Top 12 Gluten-Free Italian Spots to Delight in Key West

Miles Arnott

Absolutely delicious Italian fare! I had the Rigatoni with jumbo shrimp and my wife had the chicken Alfredo with fresh gluten free pasta. Amazing! Highly recommend.

jimi v

They make their own gluten free pizza.. So good

Thomas Buffa

Great little place right off Duval. Our server, Jess was super friendly and knew the menu like the back of her hand. Gluten free options a plenty! The Gluten Free pizza with homemade dough, is amazing! Stopped in a few times this last trip to KW and will return on our next trip.

Charmy Patel

Angelina's Pizzeria is, by far, the best pizza place I've ever been to. Not only do they serve incredible pizza, but they also offer gluten-free options, making it accessible for everyone. This place is very famous, and for good reason! The location is great, adding to the overall experience. One of the best parts is the ability to customize your pizza with whatever toppings you desire. I highly recommend Angelina's Pizzeria to any pizza lover out there!

Jonathan Brett

Went here specifically for its GF offering. Service was very poor but the food was great. Once we managed to get seated and got both menus we were offered some fresh bread but though we’d ordered Gluten Free pasta, when asked, the waitress said no, its not GF, we don’t have GF bread, ok why offer it to us then (here’s something you can’t eat). My food was brought and the pasta was cold so had to send it back, my wife’s food was brought but was the wrong dish, the waitress even said we don’t have a pasta dish with Italian sausage in but when we showed her the menu she apologised as they did. So now I have hot food my wife has no food, so rather than have them make mine a third time I ate my food and I was 90% finished by the time my wife’s food arrived. So manage expectations on service and you’ll be happy. Disappointing that they didn’t offer a coffee of something by way of an apology for a poor dining experience.

Mike Heck

My wife and children wanted to take me out for my birthday for Italian eats and La Trattoria did not disappoint. There were accommodating when we requested to move tables. Non c'e problema! My daughter was a little chilly and they gave her a small tablecloth to wear as a 'cape'. How caring and accommodating! The wait staff was friendly and fast. The food was excellent. My son enjoyed his fettuccine Alfredo, my little girl had buttered noodles with chicken and was very happy. Both of them loved the bread and were a little adventurous in trying the oil/vinegar/parmesan dip. Belissima! My wife's gluten free penne was tasty and my tortellini with sweet sausage was very on point. All that said, they totally blew us away with a surprise desert (at no charge! when does that happen here?). The Tira Misu was TO DIE FOR and they basically put a fireworks show on top of it. The entire restaurant sang to me and I was completely taken aback (see photo). This was hands-down the best dining experience we've had in a long long time. Coming on the heels of not great experience at another Italian place we realized that sometimes you have to go through some not great stuff to get to the promised land. Recommend, highly recommend La Trattoria. GRAZIE MILLE!!!!! P.S. No I don't wear the same shirt for all my reviews lol, just a coincidence.

Joshua Gathings

Terrific place for Italian food, delicious pizza, pasta, and even seafood! Gluten-free pasta substitutes available. Many ingredients from Italy used and the 1000° 🔥 oven for the best cooked pizza 🍕 on the island! This is a taste of Italy down in Key West! With 2 convenient locations on the island, it is a must try!! Loved the outside courtyard seating with low light made it very intimate and personable. Will be back!

DB Cooper

Why is the Health Department blind to this dirty, filthy, old dump that looks And smells bad. Staff have no uniformity or hair nets and they touch ready to serve food with dirty ungloved bare hands. Dirty filthy fan in the window. Food is time temperature abused and cross contaminated like everything fried in same contaminated fryer oil. Nobody wearing single use gloves. Nobody regularly washing their hands even after taking orders or touching money, then preparing and bagging orders with same contaminated hands. Way over priced for such a poor quality place that's usually overcrowded. Mostly drunk people or people unconcerned about their health and wellbeing eat there to get sick. And thankfully No Options for Vegans or Gluten Free Customers...

John Medeiros

We were at the Happy Rooster across the street and was talking With Daniel and his wife. Asked them if they had knowledge of gluten free restaurants in the area and he brought us across the street to Bruschtta Francesca introduced us to the owner Francesca. Lovely woman and had us seated immediately. Made our choices for dinner (7 of us ). Food came very soon after ordering . Everything was excellent high quality Italian food with the freshest of ingredients and the bread in house made was the best. Being from New England we have the knowledge of quality Italian food . Francesca and her staff treated us as if we were locals and were patrons since they opened for business. If you want quality Italian food in Key West this is the place. Thank you again Francesca !!!

Jamie R

Great food! I love the gluten free pizza!

Laura R

This place is a hidden gem. My husband and l stayed in Key West for 5 days, we ate here twice!!! The outside is gorgeous, the staff and owner is very friendly. The food is OUT OF THIS WORLD!! They have AMAZING gluten free pasta which is a huge plus. This is the place to come! Will definitely return. Everything 10/10 ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Mellissa Buddenhagen

Omgsh great food..definitely will return.. Great gluten free options! Great views and pricing was great!