Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Indianapolis

Cookie and pastry spots

A bakery that treats cookies and pastries with equal care instead of letting one suffer for the sake of the other.

Based on 678 Opinions
+675
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Café Babette image 1
Café Babette image 2
Café Babette image 3
View all
Pastry shop

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

Cookies here stand out for their incredible taste and quality. Varieties like the sea salt chocolate chip and s'mores cookie offer rich, memorable flavors that keep people coming back.

Sweet and savory pastries stand out with unique flavors and beautiful presentation. Each pastry offers 5-star quality that improves with every visit, making them worth the wait or preorder.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"This bakery is the best I've had outside of Europe."

"I thought the cookies here were the best I have ever had."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

02
Heidelberg Haus image 1
German restaurant

German restaurant combines cozy, authentic atmosphere with a quirky gift shop filled with knickknacks and gnomes. Space feels tight and lively, with staff in fun outfits enhancing the energy. Offers unique German groceries and pastries alongside dining tables scattered through the store.

Cookies here are authentic German treats, often paired with affordable prices. Seasonal options like Christmas cookies stand out alongside classic favorites.

Authentic German pastries feature prominently, with the Black Forest pastry standing out as a highlight. Baked goods here consistently deliver rich, traditional flavors.

People are saying

"It's a unique place packed with quirky trinkets and German imports."

"The pastries here are divine, like something from heaven."

"I found the cookies here to be soft and delicious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, but arriving early is recommended to avoid sold-out baked goods.

2

Heidelberg Haus has about eight tables, so expect limited seating.

3

The bakery offers a variety of German pastries and desserts that are popular among locals.

03
Taylor's Bakery image 1

Bakery filled with beautiful cake creations and delicious baked goods creates a fun, clean atmosphere packed with people. Known for best cakes and donuts in the area, it draws families and special occasions consistently.

Cookies come with iced sugar decorations and custom designs for events. The chocolate chip cookie with icing in the middle stands out among the selection. Seasonal decorated cookies add variety and visual appeal.

Wide variety of pastries includes donuts, bear claws, and orange fluff cake. Pastries come with fresh icing and are ready early in the morning.

People are saying

"I drive 1.5 hours for their Mardi Gras King Cakes."

"These cookies and cupcakes are delicious!"

"I thought the pastries were delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

The parking situation at the 116th Street location can be problematic.

2

Expect limited stock later in the day; arrive early for best selection.

3

Taylor's Bakery does not offer gluten-free cookies.

04
Bovaconti Coffee image 1
Coffee shop

Coffee shop offers cozy indoor seating and a spacious outdoor patio with Adirondack chairs and a dog-friendly atmosphere. Ambiance stays peaceful and quiet for work but can get loud when busy. Artful cup designs and reliable WiFi add to a welcoming, community-focused vibe.

Cookies come in peanut butter chocolate chip and ginger blueberry oatmeal varieties. They have a dense texture and pair well with chai latte.

Soft, fresh pastries come with vegan options. They pair well with consistently good coffee and tea.

People are saying

"I thought the coffee here was amazing and delicious."

"I loved the delicious pastries here."

"I really enjoyed their delicious ginger blueberry oatmeal cookies."

Good to know

1

Bovaconti Coffee is the only coffee place open on Christmas Eve.

2

There is free parking on the streets near Bovaconti Coffee.

3

The coffee shop is dog friendly.

05
Hart Bakery & Gifts image 1

Shop resembles a cozy grandma's house filled with vintage tchotchkes and tacky costume jewelry. Atmosphere invites slow browsing among nostalgic gifts alongside handmade baked goods. Regulars find pecan donuts and blueberry cake stand out for quality and size.

Toffee cookies stand out for their rich flavor and freshness. A wide variety of cookies includes thumbprint options, all offering great value and often accompanied by fresh doughnuts.

Delicious pastries include doughnuts, cakes, and cookies. The care in preparation shows in every item, making the selection stand out.

People are saying

"I ordered a custom birthday cake that guests loved."

"You have to try their cookies; they're amazing and huge!"

"I enjoyed the delicious doughnuts and pastries."

Good to know

1

Hart Bakery & Gifts accepts EBT for purchases.

2

Pre-ordering is recommended as they often run out of popular items.

3

The quarter sheet cake costs $30.00.

06
Illumine Coffee - Nora image 1

Open layout with natural lighting and cozy seating creates an airy, elegant atmosphere. Space suits both working and socializing, attracting a mix of people chatting or focused on tasks. Known for phenomenal quality coffee and a welcoming vibe, it stands out as a local favorite.

Cookies come from 4 Birds Bakery and include gluten free options. They taste excellent.

Pastries here stand out for their amazing quality and pair well with excellent coffee. The selection offers consistently delicious options beyond typical franchise fare.

People are saying

"I enjoyed their delicious coffee and amazing pastries."

"The pastries here are amazing and buttery."

"I opted for a cookie, and it was excellent."

Good to know

1

The coffee shop is locally owned and roasts its beans in-house.

2

Expect high volume during peak hours, making seating limited.

3

The drink prices start at $6 for a small cup.

07
Pots & Pans Pie Co. image 1

Small bakery with open kitchen view and minimal seating offers a clean, cozy atmosphere highlighted by the smell of flaky pie crusts. Energy stays easygoing and welcoming, with a focus on homestyle pies sold by the slice and rotating flavors that invite frequent visits.

Shortbread chocolate chip cookies have a heavenly crust and a rich buttery flavor. Oatmeal cream pies taste like oatmeal cookies with a buttery center but lack sweetness.

Fresh apple cheese pastry and choriqueso stand out among a variety of hand-made sweet pies and pastries. The selection includes both savory classics and delightful sweet options.

People are saying

"I found Bruce's Lemon Pie to be the best pie I had ever had."

"I found the pastry here to be fresh and delightful."

"These cookies are the best I have ever tasted."

Good to know

1

Pie slices are available for $7 each, with whole pies starting at $13.

2

Parking is limited, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

They offer unique pie flavors that change frequently.

08
Nine Lives Cafe & Cat Lounge image 1

Cat cafe with two separate rooms for kittens and adult cats offers a calm, relaxing atmosphere filled with playful cats and cat-themed art throughout. Visitors interact with well-cared-for cats in a clean, safe space that supports local rescues. The environment balances laid-back vibes with community-minded care.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with their rich flavor and perfect texture. Drinks pair well, making the cookie experience enjoyable.

Fresh pastries come with good coffee and tea. All the pastries look delicious and pair well with drinks.

People are saying

"I enjoyed relaxing with the cats and having a coffee."

"I loved the delicious pastries and coffee here."

"The cats here are so friendly and loving; I want to adopt them!"

Good to know

1

Reservations are required to visit the cat lounge, especially on weekends.

2

A 60-minute reservation is ideal for enjoying the cat rooms.

3

The cafe collaborates with local rescues to facilitate cat adoptions.

Discover more

Indianapolis, Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...