The Penny Pub
8.6 • Restaurant
Interior offers homey vibes with a clean, friendly environment and cool design. Activities like pool, darts, and huge Jenga add to a fun, relaxed atmosphere that supports conversation without loud music. Open late, it attracts a mix of people looking for casual eating and a good time.
View menu
"I found the food here to be amazing."
8
"The bartender Sean made me feel welcome and at ease at this pub."
5
"The beer here is ice cold and poured properly."
5
Good to know
1
Happy Hour runs from 3pm to 6pm with $1 off all drafts.
2
A flight special on Mondays offers four drinks for $14.
3
The pub is open late, perfect for a relaxed evening.
79 W Main St, Bay Shore, New York, United States
Similar places nearby
A few nearby places worth checking next.
Mustang Sally's
Classic local Irish pub with reasonably priced food and sports, featuring a clean, fun atmosphere.
Napper Tandy’s
Spacious, clean two-floor venue with multiple TVs, outdoor seating, and a beautifully decorated private event room.
Magnolias
Charming, quaint cocktail bar with a West Village vibe, offering fantastic food and drinks in an intimate setting.
