Papa’s Pizza
Family-owned pizzeria with a cozy old-school vibe, serving custom Neapolitan and Sicilian slices.
NO.1 DISCOVERYAPP 2026
South Farmingdale
Explore over 50 places in South Farmingdale, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.
Powered by millions of opinions
UPDATED MAR 30, 2026
Popular in your area
G & L Bagels
Cozy bagel shop with a family-like atmosphere, featuring dark furniture and a compact, inviting space.
It's About Time Cocktail Lounge
Quaint local cocktail lounge with vibrant, welcoming atmosphere, comfy couches, and a friendly, energetic crowd.
D & D Bakery
Family-owned bakery renowned for authentic Argentine sandwiches and a beautiful interior, offering customizable cakes and pastries.
Wah’s Garden Kitchen
Small, quaint takeout spot known for clean, quality Chinese cuisine with ample parking and a loyal following.