Edgar's Cafe

Restaurant
Gluten-free options
GF Options
Breakfast
Lunch
Dinner
More
This cafe's cozy antique decor and unique Edgar Allan Poe theme create a distinctive, relaxing atmosphere. The enclosed outdoor seating area welcomes dogs, making it a comfortable spot for those seeking a gluten-free friendly environment with attentive service and a neighborhood feel.

Good to know

1

They offer many gluten-free options including bread, pasta, and desserts.

2

Expect a $5 minimum order per person.

3

Parking availability is not mentioned, so plan accordingly.

650 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10025, USA
2.4km

People are saying

A
Delicious gluten free pasta and shrimp avocado salad! Waitress was so attentive and kind!
A
Used to like this place, but this time had a frightening experience with the owner. It was almost 10pm and I went with two of my friends because I was hungry, it has gluten free options, and I have celiac. My friends were nice to enough to share a pasta with me before we got dessert. The cheese for the pasta was served with the regular bread, so I asked for separate cheese that did not come into contact with gluten. Suddenly the the owner who was sitting behind us started yelling for 15 minutes nonstop about how dare I ask for more cheese and how we aren’t allowed to have one pasta for 3 people. He was very upset and kept shouting “three girls, 1 pasta”. We paid and left without eating it because he was standing up and yelling at us, it was quite unpleasant.
B
We have been regulars here for several years and absolutely adore it. It's a charming local spot that instantly transports you to Italy. The owner and staff are incredibly friendly and have become like family to us. They go out of their way to cater to families and are very accommodating to children. The menu offers a wide range of delicious options, including gluten-free choices for those with dietary restrictions. Whether you're looking for a brunch or dinner, you'll find fresh ingredients and affordable prices here. It's truly a gem!

Featured in Lists

Top 18 Gluten-Free Dining Spots to Experience in Central Park West Historic District, New York
Top 15 Gluten-Free Cafes to Delight in Central Park West Historic District, New York
Top 28 Gluten-Free Breakfast Spots to Delight in Central Park West Historic District, New York