Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Peoria

Ice cream spots

Ice cream that is worth the indulgence, not just a sugary distraction you regret halfway through.

Based on 592 Opinions
+589
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Novel Ice Cream image 1
Novel Ice Cream image 2
Novel Ice Cream image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Enjoy handmade ice cream with unique treats like ice cream stuffed donuts and flavors such as bourbon and butter pecan. Outdoor seating near a park offers a relaxed vibe perfect for families and pets. Creamy texture and slow melting make it a standout spot for casual afternoons.

Creamy texture and slow melting make the ice cream stand out. Unique ice cream stuffed donuts and flavors like bourbon and butter pecan add a different twist. The Cookie Monster ice cream in a cup is a hit with kids.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is amazing, especially the unique flavors."

"The ice cream stuffed donuts here are amazing and unique."

"The ice cream here is amazingly good, especially Cookie Monster."

Good to know

1

The shop is only open in Old Peoria on Friday, Saturday, and Sunday until noon.

2

A scoop of ice cream costs only $4.50.

3

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

02
Handel's Homemade Ice Cream image 1

Outdoor seating with a misting system keeps the space cool and comfortable. Ice cream offers a huge selection with a 4 scoop option for great value. Busy atmosphere means limited seating and some sticky tables, but the fantastic taste makes it worth it.

Delicious ice cream comes in many flavors with a 4 scoop option for 7 dollars. The ice cream consistently impresses with its fantastic taste and quality.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is the best I've ever tasted."

"The chocolate ice cream with peanut butter ribbons and oreos was amazing."

"I found the blueberry cobbler to be top notch."

Good to know

1

The line can be extremely long on busy days, especially after the Grand Opening.

2

There is no indoor seating; all seating is outdoors with limited tables.

3

A medium ice cream dish costs $6 and includes 3ยฝ scoops.

03
Sweety House image 1
Ice cream shop

Family-run shop offers homemade ice cream with unique flavors like banana pudding and affogato. Cozy, mom and pop atmosphere with warm decor and homemade desserts like tres leches cake. Portions suit kids well, making it great for families.

Homemade ice cream features banana pudding and handmade ice cream pops that stand out. Portions come in cups that suit kids well, and flavors like affogato with banana pudding add variety.

People are saying

"I found the tres leches cake to be delicious and full of flavor."

"You have to try the churro cheesecake; it's amazing."

"I found the homemade ice cream to be amazing."

Good to know

1

They offer a variety of desserts, including cakes, ice cream, and specialty drinks.

2

Prices are affordable, making it a great spot for families.

3

Expect a wait during peak hours, especially on weekends.

04
Happy Honu Shave Ice image 1

Shave ice shop offers authentic Hawaiian flavors and premium ice cream like ube and dole whip. Friendly staff create a chill, island vibe that welcomes families and locals. Large portions and fair prices make it a top spot for sweet treats.

Premium quality flavor and texture stand out in the ice cream here. The shaved ice pairs well with options like ube and dole whip, creating a delicious combination.

People are saying

"The ube ice cream here is incredible and a must-try."

"You'll miss the vibes of Oahu if you don't try the shave ice."

"The food here is authentic Hawaiian shave ice, just like home."

Good to know

1

The shop is open seven days a week and stays open late.

2

Prices are reasonable, with large portions of shave ice and ice cream.

3

Mini sizes are available for young kids.

05
Fabio On Fire | Panini & Gelateria image 1

Cozy spot with a wood-fired oven offers authentic Italian deli vibes and outdoor seating. Creamy gelato shines with fresh flavors like pistachio and mango. Music blends 90s and 2000s hits, creating a casual, friendly atmosphere.

Gelato stands out with its creamy texture and balanced sweetness. Flavors like pistachio, strawberry, mango, and chocolate showcase fresh, homemade quality.

People are saying

"I found the homemade gelato here to be amazing."

"The bread here is fresh and made with a traditional yeast starter."

"I experienced the best gelato I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Takeout orders can be conveniently placed through their website.

2

Bottled beverages are the only drink option; no water cups are available.

3

The indoor seating consists of high top tables, which may not be family-friendly.

06
Iced Out Ice Cream image 1
Ice cream shop

Bright, clean shop offers soft serve with unique flavors like matcha and ube in taiyaki cones. Comfortable booths and a TV playing movies create a cozy vibe. Mexican music adds a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Soft serve stands out with its Japanese-style texture and flavor. Unique options like matcha or ube come paired with taiyaki fish cones, offering a fresh and distinct ice cream experience.

People are saying

"The Japanese food, especially the ice cream, is creamy and flavorful."

"I loved the little fish filled with Nutella."

"The soft serve ice cream here is really good."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during peak hours as the shop gets busy.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality of ice cream offered.

3

The ordering kiosk is user-friendly and speeds up the process.

07
Park West image 1
Shopping mall

Modern shopping center features posh architecture and a lively atmosphere during events. Enjoy homemade ice cream from Handles for a quick summer treat. Diverse amenities include a remodeled movie theater and wellness services for a complete experience.

Homemade ice cream stands out here, especially from Handles. The spot offers a great summer treat and a quick dessert option.

People are saying

"This mall has tons of great stores and places to eat."

"The farmer's market here is fun with lots of vendors."

"I tried their homemade ice cream and loved it."

Good to know

1

The farmers market runs every Saturday during summer until noon.

2

Expect a variety of local vendors and food stalls at the farmers market.

3

Parking at Park West can be very inconvenient, especially on weekends.

08
Cold Stone Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream is creamy and delicious with many toppings. Chocolate factory adds assorted treats for variety. Atmosphere feels slightly dated but ice cream quality stays strong. Prices are premium with small portions.

Creamy and delicious ice cream comes with a variety of toppings and chocolate treats. Premade pints offer the best value, though some sizes feel small for the price.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream was always great."

"I loved the creamy, delicious chocolate ice cream."

Good to know

1

The store has a sale sign for chocolates, but specific packaging is required to get the discount.

2

Dark chocolate cashew clusters are priced at $6 for two unless specifically packaged.

3

Pints of premade ice cream offer better value compared to individual chocolate clusters.

09
La Michoacana - Al Natural image 1

Ice cream shop serves fresh made cream cheese ice cream that tastes great. Prices are fair for portion sizes. Atmosphere is pleasant and clean, making it a nice spot to enjoy a treat.

Cream cheese ice cream stands out as fresh made and very delicious. Prices for ice cream bars are fair for the amount served.

People are saying

"I thought the ice cream here was amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

The location is generally clean and well-maintained.

2

Prices may be perceived as high by some customers.

10
Cinnabon Swirl image 1
Dessert shop

Clean, cool space with fresh cinnamon aroma welcomes steady customers. Soft serve ice cream blends classic texture with a strong cinnamon twist. Unique combos like Bonini mix cinnamon rolls and creamy ice cream, perfect for families and dessert lovers.

Soft serve features Carvel's classic texture with a strong cinnamon twist. Ice cream sandwiches and the Bonini combo blend cinnamon rolls with creamy ice cream for a unique treat.

People are saying

"The Cinnabon Swirl sundae is delicious and decadent."

"The staff here is so friendly and patient with everyone."

"These desserts met the nostalgic NYC standard."

Good to know

1

The price for four Cinnabons is $17, which may be high for some.

2

Expect occasional shortages due to high customer demand at this new location.

3

Some menu items, like the Cinnabon Sundae, are only available in the evening.

11
Buca di Beppo Italian Restaurant image 1

Italian restaurant shines with quirky decor and authentic vibe. Ice cream sundaes with whipped cream and sprinkles make celebrations special. Cozy, lively atmosphere with staff singing adds charm.

Celebrations often include ice cream sundaes with whipped cream and sprinkles. Large portions like the colossal brownie ice cream serve groups well. Candles and singing sometimes accompany the treats.

People are saying

"Our server handled our large party perfectly and went above and beyond."

"The food at these dinner spots was amazing and bursting with flavor."

"They surprised us with a festive ice cream sundae for the birthday."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for large parties to ensure seating.

2

Family-style servings mean larger portions suitable for sharing.

3

Expect to spend around $40 per person for a meal.

12
Freddy's Frozen Custard & Steakburgers image 1

Retro style decor sets a fun, cozy mood while smashed steakburgers satisfy hungry guests. Quick, tasty frozen custard complements the meal perfectly. Shoestring fries and seasonal frozen concretes add tasty variety to the menu.

Frozen custard comes out quickly and pairs well with burgers and fries. The ice cream gets compliments for its good taste from diverse groups.

People are saying

"I thought the burgers were juicy and well-seasoned."

"The drive-thru staff are so kind and attentive."

"The ice cream staff here is really nice."

Good to know

1

Freddy's offers a variety of food options including burgers, fries, and shakes.

2

Expect to pay around $40 for two burger combos, which some find overpriced.

3

The restaurant is clean and comfortable for dining.

13
Culverโ€™s image 1
American restaurant

Enjoy rich soft-serve chocolate and over 50 ice cream flavors in a clean, well-maintained American restaurant. Fast service keeps lines moving, while an easygoing atmosphere with TVs offers a bright, comfortable space. Ice cream specials add extra appeal to the varied menu.

Soft-serve chocolate stands out with its rich flavor. Over 50 ice cream flavors offer plenty of variety, and the ice cream specials add extra appeal.

People are saying

"I loved the butter burgers, they're so good."

"The cod dinner here has thick, flaky pieces that never disappoint."

"I loved the delicious ice cream here."

Good to know

1

The drive-thru service is fast and efficient, making it a quick option.

2

Culver's offers 50 different ice cream flavors for dessert lovers.

3

Expect a lengthy line during peak hours, but it moves quickly.

14
Top Shelf Mexican Food & Cantina image 1

Patio with koi fish offers a calm spot while many TVs create a lively bar vibe inside. Deep fried ice cream with corn flakes coating is a unique treat, served with honey and cherries. Dogs are welcome, making it a pet-friendly place.

Deep fried ice cream comes with a corn flakes coating that creates a tough texture. It is served with honey and extra cherries, and dogs enjoy the ice cream here.

People are saying

"The lunch specials here are huge and delicious."

"The patio is really nice with a fountain and lots of seating."

"The fried ice cream here is excellent, topped with honey and extra cherries."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials are available until 4pm on weekdays.

2

The restaurant allows placing pick-up orders online or by phone.

3

A side of sour cream costs $3.50 without prior notice.

15
Dairy Queen Grill & Chill image 1
Fast food restaurant

Fast food spot offers quick service and a friendly atmosphere with affordable prices. Ice cream treats like smooth cones and shakes are a tasty highlight. Space stays clean but watch for long drive-thru lines and limited parking.

Ice cream cones and shakes come out fast and taste very good. The ice cream is consistently smooth and creamy, making it a solid choice for a cool treat.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is creamy and delicious."

"The food here is always good and cooked well."

"The ice cream from the Drive Thru was really good."

Good to know

1

Drive-thru can get backed up, expect longer wait times during peak hours.

2

Pickup orders must be collected inside, not through the drive-thru.

3

Prices are considered high for fast food, especially for those on a budget.

Discover more

Peoria, Arizona

Area guide
Loading Map...