays and Sundays.

11
FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale image 1
American restaurant

Exposed plaster, lathe, and old brickwork create an eclectic, cozy setting with heated indoor patio and rooftop dining options. The atmosphere stays laid back and inviting, suitable for conversations without raising voices. A huge full bar offers variety, drawing groups to cozy tables upstairs.

Biscuits and gravy stand out, especially at brunch. The menu also features crab cakes, bone marrow fries, and a variety of dishes like filet mignon, bang bang shrimp, and bourbon pecan pie.

Bourbon pecan pie and key lime pie stand out as popular choices. Pies come homemade and are often recommended to save room for after meals.

People are saying

"Ben made the lamb steak sound so delicious, I had to try it."

"The American Food here is amazing, thanks to Ben's descriptions."

"You should save room for the homemade pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

2

Parking can be challenging; allow extra time to find a spot.

3

Expect longer wait times for food during busy dinner hours.

12
Steer-In image 1
American restaurant

Classic diner with 1960's decor and a spacious dining area creates a cozy, small-town vibe in a city setting. Friendly regulars contribute to a welcoming atmosphere despite some wear and tear in furnishings. Known for generous portions and homestyle cooking, it feels like a neighborhood institution.

Classic diner dishes include a full rack of ribs, biscuits and gravy, and a Reuben sandwich praised for its quality. Sides like mac n cheese, tots, and baked beans complement meals, while desserts feature standout vanilla ice cream in root beer floats and a gooey apple pie a la mode.

Coconut cream pie stands out with its fresh, creamy texture. The apple pie a la mode offers a crusty, gooey mix that feels like a classic diner treat.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the desserts and prime rib, is really good."

"I felt like I stepped into a classic, old-school diner."

"I loved their fresh, tender coconut cream pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special menus like Valentine's Day.

2

Expect large portion sizes for the price you pay.

3

The restaurant is known for its reasonable prices compared to fast food.

13
Miner-Dunn image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Old-school diner with vintage 1950s-60s decor and a personal jukebox playing classic oldies music creates a quiet, homestyle atmosphere. The place offers a nostalgic, authentic vibe that feels like stepping back in time. Regulars enjoy homemade burgers and onion rings in a friendly, comfy setting.

Hand-shaped ground beef forms the base of old school hamburgers here. The cheeseburger supreme on rye bread stands out with its rich flavor and classic style.

Fresh pies stand out here, especially the homemade strawberry pie that shines when in season. The pies are consistently delicious and often described as to die for.

People are saying

"I loved the old school vibe and quality of the burgers."

"The American food here, especially the potato soup, is the best I've ever had."

"The seasonal strawberry pie is amazing when it's available."

Good to know

1

Prices for meals are generally under $20, including dessert.

2

The diner offers a free orange sherbet with any deluxe meal.

3

Carry-out is easy with a dedicated section of the building.

14
Loughmiller's Pub & Eatery image 1

Scottish/Irish style corner bar with old school tavern feel and firefighter decor creates a crowded, loud atmosphere filled with laughter and good vibes. Tables sit close together, fostering a friendly, comfortable environment popular with office workers and locals. Outdoor patio seating adds a relaxed option away from downtown bustle.

Southwestern chicken nachos come with good seasoning and plenty of toppings. Burgers and a patty melt offer solid options, while the coleslaw stands out as very tasty.

The peanut butter pie stands out with its rich, creamy texture and delicious flavor. Many find it worth trying and often take it to go.

People are saying

"The food here, especially the burgers and sandwiches, was amazingly good."

"I found the peanut butter pie to be amazing and smooth."

"The American food, like the pork loin sandwich, is huge and crispy and was huge and crispy."

Good to know

1

Dogs are not allowed anywhere in the bar.

2

Only individuals aged 21 and above are allowed inside the pub.

3

The kitchen closes 90 minutes before the bar closes.

15
Pots & Pans Pie Co. image 1

Small bakery with open kitchen view and minimal seating offers a clean, cozy atmosphere highlighted by the smell of flaky pie crusts. Energy stays easygoing and welcoming, with a focus on homestyle pies sold by the slice and rotating flavors that invite frequent visits.

Chicken pot pie stands out with versions like BBQ mac and cheese and a classic with mushrooms. Desserts include maple pecan pie, apple pie, and shortbread chocolate chip cookies.

Pies here come in both sweet and savory varieties with a flaky crust and creamy, smooth filling. The Beef & Mushroom pot pie stands out, and the sugar crรจme pie features a crรจme brรปlรฉe-like topping that adds a special touch.

People are saying

"I found Bruce's Lemon Pie to be the best pie I had ever had."

"I found the pastry here to be fresh and delightful."

"Their American food, especially the pies, has an insanely delicious, flaky crust."

Good to know

1

Pie slices are available for $7 each, with whole pies starting at $13.

2

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

They offer unique pie flavors that change frequently.

16
Bakers Square image 1
Family restaurant

Family restaurant with an old-fashioned atmosphere that feels down home and peaceful. The space is clean and tidy but shows signs of needing modernization. Known for delicious pies, especially banana cream and lemon supreme, which define much of the experience.

Pot roast stands out as a hearty classic here. The menu also features a grown up grilled cheese sandwich with fries and honey mustard, plus a good hamburger deal and a well-liked cheeseburger.

Pies here stay fresh and consistent, with classic flavors like lemon meringue, coconut creme, and banana cream. Free pie slices come on Wednesdays, and the quality has held steady for decades.

People are saying

"I was so happy to see the Carmel Pecan Silk Supreme pie again!"

"I loved the breakfast potatoes; they were some of the best."

"You have to try the American Food pies; I loved them."

Good to know

1

Free pie is available on Wednesdays with the purchase of a meal.

2

Expect no wait for breakfast at this location.

3

Bakers Square is handicap accessible for all guests.

17
Homemade Ice Cream & Bakery Cafรฉ image 1

Cozy cafรฉ with a fireplace wall and comfortable seating creates a calm, welcoming atmosphere. Guests enjoy watching cakes being decorated, adding to the relaxed vibe. Known for huge ice cream scoops and exceptional desserts, it offers a down-to-earth, low-key experience.

Pecan pie ala mode stands out as a solid choice. Apple pie slices come small and sometimes underbaked, with an artificial taste and occasional mold issues.

Chocolate Silk Pie and Reese's pie stand out with rich, smooth textures. Pecan pie ala mode and caramel pie offer fantastic flavor with melting sugar granules and fresh apple notes. Whipped peanut butter pie feels light, almost like a cloud.

People are saying

"The cakes here are out of this world delicious."

"I found the pies, like the caramel apple, absolutely delicious."

"I found the American Food pies to be wonderful."

Good to know

1

The cafรฉ offers a lunch combo of croissant and soup for $28 before tip.

2

A bowl of soup costs nearly $8, which may not be adequate for some.

3

Expect to pay extra for gluten-free options on the menu.

18
King Ribs BBQ image 1
American restaurant

Smoke fills the air, creating an authentic BBQ atmosphere with a lively and welcoming vibe. Friendly people gather inside and outside, enjoying a clean, unpretentious setting that feels like home. The place offers a drive-thru experience that lets the smoky aroma roll through the windows.

Barbecue ribs come with mild sauce and pair well with mac and cheese. Cornbread is served free, and sides like baked beans and coleslaw have strong flavor.

Chess pie has a nice texture and tastes like egg pie. Sweet potato pie features a crust and filling that stand out.

People are saying

"The food here is great, especially the ribs and chicken."

"I thought these ribs were the best I had in a long time."

"The American Food rib tips here are tender and delicious."

Good to know

1

Drive-thru service is available, but expect long wait times, especially on weekends.

2

Pre-ordering does not guarantee food availability; check before arriving.

3

Online ordering is available for quick pickup, but drive-thru can be slow.

19
MCL Restaurant & Bakery Township Line image 1

Spacious seating with comfortable booths creates a clean and peaceful environment. The atmosphere feels relaxed and inviting, suitable for sharing meals and conversation. Known for excellent desserts and home-style food, it attracts families and those seeking quick dining.

Fried chicken stands out as a delicious highlight. The meatloaf comes as part of a blue plate special and is made in a classic style. The pecan pie ranks among the better versions around.

Coconut cream pie stands out as very tasty and a highlight here. The pecan pie is notable, though the filling can vary in quality. Special promotions like 99 cent pie day offer good value.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was delicious and tasty."

"I thought the American food, especially the fried chicken, was great."

"I loved the 99 cent pie day promotion!"

Good to know

1

Lunch pricing is based on a pay-per-item structure, often exceeding $20 per meal.

2

Seniors can receive a discount on Tuesdays before 5:00 PM.

3

Tuesday features a special meatloaf dish.

20
Fat Man's BBQ image 1
Restaurant

Hickory smoke fills the air, creating a classic BBQ aroma that welcomes guests. Warm, family-centered decorations and great music set a friendly, inviting atmosphere. An old-style Pac-Man arcade game adds a nostalgic touch to the space.

Turkey tips, pulled pork, and brisket come well-seasoned and cooked just right. Sides like mac and cheese, baked beans, and cornbread stand out with rich flavors.

Chess pie features a thin crust under 2.5 inches wide and less than an inch thick. Sweet potato pie arrives well-cooked and warm, alongside peach cobbler and hot sides.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and awesome."

"The American Food brisket here is tender, moist, and delicious."

"The chess pie crust was less than an inch thick."

Good to know

1

Fat Man's BBQ offers a variety of options including chicken, lamb, brisket, turkey, ribs, and pork.

2

Prices are generally under $20 for BBQ meals.

3

Delivery is not available from Fat Man's BBQ.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...