Top 49 Gluten-Free Spots to Discover in Key West

Cheryl Jones

Carole Strout

Rachel Archer

I loved the key lime pie in a cup, great for gluten free folks to savor the best part of the pie. I seriously felt intoxicated after I was finished—soooo good! My hubby loved the slice dipped in chocolate.

Carl Gould

Brian Campbell

David Carden

Julie Peck

Jonathan Brett

Went here specifically for its GF offering. Service was very poor but the food was great. Once we managed to get seated and got both menus we were offered some fresh bread but though we’d ordered Gluten Free pasta, when asked, the waitress said no, its not GF, we don’t have GF bread, ok why offer it to us then (here’s something you can’t eat). My food was brought and the pasta was cold so had to send it back, my wife’s food was brought but was the wrong dish, the waitress even said we don’t have a pasta dish with Italian sausage in but when we showed her the menu she apologised as they did. So now I have hot food my wife has no food, so rather than have them make mine a third time I ate my food and I was 90% finished by the time my wife’s food arrived. So manage expectations on service and you’ll be happy. Disappointing that they didn’t offer a coffee of something by way of an apology for a poor dining experience.

Jessica M

A great pizza place we just happened upon when grabbing something from the grocery store. We are lovers of pizza and had tried other places, but this one was definitely the best! Awesome crust, great variety of pizza types and even gluten free for my husband. I tried the Greek, my husband the white pizza with chicken. So glad we came across here!

Denise Watson

Choppers368

This was a good ice cream spot; the ice cream is especially creamy which suggests to me that it has a higher cream content. The key lime pie was quite tasty; sweet yet tart and had a thick yummy buttery graham cracker crust. The gentleman added some whipped cream as this is not the “meringue topped” type of key lime pie. We also had some Cuban cappuccino which was essentially an Italian cappuccino but it was very good. The gentleman serving us surprised us with a taste of an affogado (espresso and some vanilla ice cream) which was really tasty! There are also giant cookies, fudge, gluten free chocolate macaroons but we did not try those. The ice cream is made down the street but it is essentially made on site as is the key lime pie. Good place!

Marina Moore

Nancy Stevens

Robert D

We stopped in at Alonzo's to take a break from the sun. Nicole was are bartender and made the best key lime pie martinis we've ever had. Bar/restaurant itself is classy, clean & comfortable. Happy to see gluten free options on the menu, we look forward to returning for food and cocktails. Cheers 🍸

Jason Suran

I was in key west for 5 days and I think I ate here at least once a day if not more. The food is incredible and the guy who runs it is super friendly and helpful. I have celiac so it’s really hard for me to eat out especially when traveling. not only was he knowledgeable about allergen safety but he made me a completely custom gluten free sandwich that wasn’t even on the menu. If I could give that sandwich 12 starts out of 10 I would.

Cameron Brown

Myself and three friends dined at New York Pasta Garden during our spring break trip to Key West in March and absolutely loved it! Our server was Donna and she made our dining experience wonderful. She made us laugh, gave great menu recommendations and was very quick to seat us! The food was excellent, the service was quick and they had lots of gluten free and vegetarian options. The prices were affordable and the portion sizes were huge! I got a glass of their Riesling and it was one of my favorites I’ve ever had. I would certainly recommend this place to anyone looking for good Italian food and a fun dining experience in Key West!

Aleida Montoya

Shirley Hawes

Bri Michaud

This place is SOOOOO GOOD. I had a smash burger with a gluten free potato waffle as the bun and omg the best burger I've ever had i would eat that potato waffle every day. 1000x better than a bun. If you are in the mood for a gluten free burger, GO HERE

Micheal Ben

Morgan Olszewski

If you have never been to First Flight, make your way over there ASAP. We have always loved this place, so it was only fitting to have our rehearsal dinner there. Justin & Brittanie - we will adore you both for a lifetime. Our rehearsal dinner could have been our wedding based on what you both created. Having Celiac Disease, they accommodated everything to make sure that I could enjoy - which I feel is rare in those larger settings. Don our bartender was the greatest! Everyone here is so kind hearted, knowledgeable and made everything we wished for come true. Thank you all so much for making this day so special for us. We cannot wait to come visit you all again soon!

John Williams

Hit this place before going on a snorkeling outing. Was worried about the time but they took care of our party of six without an issue. The Bloody Harry was the right choice for a late morning Spicy Bloody Mary drink. I had "The Harpooner" with everything and it did not disappoint! The rest of the fam ate good too! Two of us are gluten sensitive and they said give them a five star on their knowledge and they tell me to tell you gluten sensitive folks the home fries are to die for. Parking can be a little harry (pun intended).

Gen Merritt

Five stars across the board! We stopped into Café Marquesa without a reservation and were so lucky they had room at the bar #score! From start to finish, the experience was fabulous. Our bartender/server was amazing - super attentive, actually listened (rare!), had a great sense of humor, and just made the whole night even better. The amuse-bouche of beet and goat cheese was a nice surprise, and I was thrilled they had gluten-free bread so I could enjoy it with their Vermont butter topped with sea salt flakes. The oysters? Yum! May need to steal their recipe. And the scallops? Next-level. Honestly, everything was delicious, but those scallops were the standout for me. Loved everything. The vibe, the food, the drinks, the service. 🤩 We were four very happy people by the end of the night. Highly recommend if you're in Key West and want something special. Ps. Make a reservation to be sure you can get in... 🥂

Romeo Line

Inez Thomas

Natasha Brown

Awesome gluten free sandwich and the real fruit smoothies are amazing.

Julie Hicks

Ingrid Brent

Joyce Feagle

We stopped by the Blackfin Bistro for lunch yesterday. We had the best seat in the house for people watching. I am gluten intolerant and they had plenty of options for me. We had calamari, escargot and mussels in blue cheese sauce. Gabor was great! Very knowledgeable, recommended a wonderful wine and he was so friendly. I highly recommend checking Blackfin out if you find yourself in Key West.

Michael Gallop

Chad Matney

Genevieve Wilson

Charles Fulton

James Ross

Cynthia Lee

Mykala Steadman

We loved the outdoor seating and vibes here. My friend got the super meat lovers pizza I can’t remember the name of. He LOVED it, 10/10. The servers were very patient with my dietary questions. I ended up getting the gluten free spaghetti with meatballs. It was okay, I definitely don’t recommend paying $6 for the meatballs. They weren’t even very hot, in my opinion. Also high praise for the key lime pie.

DB Cooper

Why is the Health Department blind to this dirty, filthy, old dump that looks And smells bad. Staff have no uniformity or hair nets and they touch ready to serve food with dirty ungloved bare hands. Dirty filthy fan in the window. Food is time temperature abused and cross contaminated like everything fried in same contaminated fryer oil. Nobody wearing single use gloves. Nobody regularly washing their hands even after taking orders or touching money, then preparing and bagging orders with same contaminated hands. Way over priced for such a poor quality place that's usually overcrowded. Mostly drunk people or people unconcerned about their health and wellbeing eat there to get sick. And thankfully No Options for Vegans or Gluten Free Customers...

Anthony Vaughn

Anita Victor

Jessica Pereyra

Benjamin Ehrlich

Julia Paulson

Esperanza Hunt

Joe Gonzales

Betty Pinter

Derek Williams

Darren Park

Cedric Breedlove

Bree Landon

There were very little gluten-free options labeled in the menu. If the meal included toast it was not labeled (gluten-free without toast) so it was not clear what other options there were for gf items. Lots of vegan options listed, but those are not allergens 🫤. The veggie omelet was delicious. The service was very slow, and it was loud. Overall, the food was good bur pricy.