Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Indiana

Pie spots

A satisfying dinner should always conclude with a slice of pie. You know that the dessert is just as important as the main course.

Based on 530 Opinions
+527
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Dean's Steak & Seafood Indianapolis image 1
Dean's Steak & Seafood Indianapolis image 2
Dean's Steak & Seafood Indianapolis image 3
View all

Elegant dining space combines warm decor with luxurious atmosphere and live DJ music, creating a vibrant yet intimate setting. Guests enjoy top-tier steaks and seafood alongside expertly crafted cocktails, making it a standout for high-end dining experiences.

Dinner offers a quiet atmosphere ideal for two and a knowledgeable server who enhances the experience. The menu features steak and seafood with attentive service throughout.

Key lime pie stands out as a signature dessert, often praised for its flavor. The cheesecake with blueberry compote also draws attention for its rich taste and texture.

People are saying

"The steak here is amazing and perfectly cooked."

"The steaks and seafood at this dinner spot are outstanding."

"I highly recommend the key lime pie; it's the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The private dining room is available for hosting events.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers during conventions.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

02
The Kitchen on Main image 1

Small town restaurant with retro decor and a speakeasy bar in the back creates a cozy, chill vibe. Atmosphere shifts from relaxed and friendly in the dining area to lively and loud in the speakeasy. Live jazz music adds to the unique, old-school diner feel.

Dinner offers delicious and satisfying meals. The kitchen focuses on quality and flavor in every dish.

Pecan pie comes with a perfect scoop of ice cream. Blueberry pie and Nashville Wrap stand out as fantastic choices. Key Lime Pie and Tiramisu get strong praise from the group.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is delicious, especially the Smash burger."

"I thought this place was really cool to chill."

"I found the dinner spots delicious and the fries perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

The restaurant features a hidden speakeasy in the back for a unique experience.

3

Expect longer wait times during dinner hours, especially on weekends.

03
Cheeky Bastards Restaurant image 1
Modern British restaurant

Modern British restaurant offers authentic English fare with standout fish and chips and classic English rock music setting a lively tone. Interior combines cozy, quaint decor with small, intimate rooms, creating a welcoming, family-like atmosphere. Space feels compact with tables designed for two but often seating four, emphasizing a popular, bustling vibe.

Dinner offers savory and scrumptious dishes with staff willing to prepare off-menu items. The atmosphere suits both couples and families for a relaxed evening.

Steak and Guinness Shepherd's pie stands out with its generous serving and flavorful lamb and mashed potatoes. Scottish Egg and sausage rolls also complement the menu with hearty, savory options.

People are saying

"The fish and chips here are huge and perfectly crispy."

"The food at these dinner spots is so delicious, I wanted more the next day."

"Hope made me feel like family, sharing stories about the business."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch due to limited seating.

2

Expect long wait times on Saturday nights without a reservation.

3

The restaurant offers a unique afternoon tea service on the first Sunday of each month.

04
His Place Eatery - Chicken & Waffles, Ribs & Soul Food (86th & Ditch Rd) image 1

Soul food restaurant offers a clean, bright interior with crowded seating that feels lively and homey. Music and a quirky photo booth add to the welcoming vibe despite some noise from guests. The space balances an upscale design with a casual, packed atmosphere.

Dinner here features amazing flavors across all dishes. Meals come with four sides and include two dinner options that stand out.

Peach pie comes with ice cream and stands out for its flavor. Fried chicken pot pie offers a rich, savory experience. Bourbon pecan pie serves as a sweet ending to the meal.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the mac and cheese, is amazing."

"The dinner here is delicious, like amazing home-cooked comfort food."

"The fried chicken pot pie's puff pastry was crispy and melt-in-your-mouth."

Good to know

1

Expect a wait time of about 5 minutes during peak dinner hours.

2

The kitchen may close 15-20 minutes before the posted closing time.

3

Desserts often sell out by 7pm on Fridays, so arrive early.

05
Aberdeen Social House image 1

Upscale restaurant offers a mid-century modern vibe with curated artwork and thoughtful architectural details. Outdoor patio provides a comfortable, zen atmosphere ideal for leisurely dining. The space balances swanky and welcoming energy, attracting those who appreciate quality and style.

Dinner offers phenomenal options including salads and a Lobster BLT praised for quality. Service is attentive, with staff providing excellent care during meals.

Banana cream pie stands out with its unique flavor and is a popular dessert choice. Steak and mushroom pie comes with gravy and mashed potatoes, making it a well-rounded meal option.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is phenomenal and packed with flavor."

"I'm already planning my next visit for more pie."

"The dinner spots here have creative, delicious food options."

Good to know

1

The menu changes frequently with local ingredients prepared by a creative culinary team.

2

Expect higher prices for unique dishes and elevated dining experiences.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekends and special occasions.

06
Miner-Dunn image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Old-school diner with vintage 1950s-60s decor and a personal jukebox playing classic oldies music creates a quiet, homestyle atmosphere. The place offers a nostalgic, authentic vibe that feels like stepping back in time. Regulars enjoy homemade burgers and onion rings in a friendly, comfy setting.

Roast beef dinner comes with savory gravy over bread and a vegetable, paired with fresh-cut French fries served hot. Meals include a scoop of ice cream with deluxe dinner options.

Fresh pies stand out here, especially the homemade strawberry pie that shines when in season. The pies are consistently delicious and often described as to die for.

People are saying

"I loved the old school vibe and quality of the burgers."

"The American food here, especially the potato soup, is the best I've ever had."

"The burgers and fries at these dinner spots are tasty and fresh."

Good to know

1

Prices for meals are generally under $20, including dessert.

2

The diner offers a free orange sherbet with any deluxe meal.

3

Carry-out is easy with a dedicated section of the building.

07
Loughmiller's Pub & Eatery image 1

Scottish/Irish style corner bar with old school tavern feel and firefighter decor creates a crowded, loud atmosphere filled with laughter and good vibes. Tables sit close together, fostering a friendly, comfortable environment popular with office workers and locals. Outdoor patio seating adds a relaxed option away from downtown bustle.

Classic burgers and chili feature on the dinner menu. The spot offers a local vibe with a casual atmosphere suited for dinner and drinks.

The peanut butter pie stands out with its rich, creamy texture and delicious flavor. Many find it worth trying and often take it to go.

People are saying

"The food here, especially the burgers and sandwiches, was amazingly good."

"You have to try the pork tenderloin sandwich for dinner."

"I found the peanut butter pie to be amazing and smooth."

Good to know

1

Dogs are not allowed anywhere in the bar.

2

Only individuals aged 21 and above are allowed inside the pub.

3

The kitchen closes 90 minutes before the bar closes.

08
Tipsy Mermaid Conch House & Cocktails image 1

Bright, clean space with coastal decor and a tropical vibe creates a laid-back yet sophisticated atmosphere. Crowds and lively music contribute to a noisy, energetic environment. Regulars enjoy Key West style touches and inventive cocktails that stand out.

Dinner here includes a special treat atmosphere with satisfying meals. The famous key lime pie stands out as a dessert choice even after a full dinner.

Creamy and perfectly balanced, the Key lime pie stands out with its tart flavor and fresh whipped cream topping. It arrives nicely cut and plated, with quick availability even without the usual 24-hour notice.

People are saying

"The dinner spots here feel like a vacation to the Florida Keys."

"You have to try the American Food lobster rolls; they're bursting with crab and lobster."

"I saved room for their famous, creamy key lime pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not accepted, leading to potential wait times of about 30 minutes.

2

Happy hour features half-price signature cocktails and $2 oysters.

3

A kid-friendly brunch is available on Saturdays and Sundays.

09
FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale image 1
American restaurant

Exposed plaster, lathe, and old brickwork create an eclectic, cozy setting with heated indoor patio and rooftop dining options. The atmosphere stays laid back and inviting, suitable for conversations without raising voices. A huge full bar offers variety, drawing groups to cozy tables upstairs.

Dinners here feature chicken parmesan and other delicious options. Special occasions like anniversary and farewell dinners include thoughtful touches like dessert.

Bourbon pecan pie and key lime pie stand out as popular choices. Pies come homemade and are often recommended to save room for after meals.

People are saying

"Ben made the lamb steak sound so delicious, I had to try it."

"The desserts here are so delicious, I struggled to decide what to order."

"You should save room for the homemade pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

2

Parking can be challenging; allow extra time to find a spot.

3

Expect longer wait times for food during busy dinner hours.

10
Steer-In image 1
American restaurant

Classic diner with 1960's decor and a spacious dining area creates a cozy, small-town vibe in a city setting. Friendly regulars contribute to a welcoming atmosphere despite some wear and tear in furnishings. Known for generous portions and homestyle cooking, it feels like a neighborhood institution.

Quick dinner sandwiches like the meatball sub stand out here. The spot works well for a fast, casual dinner.

Coconut cream pie stands out with its fresh, creamy texture. The apple pie a la mode offers a crusty, gooey mix that feels like a classic diner treat.

People are saying

"The American food here, especially the desserts and prime rib, is really good."

"The food here is great, especially the wings and fried mushrooms."

"I loved their fresh, tender coconut cream pie."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special menus like Valentine's Day.

2

Expect large portion sizes for the price you pay.

3

The restaurant is known for its reasonable prices compared to fast food.

11
Pots & Pans Pie Co. image 1

Small bakery with open kitchen view and minimal seating offers a clean, cozy atmosphere highlighted by the smell of flaky pie crusts. Energy stays easygoing and welcoming, with a focus on homestyle pies sold by the slice and rotating flavors that invite frequent visits.

Dinner options include pies like biscuits and gravy or vegetable with potatoes. Some pies have mostly crust with sparse fillings. Meals are practical and tasty when skipping cooking.

Pies here come in both sweet and savory varieties with a flaky crust and creamy, smooth filling. The Beef & Mushroom pot pie stands out, and the sugar crรจme pie features a crรจme brรปlรฉe-like topping that adds a special touch.

People are saying

"I found Bruce's Lemon Pie to be the best pie I had ever had."

"I found the pastry here to be fresh and delightful."

"These dinner spots have the most delicious pies with crusts made with love."

Good to know

1

Pie slices are available for $7 each, with whole pies starting at $13.

2

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

They offer unique pie flavors that change frequently.

12
Fat Man's BBQ image 1
Restaurant

Hickory smoke fills the air, creating a classic BBQ aroma that welcomes guests. Warm, family-centered decorations and great music set a friendly, inviting atmosphere. An old-style Pac-Man arcade game adds a nostalgic touch to the space.

Rib tips come with mixed sauce and stay tender and juicy. Dinner options include BBQ meals served after events like the HOT ROD Power tour.

Chess pie features a thin crust under 2.5 inches wide and less than an inch thick. Sweet potato pie arrives well-cooked and warm, alongside peach cobbler and hot sides.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious and awesome."

"The food at these dinner spots is amazing."

"The chess pie crust was less than an inch thick."

Good to know

1

Fat Man's BBQ offers a variety of options including chicken, lamb, brisket, turkey, ribs, and pork.

2

Prices are generally under $20 for BBQ meals.

3

Delivery is not available from Fat Man's BBQ.

13
Bakers Square image 1
Family restaurant

Family restaurant with an old-fashioned atmosphere that feels down home and peaceful. The space is clean and tidy but shows signs of needing modernization. Known for delicious pies, especially banana cream and lemon supreme, which define much of the experience.

Dinner includes options like a turkey dinner priced around $16.00. The spot serves meals suitable for both breakfast and dinner, with a long-standing reputation for French silk pie.

Pies here stay fresh and consistent, with classic flavors like lemon meringue, coconut creme, and banana cream. Free pie slices come on Wednesdays, and the quality has held steady for decades.

People are saying

"I was so happy to see the Carmel Pecan Silk Supreme pie again!"

"I loved the breakfast potatoes; they were some of the best."

"I enjoyed the good food at these dinner spots."

Good to know

1

Free pie is available on Wednesdays with the purchase of a meal.

2

Expect no wait for breakfast at this location.

3

Bakers Square is handicap accessible for all guests.

14
Round the Clock Highland image 1

Rustic barn-style setting creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere with sectioned layout that eases navigation. The vibe is family-friendly and chill, often accompanied by smaller booths and booster seats for kids.

Dinner options come with soup or salad, dessert, and two sides for $13. Seniors get a special price of $9.29 that includes an entree, drink, and dessert. Late-night dinners with groups are common.

All pies come made in-house for a homemade taste. Options include chocolate peanut butter pie and selections on a senior menu.

People are saying

"I found the breakfast here to be really good and satisfying."

"The service here is fantastic and the staff are lovely."

"Dinner spots here offer so much food for a bargain price."

Good to know

1

Half-price burgers are available from 8 to 10 PM every night.

2

A new half-priced breakfast special is offered after 8 PM.

3

Senior citizens can enjoy a full course meal including dessert for $9.29.

15
King Ribs BBQ image 1
American restaurant

Smoke fills the air, creating an authentic BBQ atmosphere with a lively and welcoming vibe. Friendly people gather inside and outside, enjoying a clean, unpretentious setting that feels like home. The place offers a drive-thru experience that lets the smoky aroma roll through the windows.

Rib tip dinners come with mixed sauce and two sides. Cornbread and dinner rolls replace sliced bread as the bread options.

Chess pie has a nice texture and tastes like egg pie. Sweet potato pie features a crust and filling that stand out.

People are saying

"The food here is great, especially the ribs and chicken."

"I thought these ribs were the best I had in a long time."

"I loved my tender and delicious rib tip dinner."

Good to know

1

Drive-thru service is available, but expect long wait times, especially on weekends.

2

Pre-ordering does not guarantee food availability; check before arriving.

3

Online ordering is available for quick pickup, but drive-thru can be slow.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...