Rolling Pin
8.7 • Bakery
Wide-ranging old-fashioned scratch bakery with on-site fresh baking daily and outdoor cafe tables. Atmosphere feels authentic and well-decorated, drawing consistent crowds without fanfare. Known for beautiful, delicious cakes and standout pastries like pecan pie and scones.
View menu
"The wedding cake from this bakery was delicious and beautifully presented."
52
"The cake here is beautiful and tasted amazing."
25
"The croissants here are flaky, soft, and delicious."
5
Good to know
1
Rolling Pin offers free tastings for wedding orders.
2
Delivery is reliable and on time for all orders.
3
There is no option to eat inside the bakery.
1387 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, New York, United States
