Top 9 Gluten-Free Spots to Discover in Fort Atkinson
+60
Based on 63 recommendations
Last updated: July 5, 2025
Fireside Dinner Theatre
1131 Janesville Ave, Fort Atkinson, WI 53538, USA
Accommodating Gluten-Free
Kid FriendlyRestaurant
People are saying
View more
Christina Ernster
We came from Mequon, WI. We got there early but were told by the lady at the front ticket desk, that we couldn't get our tickets until 4:30. So we went to the bar. At 4:30 there was a long line going out the door. There were a lot of older people who had trouble walking and some had walkers and wheel chairs. I feel they could have illuminated that line by sending people their tickets. Then the bar got packed and some couldn't get a seat and had to wait for drinks. Then the second long line to get into the dining room to eat. We waited in the bar until the line died down. Maybe that's why our food was mediocre. The brie was hard on the top and tasteless and served with wafer like crackers. The asparagus soup tasted ok but it would have been nice to have a piece of asparagus in it. The beef with gravy and vegetables were good but the baked potato had hardened cheese on top and was not appetizing. The gluten free dessert was a disappointment. We didn't care for it. Then the third line to get into the theater was all the way down the hall, again. I feel these lines should have been eliminated by better organization. The show was good but didn't make up for all of the waiting and lines. We were dispointed.
Lots of items to choose from and great place to pick up a sandwich. All the items that you find in your grocery and then some are here. Some items are available in bulk. I appreciate that their products are certified gluten free.
Service was beyond slow. The gluten free is not trust worthy as I asked the server if the they still had a gf fryer and he replied " yes I didn't know that was even a thing". Come to find out a pair of undies and white bed sheet later the fries are indeed not gluten free. The music was cool good beer and it's always a plus when you can go next door to get a cool vanilla ice cream to cool you're irrated bowels down. It was on the pricey side as well.
Great service and amazing food. Everything was perfect. We greatly enjoyed the shrimp appetizer and my husband pasta rags were out of this world. I was a little hesitant being that I am gluten free and have gotten sick at Italian restaurants before but they were extremely accommodating and knowledgeable. My funghi pasta was scrumptious. Worth making the drive more often!
Friendly and attentive staff. Excellent gluten free options. Worked with me to accommodate my food allergies. Food was outanding. Highly recommend 👌