Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to Setauket-East Setauket

Food spots

You have a standard for what you put on your plate and you aren't willing to lower it.

Based on 727 Opinions
+724
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mo's Island Spice Authentic Jamaican Cuisine image 1
Mo's Island Spice Authentic Jamaican Cuisine image 2
Mo's Island Spice Authentic Jamaican Cuisine image 3
View all

Small, colorful space offers a cozy, homey vibe with soft reggae music setting a relaxing mood. Bright, vibrant decor and aroma of Caribbean spices create an inviting atmosphere. Guests enjoy authentic Jamaican cuisine with oxtail and jerk chicken that is rich and bold, packed with real, soulful flavors.

Food here is rich and bold, packed with authentic Jamaican flavors that feel homemade and comforting. Every dish is cooked properly, delivering real, soulful Caribbean cuisine with consistent quality and great service.

People are saying

"The Jamaican food here is authentic, flavorful, and packed with bold taste."

"The Jerk Chicken here is moist and has just the right amount of seasoning."

"Mo is so kind and embodies a cheerful spirit."

Good to know

1

Parking is plentiful and easily accessible near the restaurant.

2

Prices are reasonable for the portion sizes offered.

3

Expect some items to sell out by early afternoon, especially oxtail.

02
Mezze Mediterranean Grill image 1

Mediterranean grill offers authentic Turkish cuisine with generous portions that arrive hot and fast. Cozy indoor seating feels welcoming but tables are limited and uncomfortable, encouraging quick meals. Outdoor area suits takeout well, blending comfort with efficiency.

Mediterranean food here is consistently delicious, fresh, and served in generous portions. Delivery arrives fast and the food stays hot.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

"The Mediterranean dinner spots here are phenomenal, especially the mixed grill."

"The chicken gyro wrap was packed with authentic flavor and cooked perfectly."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is mainly set up for takeout, with limited dine-in options.

2

Everything is made to order, using fresh ingredients and halal meat.

3

The portions are generous, providing good value for the price.

03
Vincent’s_NYWF_Pizza image 1

Wood-fired pizza cooks fast from a mobile setup with a woodburning oven. Guests enjoy making their own pies, adding a fun, custom pizza touch. Lively music and dance playlists create a party atmosphere that suits events well.

Food truck serves custom pizzas and lets guests make their own. It offers easy setup for events and delivers food that everyone enjoys.

People are saying

"The pizza here is delicious with a perfectly crispy crust."

"The pizza kept coming all day long for the party!"

"The food here is delicious and fresh."

Good to know

1

Vincent's NYWF Pizza Food Truck offers a variety of pizza options for events.

2

The team is known for excellent service and professionalism during events.

3

Vincent's accommodates various dietary preferences and restrictions.

04
Right Coast Taqueria Setauket image 1

Glass garage doors create an outdoor feel while loud music sets a fun atmosphere. Food tastes like home cooked meals with fresh ingredients and adjustable spice levels. Generous portions and great tacos make it perfect for relaxed dining.

Food tastes like a home cooked meal with fresh, perfectly cooked ingredients. Options exist to adjust spice levels by substituting or omitting ingredients.

People are saying

"I thought the food was great, especially the specialty tacos."

"I thought the queso was exceptional and flavorful."

"The fish tacos with mango salsa were delicious."

Good to know

1

Burritos cost $5-6 after 8pm on Fridays and Saturdays.

2

Expect a clean environment with visible kitchen staff maintaining hygiene.

3

There is plenty of parking available in the Kohl's lot.

05
Pumpernickels Delicatessen and Market image 1

Small deli offers phenomenal chicken cutlets and perfectly cooked bacon on homemade bread. Staff deliver excellent service in a warm, clean space. Prices stay reasonable, making it a great spot for fresh, creative sandwiches.

Food comes fresh and delicious with creative sandwiches on homemade bread. Staff provide excellent service and prices stay reasonable.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious and always fresh."

"They went out of their way to deliver my missing sandwich."

"The Deli staff here is so friendly and helpful."

Good to know

1

Condiments must be ordered through DoorDash; they are not available in-store.

2

The deli offers a wide variety of food options for all tastes.

3

The store is clean and well-organized, enhancing the shopping experience.

06
Setauket Village Diner Restaurant image 1

Cozy diner offers a family-like atmosphere with a roomy, immaculate interior. Food is fresh daily and served quickly, keeping quality high. Charming vibe makes it a tucked away gem for casual meals.

Food comes out fresh daily and tastes consistently great. Meals arrive quickly and maintain high quality every visit.

People are saying

"I found the diner food to be great."

"The food and staff here make it a great spot for a date."

"I found the food here to be fresh and delicious."

Good to know

1

Breakfast is served all day, offering a variety of options.

2

The diner has a large menu selection with daily specials.

3

Expect to pay around $50 for two medium Greek salads with chicken.

07
Sichuan Garden image 1
Chinese restaurant

Small restaurant offers authentic Sichuan cuisine with astonishingly fresh flavors and generous portions. Beautiful décor and calm jazz create a relaxed and elegant atmosphere. Regulars are mostly Chinese, adding to the authentic dining experience.

Food here is astonishingly fresh and flavorful, with generous portions. The menu focuses on authentic Sichuan cuisine that stands out for its quality and taste.

People are saying

"The authentic Sichuan Chinese food here is amazing, especially the Mapo Tofu."

"You have to try the soup dumplings; they're yum yum in your tum tum."

"The food here is amazing and so authentic."

Good to know

1

There is free parking available with more space towards the back.

2

Their weekday lunch specials offer a lot of food at a good price.

3

The portion sizes at Sichuan Garden are generous.

08
Play à La Mode image 1
Indoor playground

Indoor playground feels like a cozy village with themed areas like gym and grocery store. Food features custom-themed dishes with strawberry accents, and outside food is allowed. Space is immaculately clean and safe, perfect for kids to play while parents relax.

Food includes custom-themed dishes like strawberry accents for birthday parties. They manage all food aspects but also allow bringing outside food for adults and children.

People are saying

"This place is so kid-friendly; they handled every detail of the party!"

"They handled all aspects of the party, including the food."

"This place is Baby-Friendly; they handle all the decorations and food for you."

Good to know

1

The venue is clean and well-kept, ensuring a safe play environment for kids.

2

They offer flexible event spaces suitable for various party needs.

3

Parents can bring outside food for both kids and adults during events.

09
Bango Bowls - East Setauket image 1
Health food restaurant

Bright space serves fresh acai bowls with healthy fruit toppings and granola. Staff offers knowledgeable service in a clean, affordable setting. Quick seating makes it ideal for fast, nutritious meals.

Food here is consistently fresh and delicious with a focus on healthy options. Presentation is appealing and the staff is knowledgeable about the menu.

People are saying

"I found the healthy food options here to be really yummy and fresh."

"I found the food options here to be pretty healthy."

Good to know

1

Bango Bowls offers fresh, fast, and healthy food options.

2

The prices are affordable for the quality of food provided.

3

Seating is available for customers at Bango Bowls.

10
5 Brothers Chicken & Waffles image 1

Enjoy flavorful fried chicken and waffles served fresh with generous portions. Family-friendly space stays super clean and offers reasonable prices. Food prep takes about 15 minutes, making it a great spot for comfort food lovers.

Food comes out fresh and offers great value with generous portions. The quality and taste stand out, making the wait reasonable.

People are saying

"The chicken and waffles here are perfectly fried and fluffy."

"I'd rate the Banana Pudding higher if I could."

"The food here is amazing, especially the juicy chicken and perfect waffles."

Good to know

1

Ordering ahead is recommended to avoid long wait times.

2

The food takes about 15 minutes to prepare.

3

Prices are very reasonable, with meals averaging around $16.

11
Se-port Delicatessen image 1

Deli offers large sandwiches packed with flavor and a massive selection of fresh deli foods. Space is roomy and well-lit with a casual vibe and friendly staff. Perfect for Long Island comfort food at breakfast and lunch.

Massive selection of fresh deli foods includes many sandwich options, hot food, and a salad bar. Great for Long Island comfort food at breakfast and lunch with consistently great taste.

People are saying

"The food here is great, with generous portions."

"I thought their sandwiches were delicious and hearty."

"The salads here are delicious and the portions are generous."

Good to know

1

Se-port Delicatessen offers a huge selection of sandwiches and deli items.

2

Portions are king size, so come with a big appetite.

3

The deli maintains very clean floors and food areas.

12
Via Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Small seating area offers an intimate setting with a casual vibe. Variety of New York-style pizzas and specialty slices deliver bold flavors. Reasonable prices and large portions make it a solid neighborhood spot with outstanding food and easy counter service.

Outstanding food and counter service create a casual and easy dining experience. Some dishes show extra effort in preparation and flavor.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was delicious and great."

"Their delivery staff go the extra mile and are so pleasant."

"The pizza here is delicious, with huge slices."

Good to know

1

The pies are very large, so count heads accordingly.

2

There are many topping options available at the counter.

3

The restaurant offers a variety of pizza, pasta, dishes, and salads.

13
Setauket Gourmet Deli and Catering image 1

Deli serves fresh sandwiches and egg dishes with outstanding service in a warm, inviting space. Staff are friendly and attentive, creating a timeless community staple. Food is reasonably priced and always arrives on time.

Food arrives fresh and on time with outstanding service including help with setup. The menu offers delicious, reasonably priced dishes that consistently earn compliments.

People are saying

"Carl makes the best sandwiches and knows what he's doing."

"Carl makes custom food to order and knows what he's doing."

"I thought the egg sandwich was a perfect 10 out of 10."

Good to know

1

The deli opens early, making it a great breakfast spot.

2

Expect to pay around $11.50 for a breakfast combo with coffee.

3

The deli is known for its great breakfast selection.

14
Wild By Nature image 1
Supermarket

Supermarket offers a peaceful atmosphere with a maze-like layout and eco-conscious design. It features a great selection of natural and organic foods, especially for vegetarian and vegan diets. Prices are high but unique specialty items make it worth visiting.

Selection focuses on natural and organic foods with a decent range of gourmet items like cheeses and fresh produce. Hot food options exist but may lack freshness later in the day.

People are saying

"I found the natural and organic food selection to be great."

"I found unique, natural, and environmentally friendly items here."

Good to know

1

Expect higher prices compared to nearby grocery stores for organic products.

2

Wild By Nature offers a unique selection of specialty items not found elsewhere.

3

The store is particularly good for vegetarians and vegans seeking diverse options.

15
Bagel Express image 1
Bagel shop

Small bagel shop offers oversized fresh bagels and great breakfast sandwiches with quality ingredients. Cozy, old school deli vibe with local sports memorabilia on walls creates a welcoming atmosphere. Rush hours bring a chaotic, crowded energy, while quiet times feel relaxed.

Food features fresh bagels, great breakfast sandwiches, and quality ingredients. The food is consistently delicious and served quickly.

People are saying

"I found the bagels here to be the best around."

"The egg sandwiches here are perfect, with eggs and bacon that don't slide off."

"I found the food here to be delicious and always fresh."

Good to know

1

Online ordering is available for convenience, especially during busy times.

2

Expect to pay around $40 for a meal for three people.

3

Toasting a bagel costs an additional $2.

Discover more

Setauket- East Setauket, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...