Top 18 Gluten-Free Italian Spots to Delight in Fort Myers

Ms. Jade Alexis

First time I’m downtown Ft. Myers and I ordered the gluten free cheese pizza and it did NOT disappoint! I imagined being gluten free it would taste mediocre boy was I wrong. If I could give 10stars I would. The waitress however was lackluster. She got my drink order wrong. I asked for Mezcal and she brought me a glass of Moscato. After the mixup she advised Mezcal is only served on certain days 🤔. I ordered an Old fashioned and it was garbage. I waited 40 minutes for my food and only saw her 3 times. Once to take my drink order, once to take my food order and then to bring the check. It was a Thursday night and the tables were pretty empty so it wasn’t due to the crowd. I still would go again for the amazing tasting pizza and stick with a glass of wine! 🍕

Jill S

Gluten free vegan options are even really great

Elizabeth Thew

Our kids are picky eaters and they absolutely loved the pizza here. We got gluten free pizza bases with vegan cheese and it was all lovely! The kids were chatting with the staff who were great with them and very accommodating. We loved the food and service and will definitely return any time we are in the Fort Myers area!

Vince G

I agree with the other reviewers who felt this is one of the better Italian restaurants in the area. Had the House Favorite with Sausage which was excellent. I appreciate they offer Gluten Free pasta and pizza since that expands my options. Portions were big and prices very reasonable. Server checked on us often. Looking forward to going back.

Elizabeth Trempert

We had the sweetest server tonight and the best slring sangria ever. Its always a pleasure! Mind you we are a couple where one is vegan and one is gluten free and we always eat so well here

A M

Feeding the Hangry and the Heroic So there I was—lunchless, hungry, and dangerously close to turning into the kind of person who snaps at motivational work posters. Despite my well-documented aversion to unsolicited human interaction, I found myself at McGregor Pizza & Deli, where society and carbs collide in the best possible way. Why? Because my operating dojo was teeming with surgical tech ninjas—dedicated, scrappy, potentially hormonal, and suspiciously eager to stay after hours for more practice. Or hazing. Depends on the lighting and legal definitions. I needed to feed them before their inner beasts turned on me, so I ordered seven assorted pizzas. Seven. Because apparently I enjoy lifting pizza boxes with a back that served three tours when there was an actual war. Enter McGregor’s staff: fast, friendly, and blessedly unbothered by my general disdain for small talk. Not only did they whip up pizzas that could make a gluten-free monk reconsider their life choices, they also noticed my service-connected Marine Corps-certified spine and kindly carried the pies to my vehicle. Actual heroes in a world of people who still ask if I want to sign up for their rewards program, and I did. And the pizza? Hot, cheesy, meaty, and appropriately sacrificial—each slice laid down its life to tame the dojo beasts. Flavors? Bold. Crust? The right balance of crunch and chew. Sauce? A righteous splash of tangy salvation. Bottom line: McGregor Pizza & Deli is the unsung MVP of hunger emergencies and late-night practice sustenance. If you’re antisocial, hangry, heroic, or just in desperate need of seven pizzas and a little human decency—this is your spot. Five stars. Would return. Preferably with fewer ninjas next time. Full-grown adults get expensive!

Magellan

Nasty nasty nasty - Andre, the OWNER was already distasteful over the phone when I called to ask if they had gluten free pasta. They do; so I decide to drive over. When I arrived and asked questions about the food ingredients of certain entrees, he told me to leave! Verbatim. When I asked why, he said I was giving him an attitude by wanting/ ordering the food to my specifications.

Nicole Sherrill

Love this place. Staff and management are great. Food is wonderful. They were very helpful with our gluten allergies.

sarah Machado

Great gluten free pizza on customer service

Miss R

Best gluten free pizza around. Love that they cook it in its own separate foil pan to prevent cross contamination. Amazing quality ingredients and always fresh!

Bill Gould

Our server Viloria was the best! And Manager John visited our table to discuss gluten free options and pleasantries as well! An excellent dining experience!

Larry Agee

Good traditional pizza place. Great gluten free pizza

Lori Angelilli

Fantastic meal and the service was top notch. This was our first time there and we will definitely go back. I have to follow a gluten free diet and there were many options to choose from. Our waitress chose a great wine for us based on our description of what we like and the serving size was generous. 5 stars!!

Mr. T

Great place to go to eat at. Everything is just perfect about this restaurant, its food(which is more than likely gonna fill you up), its atmosphere, and its service(kudos Zachary), .If you have anybody that has lactose and gluten intolerants (like my son), they have pasta and probably more that you can eat.You just need to ask the waiter.Again ,this is just an over all awesome place to eat at. If you go there, you’ll definitely have a great time. “ buon cibo”

Marty O’Hern

If you have a gluten sensitivity this is the place for pizza!

Irma Canterbury

Becky Slack

We were with a group & randomly chose this restaurant when the place we were originally going ended up being closed. Being gluten intolerant I was happy to find that they do offer a gluten free pasta option that can be substituted into any of the main pasta dishes as well as several gluten free dessert options. I chose the Penne Alla Vodka- the dish was absolutely robust in flavor & satisfying. The menu was pricey however the prices for the superior quality of the food, portions & staff experience were in line & well worth it. I was also pleased with the care taken to ensure no gluten cross contamination. Our group; 9 in total, totally enjoyed our meals as well as the dining experience with great staff & atmosphere.

Katherine Darrell

Went with friends and had a wonderful meal - I had aglio e olio - gluten free pasta - amazing. The special for the evening was Osso Buco with veal - I had to order it to go because it is my husbands favorite! Even re heated the followin evening it was "devine" per my husband. We will go back!