The American Hotel
8.7 • Hotel
Historic building offers old-world charm with a spooky, quaint atmosphere. Bar area fills with a lively crowd sharing laughs and conversations, while the restaurant buzzes with piano music and energy. Setting suits special occasions and romantic dates.
View menu
"The food and wine here are perfect for Date Spots."
8
"It's a classy historical building with old-world charm."
6
"It's a timeless escape with old-school vibes and classic drinks."
5
Good to know
1
Reservations are recommended for dining, especially on weekends.
2
Expect entrees to cost over $40 each at the restaurant.
3
The restaurant offers a 20% discount on the total bill occasionally.
45 Main St #3012, Sag Harbor, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Sag Harbor Cinema
Charming vintage cinema with modern comfy seats, rooftop bar, and thoughtfully curated film programming.
Long Wharf Wines & Spirits
Well-stocked shop offering a diverse selection of wines and spirits, highly recommended by patrons.
LT Burger Sag Harbor
Casual, retro-inspired diner with a lively, cheerful atmosphere and charming outdoor seating on main street.
