Setauket- East Setauket

Explore over 400 places in Setauket- East Setauket, New York for coffee, date spots, drinks, and more, all curated by locals on Atly.

UPDATED MAY 15, 2026

Best lists

You have a standard for what you put on your plate and you aren't willing to lower it.

15 curated spots

A place where children can be themselves while everyone stays comfortable.

8 curated spots

Finding a quiet corner to decompress is a necessity, not a luxury.

5 curated spots

Bright, roomy deli with a casual atmosphere and friendly staff, renowned for its exceptional sandwiches.

Beautiful new restaurant with open glass garage doors creating a chill, outdoor-feel atmosphere and great vibes.

Charming, immaculate small diner with a cozy, family-like atmosphere and scenic water views.

Small, impressively clean deli with a warm, welcoming atmosphere and endless excellent selections.

Authentic bakery known for fresh daily baking and expertly decorated treats, delivering reliable, professional service.