The Pie at Salvatore's
9.0 • Pizza restaurant
Cozy dining space with a friendly atmosphere and freshly baked pizza aroma fills the room. The place suits casual family meals and offers whole pies only, creating a communal vibe. Seating can feel cramped but service is attentive and quick for groups.
View menu
"The food here is amazing, with fresh, top-notch ingredients."
24
"I thought the pizza here was the best on Long Island."
8
"It's so charming and cozy inside."
4
Good to know
1
Reservations are not required, and large groups can be seated quickly.
2
Extra toppings on pizzas incur additional charges.
3
The menu only offers whole pies, no slices available.
120 E Main St, Bay Shore, New York, United States
Check out lists where this place stands out
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Victorio's Pizza
Casual eatery known for pizza and diverse menu specials, serving the community with reliable fare.
Bono's Pizzeria
Old-school pizzeria with a great crust and high-quality ingredients, offering a friendly, homey atmosphere.
Bruno's Pizzeria & Restaurant
Small, friendly restaurant known for its pizza with a reputation for great value despite higher prices.
