Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of New York

Shrimp po boys

A shrimp po boy that respects the integrity of the fried seafood instead of burying it in an oversized, flavorless bun.

Based on 518 Opinions
+515
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Cap’t Loui - 32nd st, NY image 1
Cap’t Loui - 32nd st, NY image 2
Cap’t Loui - 32nd st, NY image 3
View all

Seafood restaurant offers spacious, well-designed interior with immaculate cleanliness and thoughtful amenities like handwashing stations and mouthwash. Atmosphere carries a strong Cajun spice aroma, creating a lively yet clean vibe. Guests enjoy highly praised seafood boils and lobster rolls alongside a selection of soju and beer.

Fresh ingredients and authentic Cajun seafood flavors stand out here. Plates come beautifully presented with a taste that is hard to find elsewhere.

Shrimp po boy sandwiches come very filling with a seafood boil option. Flavor varies, with some finding it pretty good and others noting a lack of flavor.

People are saying

"The seafood is fresh and perfectly seasoned with a tasty garlic sauce."

"I had an amazing time and highly recommend this seafood spot."

"The staff are friendly and attentive, making the visit enjoyable."

Good to know

1

Oyster special on Tuesdays costs $1.50 each.

2

Lunch specials are available from 12pm to 3pm.

3

Happy hour features discounted oysters on Tuesdays.

02
Lowerline image 1
Lowerline image 2
Lowerline image 3
View all

Small space with intimate setting and New Orleans charm offers authentic Louisiana comfort food like gumbo and crawfish etouffee. Shrimp po' boy shines with balanced Cajun flavors. Cozy indoor and outdoor seating stays dry even in rain.

Dishes like gumbo, crawfish etouffee, and red beans & rice deliver authentic New Orleans flavors with the right amount of heat and seasoning. The menu offers Louisiana comfort food that stays true to its roots.

The shrimp po' boy features perfectly balanced Cajun flavors without being too peppery or salty. It pairs well with the roast beef version and stands out as a delicious sandwich option.

People are saying

"I loved the authentic New Orleans flavors in the gumbo and red beans."

"The food truly captures authentic New Orleans flavors."

"This Shrimp Po Boy offers authentic New Orleans flavors."

Good to know

1

The oyster happy hour is from 5:30 to 6:30 PM with half-off oysters.

2

Seating is limited if you want to sit indoors.

3

You can order half portions of most entrees for easy sampling.

03
NBHD Brulee image 1
NBHD Brulee image 2
NBHD Brulee image 3
View all

Spacious coffee shop with Cajun French aesthetic and covered outdoor seating that feels cozy and inviting. Warm atmosphere combines with good music and plenty of outlets, making it suitable for work or socializing. The vibe is relaxed and artistic, creating a sense of community and belonging.

Shrimp po boys come with fresh, high-quality ingredients and pack a lot of flavor. The grilled version tastes delicious and stands out among the dishes.

People are saying

"I loved the tasty food and great coffee here."

"The vibe is chill with cool art and comfy seats."

"The Cajun dishes had hits and misses for me."

Good to know

1

The establishment offers a variety of breakfast and lunch options, and drinks.

2

You can dine in, sit outside, or take food to go.

3

The coffee shop is located at the heart of Harlem.

04
Aqua Boil image 1
Aqua Boil image 2
Aqua Boil image 3
View all

Nautical boathouse design sets a cozy mood with dim lighting and lively music. Seafood boils burst with authentic Cajun seasoning and come in bags for a fun, informal meal. Shrimp po' boys pack a generous filling with a strong sauce that dominates flavor.

Seafood boils here feature authentic Cajun seasoning and flavorful spices. Lobster rolls and boils taste extremely tasty and true to Cajun style.

People are saying

"The seafood boil was fresh and perfectly spicy."

"The food was tasty and the vibe upbeat."

"I found the seafood boil here to be authentic and perfectly seasoned."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for dinner, especially between 6-8 PM.

2

Happy hour drinks are $6 all day from Monday to Thursday.

3

From Friday to Sunday, happy hour drinks are $6 before 7 PM.

05
1803 NYC image 1
1803 NYC image 2
1803 NYC image 3
View all

Live jazz bands create a mellow atmosphere that matches the modern southern, rustic decor. Shrimp Po Boy is tasty and filling, served with fries and hot sauce. Food hints at New Orleans but lacks authentic Cajun flavors.

Food shows some New Orleans flavors but lacks authentic Cajun or Creole dishes. Shrimp Etoufféé and Jambalaya taste bland and do not match traditional Louisiana recipes.

People are saying

"I loved the flavorful food and lively vibe here."

"The prices felt a bit high but fair overall."

"The spinach artichoke dip was creamy and tasty."

Good to know

1

Live music is available on weekends from noon to 3 PM.

2

Happy hour specials include $2 off drinks; arrive early for the best selection.

3

Reservations are required for dinner on Saturday evenings.

06
Strange Delight image 1
Strange Delight image 2
Strange Delight image 3
View all

Open kitchen and New Orleans style decor create a spacious, welcoming atmosphere with lively energy. Unique cooking techniques highlight seafood dishes, complemented by notable cocktails like martinis and clarified Mary mix. Music and communal dining encourage a fun, social vibe.

Fried shrimp po boys feature a perfectly crispy coating and juicy meat. They stand out as some of the best in the city.

People are saying

"The seafood tastes great and the vibe is unique."

"Their cocktails pack a flavorful punch."

"The fried shrimp po' boy has a perfectly crispy coating and juicy meat."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for large group events to ensure availability.

2

Happy hour offers discounted drinks and appetizers from 4-6pm on weekdays.

3

Expect a wait time of up to 20 minutes for parking in the area.

07
Filé Gumbo Bar image 1
Filé Gumbo Bar image 2
Filé Gumbo Bar image 3
View all

Open concept bar and live jazz trio create a lively, somewhat loud atmosphere with a trendy, upscale decor featuring mustard yellow accents. The space draws a crowd seeking authentic Creole cuisine and vibrant flavors, with music often parading through the dining area. Seating is assigned and intimate, enhancing the energetic yet cozy vibe.

Food delivers authentic New Orleans flavors with dishes reflecting true Louisiana soul food. The atmosphere matches the cuisine, offering a genuine Cajun vibe throughout the experience.

Fresh bread and crispy shrimp define the shrimp Po Boy here. The sandwich holds together well and delivers a solid, classic taste.

People are saying

"I found the authentic Cajun-Creole flavors to be bold and soul-satisfying."

"I love how the food captures authentic New Orleans flavors."

"Some dishes tasted authentic, others didn’t."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

The restaurant will have a jazz trio and parade every weekend.

3

Their happy hour is from 3-6pm with specialty cocktails for $12.

08
Sea To Soul Harlem image 1
Sea To Soul Harlem image 2
Sea To Soul Harlem image 3
View all

Small, unassuming seafood spot with a welcoming atmosphere and strong sangria at a cozy bar area. Music ranges from loud to chill, creating a lively yet friendly vibe. Offers hookah service and sports on large screens, blending casual dining with entertainment.

People are saying

"The vibe is cozy and the soul food rocks."

"The food is fresh, tasty, and affordable."

"The seafood tastes perfectly seasoned and delicious."

Good to know

1

The restaurant has lunch specials, like catfish and fries for $10.

2

You can order takeout or dine in at the restaurant.

3

The entree includes one meat and two sides.

Discover more

New York, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...