Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Indiana

Cake and pie spots

You want a place that takes both cake and pie seriously. You should not have to choose between your two favorite desserts.

Based on 555 Opinions
+552
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Bakes of Carmel image 1
Bakes of Carmel image 2
Bakes of Carmel image 3
View all

Bakery showcases beautifully decorated cakes and party-ready cupcakes with buttercream icing that impress both kids and adults. Atmosphere feels festive and custom orders are handled efficiently with clear storage instructions. Dedication to quality and artistry stands out in every item.

Wedding cakes feature Biscoff filling and stunning designs that impress guests. Birthday and gender reveal cakes come in flavors like Chocolate Ganache Grandeur Delight and have delicious buttercream icing.

Apple and pecan pies stand out for their rich, nostalgic flavors. Butterscotch pie appears as a special, off-menu treat made fresh on request. Pies arrive beautifully presented and are ready on time.

People are saying

"The cake here is amazing and beautifully decorated."

"The pie here is delicious and tasted amazing."

"The cakes for your celebration are visually appealing and delicious."

Good to know

1

Bakes of Carmel can accommodate custom cake orders with short notice.

2

Cakes are packaged securely for easy transport to events.

3

They provide clear instructions on how to store and serve cakes.

02
Dean's Steak & Seafood Indianapolis image 1

Elegant dining space combines warm decor with luxurious atmosphere and live DJ music, creating a vibrant yet intimate setting. Guests enjoy top-tier steaks and seafood alongside expertly crafted cocktails, making it a standout for high-end dining experiences.

Chocolate Cake with Raspberry stands out as a decadent finale and a highlight. Carrot Cake also offers a highly recommended option. A smoke flaming cake adds a mind-blowing twist to the dessert selection.

Key lime pie stands out as a signature dessert, often praised for its flavor. The cheesecake with blueberry compote also draws attention for its rich taste and texture.

People are saying

"The steak here is amazing and perfectly cooked."

"The cake here was mind-blowing, like a smoke flaming cake."

"I highly recommend the key lime pie; it's the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The private dining room is available for hosting events.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers during conventions.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially on busy nights.

03
Cheeky Bastards Restaurant image 1
Modern British restaurant

Modern British restaurant offers authentic English fare with standout fish and chips and classic English rock music setting a lively tone. Interior combines cozy, quaint decor with small, intimate rooms, creating a welcoming, family-like atmosphere. Space feels compact with tables designed for two but often seating four, emphasizing a popular, bustling vibe.

Victoria sponge layer cake stands out with its classic, light texture and balanced sweetness. The toffee Bundt cake offers a rich, moist alternative for dessert lovers.

Steak and Guinness Shepherd's pie stands out with its generous serving and flavorful lamb and mashed potatoes. Scottish Egg and sausage rolls also complement the menu with hearty, savory options.

People are saying

"The fish and chips here are huge and perfectly crispy."

"Hope made me feel like family, sharing stories about the business."

"I found the fish and chips to be far above my expectations."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for weekend brunch due to limited seating.

2

Expect long wait times on Saturday nights without a reservation.

3

The restaurant offers a unique afternoon tea service on the first Sunday of each month.

04
Marilyn's Bakery image 1

Warm aroma fills a clean, inviting space with freshly baked treats and detailed custom cakes that impress visually and in taste. The atmosphere balances consistent quality with special occasion craftsmanship, attracting those seeking memorable desserts.

Custom cakes feature detailed character designs like Buzz Lightyear and SpongeBob. Cakes are moist and rich, with flavors like chocolate and pineapple upside-down that get great feedback.

Cherry pie shines in small sizes with freshness and great taste. Coconut cream, chocolate, blueberry, pumpkin, and chicken pot pies also show consistent quality and flavor.

People are saying

"They brought my vision to life with an incredible custom cake."

"I found the pies here to be fresh and tasty."

"You have to try their blueberry and pumpkin pies."

Good to know

1

Prices at the bakery are generally high, costing $$$$.

2

The bakery often runs out of popular items like brisket, soup, and quiche.

3

Custom cake orders require clear specifications to avoid mistakes.

05
Taylor's Bakery image 1

Bakery filled with beautiful cake creations and delicious baked goods creates a fun, clean atmosphere packed with people. Known for best cakes and donuts in the area, it draws families and special occasions consistently.

Cakes come out beautiful and delicious with consistent quality. They serve as reliable choices for weddings and birthdays over many years. The taste and appearance stand out as top commercial cakes.

Cherry pie stands out as a favorite, often described as the best and a nice treat. Pot pies and quiches add savory options, while pies arrive delivered safely and promptly for events. Rewards programs offer chances to get pies for free.

People are saying

"I drive 1.5 hours for their Mardi Gras King Cakes."

"These cookies and cupcakes are delicious!"

"I thought the cherry pie was the best pie I ever had."

Good to know

1

The parking situation at the 116th Street location can be problematic.

2

Expect limited stock later in the day; arrive early for best selection.

3

Taylor's Bakery does not offer gluten-free cookies.

06
Aberdeen Social House image 1

Upscale restaurant offers a mid-century modern vibe with curated artwork and thoughtful architectural details. Outdoor patio provides a comfortable, zen atmosphere ideal for leisurely dining. The space balances swanky and welcoming energy, attracting those who appreciate quality and style.

Pineapple upside down cake stands out as excellent, while the carrot cake is a solid choice for dessert. The banana cream pie and chocolate caramel cake are rich, but the ricotta cake tends to be dry and hard to enjoy.

Banana cream pie stands out with its unique flavor and is a popular dessert choice. Steak and mushroom pie comes with gravy and mashed potatoes, making it a well-rounded meal option.

People are saying

"The food at these Date Spots is phenomenal and packed with flavor."

"I'm already planning my next visit for more pie."

"You have to try the carrot cake; it's excellent."

Good to know

1

The menu changes frequently with local ingredients prepared by a creative culinary team.

2

Expect higher prices for unique dishes and elevated dining experiences.

3

Reservations are recommended, especially for weekends and special occasions.

07
Homemade Ice Cream & Bakery Café image 1

Cozy café with a fireplace wall and comfortable seating creates a calm, welcoming atmosphere. Guests enjoy watching cakes being decorated, adding to the relaxed vibe. Known for huge ice cream scoops and exceptional desserts, it offers a down-to-earth, low-key experience.

Cakes here stand out for their phenomenal flavor and affordable value. Options like chocolate, carrot, and sweetheart cakes are consistently delicious and generously sized.

Chocolate Silk Pie and Reese's pie stand out with rich, smooth textures. Pecan pie ala mode and caramel pie offer fantastic flavor with melting sugar granules and fresh apple notes. Whipped peanut butter pie feels light, almost like a cloud.

People are saying

"The cakes here are out of this world delicious."

"The food here was delicious and excellent."

"I found the pies, like the caramel apple, absolutely delicious."

Good to know

1

The café offers a lunch combo of croissant and soup for $28 before tip.

2

A bowl of soup costs nearly $8, which may not be adequate for some.

3

Expect to pay extra for gluten-free options on the menu.

08
Café Babette image 1
Pastry shop

Pastry shop offers over 15 uniquely crafted baked goods with a simple, unadorned layout featuring old mismatched tables and no labels. Atmosphere feels laid-back and comforting with a bustling, positive energy especially on busy days. No eat-in service or coffee is available, and waiting or preordering is common due to high demand.

Cakes feature exceptional icing and artistic decoration that impress visually and in taste. Varieties like coconut and brown butter lemon curd offer balanced sweetness and elegant textures.

Blueberry hand pie features a crunchy outside and soft inside with orange icing. Cherry sumac pie lacks quality compared to cheaper options. Other desserts like croissants and brownies also stand out.

People are saying

"I found the pastries here to be amazing and thoughtfully executed."

"This bakery is the best I've had outside of Europe."

"The blueberry hand pie is high quality and crunchy."

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering is recommended to avoid long waits on weekends.

2

Expect long lines, especially on Saturdays and holidays.

3

Arrive early to secure pastries before they sell out.

Discover more

Indiana

Area guide
Loading Map...