Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Ice cream sandwiches in Indiana

Made for those who believe that ice cream is best served as a structural component of a handheld dessert.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
What's Shaken Café image 1
What's Shaken Café image 2
What's Shaken Café image 3
View all

Cozy café with a warm, inviting vibe and beautifully decorated interior creates a calm, family-friendly atmosphere. Freshly made cupcakes and unique offerings like an açaí bowl draw a steady crowd from nearby areas.

Elote ice cream offers a unique, fantastic flavor. Cakes and cookies come with rich density and moistness, and a pup cup is available for pets.

Chicken salad sandwich stands out with fresh ingredients and balanced flavors. Coffee pairs well with the fantastic sandwiches offered.

People are saying

"The cupcakes here are so welcoming and sweet."

"I found the sandwiches here to be fantastic."

"The ice cream here has amazing flavor and is worth trying."

Good to know

1

The café offers a variety of menu options including coffee, smoothies, and cupcakes.

2

Large coffees cost $6 each, which is a reasonable price for quality coffee.

3

The café has a points rewards system for frequent customers.

02
The Kitchen on Main image 1

Small town restaurant with retro decor and a speakeasy bar in the back creates a cozy, chill vibe. Atmosphere shifts from relaxed and friendly in the dining area to lively and loud in the speakeasy. Live jazz music adds to the unique, old-school diner feel.

Delicious ice cream and shakes complement meals well here. A scoop of ice cream often rounds out desserts like pecan pie.

Sandwiches feature fresh ingredients and attention to detail with standout options like the South American Schnitzel and TBH Sandwich. Varieties include grilled mahi mahi, tenderloin, and meatball, often paired with onion rings or shakes.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is delicious, especially the Smash burger."

"You have to try the South American Schnitzel sandwich; it's amazing."

"I loved the fresh and delicious garden salad."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

The restaurant features a hidden speakeasy in the back for a unique experience.

3

Expect longer wait times during dinner hours, especially on weekends.

03
FoxGardin Kitchen & Ale image 1
American restaurant

Exposed plaster, lathe, and old brickwork create an eclectic, cozy setting with heated indoor patio and rooftop dining options. The atmosphere stays laid back and inviting, suitable for conversations without raising voices. A huge full bar offers variety, drawing groups to cozy tables upstairs.

Soft baked cookies come with a scoop of ice cream for dessert. Complimentary cookie and ice cream treats are offered on first visits.

Crunchy exterior and soft interior define the Cuban sandwich, featuring high-quality meat and thick sliced pickles. The chicken shawarma and mushroom "steak" sandwiches offer tasty fillings with onions, peppers, and mushrooms.

People are saying

"Ben made the lamb steak sound so delicious, I had to try it."

"The beef Manhattan sandwich was the best I've ever had."

"You have to try the warm cookie with ice cream for dessert."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially during peak hours.

2

Parking can be challenging; allow extra time to find a spot.

3

Expect longer wait times for food during busy dinner hours.

04
Cousin Vinny's Deli & The Sub Hub image 1

Deli resembles a clean gas station market with a friendly atmosphere and affordable prices. Sandwiches are fresh and filling, featuring standout options like chicken cordon bleu and grilled chicken Philly. The vibe is casual and unpretentious, with quick service and a focus on value.

Homemade ice cream offers a consistent treat throughout the year. Strawberry flavor stands out as a notable choice. The ice cream case design limits direct visibility of the product's freshness.

Chicken cordon bleu stands out as a top sandwich here, with others like corned beef also highly praised. Sandwiches stay fresh and not soggy, offer great value, and come in a solid variety.

People are saying

"The Cousin Vinny sandwich was the obvious standout."

"The deli sandwiches here are delicious and so fresh."

"Their homemade ice cream is always a treat."

Good to know

1

The sandwiches are reasonably priced, making them a good value.

2

Orders typically arrive within 10 minutes, ensuring quick service.

3

The belly buster deal offers three meats and a choice of cheese for $8.

05
Jodi's Italian Ice Factory-Hammond image 1

Small joint with an old school feel and an updated look offers a friendly vibe and simple atmosphere. It draws a crowd for its best Italian ice and standout Philly cheesesteak sandwiches. Parking can be challenging when busy.

Italian ice comes in flavors like blue razz and pairs well with homemade vanilla ice cream. Sweet potato ice cream offers a unique twist alongside classic options.

Sandwiches come huge and well seasoned with plenty of meat. Wrapping in foil keeps them hot for takeout, and the Philly cheese steak and sweet steak sandwiches stand out.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are tasty and satisfying with lots of meat."

"These steak egg rolls are the best, so cheesy and gooey."

"I loved the homemade vanilla ice cream; it was delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is limited and requires planning to find a spot.

2

Expect long wait times of 35-45 minutes during busy hours.

3

Ordering ahead is recommended to reduce wait times.

06
LiftOff Creamery - Irvington image 1

Tiny ice cream shop with airplane-themed decor and few tables creates a cozy, bright atmosphere. Friendly energy fills the space, often loud from customers, with a small play area adding to the vibe. Offers generous portions, vegan and no sugar added options, and a variety of unique flavors.

Offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors including vegan options. The ice cream is consistently high quality and popular with families.

Grilled cheese sandwiches come hot and tasty with options like grilled pineapple and cheese. The menu includes a few quick bites alongside these sandwiches.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the delicious ice cream here."

"This ice cream shop is a great little spot."

"The ice cream sandwich was a chocolate dream."

Good to know

1

LiftOff Creamery offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors and options for customization.

2

They have several vegan options available, including no sugar added flavors.

3

The shop is known for its clean environment and generous ice cream portions.

07
NY Food Center image 1
Restaurant

Spacious interior with no seating creates a standing-room-only environment where people wait for food. The atmosphere is clean and smells pleasant, offering a wide variety of options at reasonable prices. Orders can be placed by phone, and wait times are communicated clearly, making it convenient for those in a rush.

Banana pudding ice cream stands out as a delicious option. Ice cream here is consistently exceptionally good and often served alongside subs, wings, and burgers.

Breakfast sandwiches come with fries and a drink and stay hot. The Philly Cheesesteak sandwich stands out and prices stay very reasonable.

People are saying

"The food here is always hot and fresh."

"The food here is delicious and my kids loved it."

"I thought the sandwiches were delicious and made fresh."

Good to know

1

You can call and place your orders if you're in a rush.

2

They accepted EBT payments.

3

There are no seats or tables to sit at while waiting.

08
serenDIPity Restaurant & Ice Cream Parlor image 1

Ice cream parlor with old-school candy shop vibes and nostalgic games creates a wholesome, kid-friendly atmosphere. Decor and presentation emphasize a cute, classic feel that suits families and casual hangouts. Board games add interactive entertainment alongside sweet treats and simple meals.

Amazing ice cream pairs well with donuts and boba, making it a hit for all ages. The parlor stays very clean and offers friendly service that makes waiting worthwhile.

Sandwiches come toasted to perfection and are served with crispy, golden fries. A snack and sandwich bar offers a variety of options alongside ice cream.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was awesome and delicious."

"The grilled cheese sandwiches were toasted to perfection."

"The sandwiches were toasted to perfection."

Good to know

1

Expect to spend $5 to $10 per person, especially for extras.

2

The medium two scoop sundae costs $7.25.

3

Kids' cones are priced at $2.75, totaling $10.50 with tax for a medium cup.

09
NYC Market image 1
Restaurant

Small market with freshly made food and affordable prices offers customizable salads and seasoned wings. Environment stays clean and welcoming with no dine-in option, focusing on takeout. Essential food items and meal prep service add convenience.

Thick, creamy ice cream stands out here, especially the cookies and cream flavor. Staff often offer free ice cream with a kind attitude.

Sandwiches come packed with tons of flavor and spices and feel very heavy. Options like the Philly cheese steak and turkey sandwich stand out, though some sandwiches may be smaller than expected and occasionally made incorrectly despite repeated instructions.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was absolutely delicious."

"The ice cream here is thick, creamy, and satisfying."

"This sandwich is acceptable if you don't know authentic New York deli."

Good to know

1

There’s no dine-in option, so you’ll have to get your food to go.

2

They accepted EBT.

3

The prices were very cheap.

10
The Garage Food Hall image 1

Old warehouse space transformed into a historic food hall with a museum feel and revitalized industrial design. Atmosphere is lively and chaotic, filled with live music, pinball machines, and multiple bars offering tastings and mixed drinks. Crowds gather for a family-friendly vibe and diverse activities like sim racing, creating a bustling social hub.

Wide variety of ice cream flavors includes some unique options not commonly found elsewhere. The ice cream stands out as a top choice among many diverse food options available.

Cuban and Brazilian steak sandwiches stand out with rich, bold flavors. Other options include a Honey Spice Chicken sandwich, a BLT lobster sandwich, and a flavorful chicken salad sandwich.

People are saying

"It's a cool spot with great vibes."

"I enjoyed the ice cream and all the choices available."

"I loved the variety of international sandwich options here."

Good to know

1

Parking at The Garage Food Hall is difficult, especially on weekends.

2

The Garage Food Hall closes at 10 pm.

3

It is best to grab a table first before ordering food.

11
Miner-Dunn image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Old-school diner with vintage 1950s-60s decor and a personal jukebox playing classic oldies music creates a quiet, homestyle atmosphere. The place offers a nostalgic, authentic vibe that feels like stepping back in time. Regulars enjoy homemade burgers and onion rings in a friendly, comfy setting.

Soft serve ice cream features a natural orange and vanilla swirl that comes free with meals. The orange sherbet twisted with vanilla stands out as a signature flavor.

Reuben sandwiches come with finely chopped onions that are hard to remove. Turkey bacon and club sandwiches stand out, paired well with fresh cut fries and orange sherbet dessert.

People are saying

"I loved the old school vibe and quality of the burgers."

"I loved getting ice cream with my meal."

"They remade my sandwich without hesitation after I asked."

Good to know

1

Prices for meals are generally under $20, including dessert.

2

The diner offers a free orange sherbet with any deluxe meal.

3

Carry-out is easy with a dedicated section of the building.

12
California Burger image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food restaurant offers homemade burgers with crispy seasoned fries and large ice cream cones. Atmosphere is casual with occasional long waits and a busy drive-thru line. Prices tend to be higher than typical chains but reflect a focus on quality and flavor.

Very large ice cream cones offer a lot of ice cream at a good price. The vanilla ice cream works well on its own and in shakes, which use quality ice cream.

Beef sandwiches stand out, especially the Philly cheesesteak and Pastrami. Sandwiches hold together well and match their pictures.

People are saying

"I thought the food was delicious and always hot."

"The ice cream cones here are huge and a great price."

"The Philly Cheesesteak sandwich is fantastic and tasty."

Good to know

1

The total cost for a 2-pound combo with curly fries is about $15.

2

Refills for drinks are not free.

3

Dipping sauces other than ketchup are not included with meals.

13
Jodi's Italian Ice Factory image 1

Spacious dining room with wide-open seating and large booths creates an accessible and inviting environment. Atmosphere stays relaxing and friendly, though music can be a bit loud. Known for huge, flavorful sandwiches and delicious Italian ice, it offers a casual spot to enjoy satisfying meals and treats.

Ice cream here has a homemade vanilla flavor that tastes like it was churned for hours. Some find the vanilla excellent, while others do not care much for it.

Steak sandwiches stand out with well-spiced meat, sautéed onions, and melted cheese. They arrive very hot and are notably large and reasonably priced.

People are saying

"I thought the Philly Cheesesteak sandwich was absolutely wonderful."

"I thought the Philly cheesesteak sandwich was wonderful."

"Raquel made my ice cream experience the absolute best."

Good to know

1

There is plenty of parking available at the Schererville location.

2

The dining area and bathrooms are very clean.

3

Expect to wait if you're in a rush; it's best to visit when you have time.

14
Homemade Ice Cream & Bakery Café image 1

Cozy café with a fireplace wall and comfortable seating creates a calm, welcoming atmosphere. Guests enjoy watching cakes being decorated, adding to the relaxed vibe. Known for huge ice cream scoops and exceptional desserts, it offers a down-to-earth, low-key experience.

Homemade ice cream features huge scoops with flavors like cinnamon and cookies and cream standing out. The ice cream pairs well with baked goods and coffee, making it a solid choice for evening sweets.

Catered sandwiches work well for family get-togethers. The Caprese Sandwich and Turkey Mediterranean sandwich stand out. Sandwiches come with soups and shakes often enjoyed together.

People are saying

"The cakes here are out of this world delicious."

"The ice cream here is amazing, with huge scoops!"

"I loved their desserts, especially the Oreo Cake."

Good to know

1

The café offers a lunch combo of croissant and soup for $28 before tip.

2

A bowl of soup costs nearly $8, which may not be adequate for some.

3

Expect to pay extra for gluten-free options on the menu.

15
Culver’s image 1
American restaurant

Fast food restaurant with fresh-made burgers and delicious frozen custard offers a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere. Busy with lively teenagers around counters, it maintains high cleanliness standards and quick service, including drive-thru options.

Ice cream and shakes taste yummy and delicious here. Wait times can be long, sometimes over 25 minutes, and ingredient information is not readily offered.

Fish sandwiches stand out here, especially the cod sandwich which many find really good. The grilled chicken breast sandwich is simple but well-executed, and the grilled reuben sandwich pairs well with a milkshake.

People are saying

"The food here is hot, fresh, and delicious."

"I thought the ice cream here was yummy."

"I thought their fish sandwich was the best I had ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Culver's often closes early, sometimes 45 minutes before 10pm.

2

Showing up 20 minutes before closing might affect food quality.

3

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially at the drive-thru.

16
Natural State Provisions image 1
American restaurant

Space combines vintage lights, curated decor, and an open, cozy setting with a large dog-friendly patio featuring a connected dog park. Atmosphere feels laid back and eclectic, with friendly people and a relaxed vibe. Pool table and outdoor seating add to the casual, welcoming energy.

Thai iced tea ice cream stands out as a unique flavor worth trying. Ice cream comes in soft serve cones or plastic tubs without toppings.

Chicken sandwiches come with large portions and palm-sized pieces of meat. Prices start at $13 with no sides included, but sides can be added for extra cost.

People are saying

"I loved the craft beer selection and domestics."

"I thought the chicken sandwich was fantastic."

"The Thai iced tea ice cream is worth a visit."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has a dog park on site, but it is unmanaged.

2

Expect a 20% automatic gratuity on bills over $40.

3

There is a 3% charge for using a credit card.

17
219 Grounds image 1

Minimal, modern cafe with plenty of seating and a cozy, welcoming vibe. Music plays softly, creating a super chill atmosphere suitable for working or relaxing. Games and family-friendly features add to the inviting environment.

Offers a variety of ice cream and paletas alongside pastries and paninis. The ice cream pairs well with their great coffee and espresso options.

Offers panini sandwiches that are consistently delicious. Sandwiches come alongside coffee and ice cream options.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the coffee; it was awesome."

"You can taste test so many unique ice cream flavors here."

"I found their panini sandwiches to be delicious."

Good to know

1

The café offers a variety of drinks, including coffee, ice cream, and crepes.

2

Prices are fair and comparable to other local coffee shops.

3

The location is convenient for students at Purdue College with easy parking access.

18
Leo's Market and Eatery image 1

Market combines cleanliness with organized shelves and a wide product variety. Atmosphere feels energetic and welcoming, supported by air conditioning and outdoor seating. Unique features include a family restroom and a small gift shop.

Soft serve draws frequent visits for a quick sweet treat. A variety of flavored syrups complements ice cream, slushes, and sodas.

Fresh sandwiches and wraps come ready-made here, alongside meat dishes and salads. Potato salad pairs well with the sandwich options.

People are saying

"The food here is great, and the staff is super friendly."

"The staff here treats you like an old friend."

"You'll find fresh sandwiches and great potato salad here."

Good to know

1

The store is known for its cleanliness and well-organized shelves.

2

Leo's offers a wide selection of local products, including snacks and drinks.

3

The drive-thru service is convenient for families with small children.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...