New Yorkers 1st Choice
The Pie at Salvatore's image 1
The Pie at Salvatore's image 2
The Pie at Salvatore's image 3

The Pie at Salvatore's

9.0 • Pizza restaurant
🛋️ Cozy
🥘 Food
🍕 Pizza
🍞 Bread
🍕 Calzone
🥗 Salad
🇮🇹 Italian Food
💎 Hidden Gems
🥙 Greek Salad
🇬🇷 Greek Food
🦞 Seafood
🧆 Meatballs
🍕 Neapolitan Pizza
💘 Date Spots
🍽️ Lunch Spot
More
Cozy dining space with a friendly atmosphere and freshly baked pizza aroma fills the room. The place suits casual family meals and offers whole pies only, creating a communal vibe. Seating can feel cramped but service is attentive and quick for groups.
View menu

Good to know

1

Reservations are not required, and large groups can be seated quickly.

2

Extra toppings on pizzas incur additional charges.

3

The menu only offers whole pies, no slices available.

Map showing 120 E Main St
The Pie at Salvatore's
9.0
120 E Main St, Bay Shore, New York, United States
Discovery made simple

Explore 91K locations in NYC!

I have been using it now for 3 months and it saves me so much research. Reduces the need to call and double check every time.

Michael L.
Michael L.Adventurous Diner

How did I not know these places existed?! Atly's scoring is a lifesaver, now I can finally find THE spot without wasting time Googling my life away.

Clara D.
Clara D.Frequent Traveler