Papa’s Pizza
9.0 • Pizza restaurant
Old-school pizza parlor with a cozy, family-owned atmosphere and authentic Italian flavor. The place stays open late and welcomes custom orders beyond the menu. Known for high-quality ingredients and standout Sicilian slices.
View menu
"I thought the Sicilian pizza here was the best I ever tasted."
80
"It's a great family owned business."
4
"This Chicken Parmigiana hero was the best I've ever had."
1
Good to know
1
They are open late for evening cravings.
2
Both slices cost $7, making it affordable.
3
Custom orders are available even if not on the menu.
199 Merritts Rd, Farmingdale, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Wah’s Garden Kitchen
Small, quaint takeout spot known for clean, quality Chinese cuisine with ample parking and a loyal following.
East Eats
Popular spot known for generous portions and a wide variety of Asian dishes, including Ramen and Thai food.
G & L Bagels
Cozy bagel shop with a family-like atmosphere, featuring dark furniture and a compact, inviting space.
