Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in Phoenix

Pie spots

A slice of pie is the only way to finish a proper American meal.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole image 1
Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole image 2
Mamma Toledo's The Pie Hole image 3
View all

Small pie shop with a quaint, 40-year-old small town interior and a casual, hole-in-the-wall vibe. The air fills with a heavenly baked pie smell that welcomes visitors. A cozy coffee shop sits beside the pie area, creating a calm and inviting atmosphere.

Pecan pie stands out with a rich, sweet flavor that beats many other spots. Chicken pot pies come homemade with hearty fillings, and the apple pie has a sugary, non-goopy filling.

Pies here stand out for their coconut cream, pecan, and key lime varieties, all noted for rich flavor and freshness. Mini key lime pies and a homemade chicken pot pie also feature prominently, making the selection diverse and satisfying.

People are saying

"I thought their homemade style pies were some of the best I'd ever tasted."

"I thought the green chili burritos were amazing."

"The American Food pies taste like they are homemade and out of a dream."

Good to know

1

Pies are available for $9 each, despite some signs indicating $8.

2

You need to place orders in October for Thanksgiving and Christmas pies.

3

The pie truck sells only one-person pies.

02
The Neighborly image 1
Restaurant

Large outdoor patio offers shaded, comfortable seating with heaters for cooler times. Interior features spacious, tasteful design with a huge bar and two levels including an epic center bar upstairs. Atmosphere stays warm and lively at a volume that allows easy conversation, making it a popular local meet-up spot.

Cornbread stands out with an unbelievable crust and unique flavor. Prime rib and clam chowder also feature as delicious American classics here.

Coconut pies stand out with great texture and rich consistency. Chocolate and key lime pies offer distinct flavors, with chocolate pie served a la mode.

People are saying

"The Happy Hour wings were crispy and flavorful with sauce on the side."

"You have to try the prime rib; it's one of the best I've ever had."

"I found the coconut cream pie here to be life changing."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs all night on Mondays with $6 mini tinas.

2

The restaurant hosts a special restaurant week menu from May 17 to 26, 2024.

3

Private events can be hosted upstairs, offering a unique space.

03
Amadio Ranch image 1
Farmers' market

Farm setting with petting zoo and orchard creates a family-friendly atmosphere. Outdoor spaces include play areas and seating among peach trees, fostering a relaxed, local vibe. Food offerings come from a barn-based cafe featuring homemade pies and simple meals.

Homemade grilled hamburgers come with crispy fries and mini corn dogs. Various pies like caramel apple, peach, banana cream, and pecan offer classic American dessert flavors.

Homemade pies stand out for their fresh ingredients and rich flavors. Varieties include blueberry, apple, and chocolate silk pie in a cup, all noted for being very delicious.

People are saying

"This place feels like a genuine, down-to-earth spot with unique charm."

"I thought the food here was delicious."

"I got their chicken pot pie, it was amazing."

Good to know

1

Amadio Ranch hosts a weekly farmers market with local vendors every Saturday.

2

Food trucks are available on different days of the week at Amadio Ranch.

3

Entry and parking at Amadio Ranch are free for all visitors.

04
Gus's World Famous Fried Chicken image 1

Open layout chicken restaurant with laid-back Southern vibe and friendly, casual atmosphere. Mismatched chairs add a homey touch while music keeps energy lively and fun. Customers seat themselves in a clean, simple space that feels welcoming and relaxed.

Fried chicken comes made to order with a crispy, flavorful crust and juicy meat. Collard greens accompany the meal, adding a classic Southern touch to the American food experience.

Chocolate pie and pecan pie stand out as popular choices. The max and cheese pairs well with the chocolate pie, and the pies are homemade and often come with friendly service.

People are saying

"The food here is delicious, fresh, and hot."

"The American food here is so juicy and crispy."

"The fried chicken here is so juicy and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Fried chicken is made to order, taking about 18 minutes to prepare.

2

The restaurant offers a daily special, so check for current deals.

3

All food is cooked in peanut oil, which is filtered for peanut allergies.

05
Knead Luv Gluten Free Bakery & Cafรฉ image 1

Gluten-free bakery with cute decor and a cozy vibe featuring a comfortable lounge and a small patio. Atmosphere feels warm and inviting, enhanced by a kids corner and a photo zone. Offers visually stunning desserts and a welcoming environment for enjoying organic, allergen-conscious baked goods.

Prime rib soup and a Luv Club Sandwich stand out among the American food options. The menu also includes biscuits and gravy, pizzas, and a variety of sandwiches.

Gluten-free pies stand out with freshly baked quality and rich flavors like pumpkin and key lime. Options include pies that freeze well, making them great for celebrations or later enjoyment.

People are saying

"I couldn't tell these delicious baked goods were gluten free!"

"I found the gluten-free pies here to be the best I ever had."

"I loved their gluten-free American food options."

Good to know

1

Order in advance because they sell out quickly.

2

All baked goods are gluten-free and sourced from local farms.

3

Just one single cinnamon roll is $10.

06
Texaz Grill image 1
American restaurant

Old western saloon style sets a homey, eclectic vibe with authentic Texas roadhouse decor and western music. Friendly, inviting atmosphere feels like a mom and pop steak joint known for its chicken fried steak and cold draft beers.

Chicken fried steak stands out with its well-cooked texture and nice gravy. Prime rib, hamburgers, and chicken tenders also feature on the menu, with staff accommodating special requests.

Pecan pie stands out as a memorable dessert here. The homemade version often comes ร  la mode and is popular enough to take home.

People are saying

"I found the chicken fried steak to be authentic and large enough to share."

"The mashed potatoes with cream gravy are to die for."

"I remembered the homemade pecan pie as the best around."

Good to know

1

Parking can be difficult, especially on weekends.

2

Reservations may be required during busy times.

3

The restaurant is usually crowded after 5 PM on weekdays.

07
T-Bone Steak House image 1

Rustic steakhouse offers live music and amazing city views with dim lighting that creates a relaxing atmosphere. The vibe blends an authentic cowboy feel with warm energy, attracting diners who enjoy hearty meals and a lively soundtrack.

Steaks like Porterhouse, Bone-In Rib Eye, and Filet Mignon come cooked to order, often medium rare or medium. Non-meat options include grilled salmon, trout, and smoked chicken. The apple pie stands out as a notable dessert.

Apple pie stands out as a highlight here, often served a la mode. The pie is consistently described as delicious and highly recommended.

People are saying

"The views from the restaurant were amazing."

"The American Food here, especially the porterhouse steak, is cooked to perfection."

"I had the best apple pie I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Live music happens every Friday night at T-Bone Steak House.

2

Reservations are recommended for weekend dining due to high demand.

3

Dinner for two typically costs around $50, including drinks and tip.

08
Seamus McCaffrey's Irish Pub image 1

Classic Irish pub with dark woodwork and authentic traditional decor creates a comfortable, welcoming atmosphere. Live music and a large bar area keep energy lively, especially late at night. Regulars enjoy whiskey and Guinness, while plenty of screens show various games, adding to the vibrant vibe.

The menu features a Reuben sandwich with fries and Irish nachos made of thick cut spiral fries that are crispy outside and fluffy inside. Fish and chips come with malt vinegar, coleslaw, and tartar sauce. Chicken wings and Cobb Salad also stand out.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with its traditional Irish flavor and consistent quality. Chicken pot pie offers a rich, comforting taste that pairs well with other hearty dishes like Irish nachos.

People are saying

"The fish and chips here are amazing and perfectly battered."

"The pot pie here is exceptionally delicious and very good."

"The Irish nachos here are great, especially the crispy fries."

Good to know

1

Last call for drinks is at 2AM, and for food at 1AM.

2

Parking can be tricky, so plan ahead.

3

They occasionally host local Irish bands for live music.

09
Pie Snob Uptown image 1

Bakery offers pie vending machine and ATM slice option for pie at any hour. Atmosphere stays quiet with good music and open-air windows, inviting guests to relax. Pies come in dozens of varieties, sold by slice or whole, with a rotating weekly menu.

Key Lime Pie stands out with its tangy flavor. Other options include Apple Crumb and Pecan Pie, with the apple pie being decent but not exceptional.

Pies come in at least two dozen varieties by the slice or whole, with coconut cream, chocolate cream, and apple crumble standing out. The pie ATM offers a unique way to grab these homemade treats, which often draw long lines during holidays.

People are saying

"The blackberry pie was bursting with tangy flavor and a flaky crust."

"I found their cheesecakes to be delicious."

"The American Food here, especially the pies, is truly delicious and homemade."

Good to know

1

Pies are available by the slice or as whole pies.

2

Expect long lines around the holidays due to popularity.

3

Some crusts contain lard, which may not be suitable for vegetarians.

10
My Mother's Restaurant image 1
American restaurant

Unassuming exterior opens to a cozy small diner with nostalgic decor reminiscent of a grandma's house. Atmosphere stays warm and inviting with low lighting creating a peaceful, homey vibe. Frequented for generous portions and an extensive menu, it suits family meals, casual meetings, and private events.

Prime rib stands out with its buttery tenderness and consistent quality. Comfort dishes like pot roast, chicken parmesan, and chicken fried chicken offer hearty, classic flavors.

Chocolate cream and coconut cream pies stand out with rich flavors. Slices come in generous sizes, making the pie a notable dessert choice.

People are saying

"I woke up dreaming about the amazing homemade pies."

"I loved the fresh Salad Bar with so many choices."

"You have to try the pot roast; it's amazing comfort food."

Good to know

1

Parking at the restaurant is a little tight, but there's nearby parking available.

2

The menu features over 20 dinner entrees, catering to various tastes.

3

Portions are generous, providing good value for the price.

11
George and Dragon English Pub image 1

Pub recreates authentic British atmosphere with dim lighting and traditional decor that feels like north London. Outdoor seating and multiple TVs create a relaxed spot for watching games or playing darts and pool. Local crowd adds a community vibe that feels welcoming and lively.

Meatloaf stands out as a signature dish, often described as the best ever tasted. Other notable items include the pot pie, stuffed meatloaf, and dragon chips, with the "Protein Bomb" featuring a hamburger patty, bacon, chili, and cheese.

Shepherd's Pie stands out with its authentic English style and simple, comfort-food appeal without lamb. The chicken pot pie pastry and pastie also offer hearty, satisfying options that echo traditional flavors.

People are saying

"The food here is really good, with large portions."

"I found the shepherd's pie to be excellent and comforting."

"I thought the American Food meatloaf was the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for private events, especially in the side room.

2

Karaoke night happens every Monday with a two-drink minimum.

3

Trivia night takes place every Thursday at 8pm, attracting a lively crowd.

12
Dubliner Irish Pub image 1

Irish pub with large L-shaped bar and live music including DJs and bands creates a lively yet conversational atmosphere. Games like pool, darts, and foosball add to the fun neighborhood vibe. Authentic drinks like perfectly poured Guinness complement classic pub food such as fish and chips and Guinness stew.

Traditional bar food features Shepherd's Pie, Prime Rib sliders, and a Reuben sandwich. Homemade potato chips, chicken wings, fish and chips with tater tots, nachos, chicken sliders, and good coleslaw round out the menu.

Shepherd's pie comes in a small bowl without bread. It tastes delicious and is easy to carry without a bag. This dish is a pub staple alongside fish and chips and Reuben sandwiches.

People are saying

"This pub has amazing food, especially the Shepards pie."

"The American food, especially the fish fry, is plentiful and delicious."

"I thought the shepherd's pie was great."

Good to know

1

Trivia nights are hosted every Tuesday at 8 pm.

2

Open mic nights occur every Sunday evening.

3

Live music starts around 8 pm, making conversation difficult.

13
Mandy's Fish & Chips image 1

Quaint restaurant offers a harmonious atmosphere with music and movies playing in the dining area. The vibe is measured and cozy, attracting those seeking affordable, fresh fried fish with generous portions.

Extra crispy catfish comes with hush puppies and French fries on the side. The Philly Cheesesteak stands out as a fantastic option.

Sweet potato pies come with a delicious crust and cook to perfection. Pecan pie is also available as a slice alongside the sweet potato option.

People are saying

"I found the fish here to be fresh, hot, and amazing."

"The American food, especially the crispy catfish, is delicious."

"The sweet potato pie here is delicious."

Good to know

1

The meal does not include lemon or tartar sauce, which are extra charges.

2

The restaurant is located in a neighborhood that may feel unsafe to some visitors.

3

Expect to pay extra for sauces; they are not included with meals.

14
Rally's image 1
Fast food restaurant

Outdoor seating with concrete tables and umbrellas creates a casual, home-like vibe. The place offers affordable prices and freshly made burgers with fries often praised as the best in fast food. No indoor dining exists, and the atmosphere stays relaxed with a walk-up window service.

Brisket sandwiches and burgers stand out with solid flavors. Fries, onion rings, funnel fries, and apple pie offer classic American sides and desserts with a fair-like vibe.

Apple pies stand out with a great taste and a fair-like quality. The cashier offers ice cream while pies cook, adding a nice touch.

People are saying

"I found the burgers here to be delicious."

"The American Food here, especially the burgers, is really good and juicy."

"I thought the apple pies were delish."

Good to know

1

This location has no indoor dining, only outdoor seating available.

2

Prices are considered affordable for fast food, with a $4 combo available.

3

Rally's charges $0.75 for a side of ranch dressing.

15
Village Inn image 1
Breakfast restaurant

Breakfast restaurant offers all-day breakfast with a friendly neighborhood feel and a quiet, cozy atmosphere favored by an older crowd. A mini bar-like seating area provides casual dining options. The place is known for excellent pies and a variety of affordable, well-prepared meals.

Eggs Benedict stands out with consistent quality and flavor. The grilled cheese features parmesan-crusted bread and comes with crinkle-cut fries. Patty melts and chicken fried steak also appear regularly on the menu.

Pies come in full size and taste solid. Free pie Wednesdays draw a crowd, and pies work well for work parties.

People are saying

"I thought the pie here was amazing."

"I found the breakfast here super delicious and tasty."

"The American Food here is great, especially the service."

Good to know

1

Village Inn offers free pie on Wednesdays with an entree order.

2

Prices at Village Inn are reasonable for the quality of food.

3

Expect a variety of breakfast options available all day.

16
Squarz Bakery & Cafe - Scottsdale image 1

Colorful decor and cozy couches create a relaxed, inviting atmosphere with plenty of seating options including booths with outlets. Soft piano jazz plays at a comfortable volume, supporting both casual hangouts and remote work. A community bulletin board and games for kids add a welcoming, family-friendly touch.

Mini pies like chicken pot pie and spinach and feta stand out. Drinks include a mocha frappe that pairs well with the food.

Flaky, buttery crusts define the pies here. Mini pies like the chorizo and egg and chicken pot pie stand out alongside croissant puff sandwiches and almond or raspberry croissants.

People are saying

"The croissant sandwiches here are delicious and made with croissant dough."

"The American food, especially the pies, was flaky and buttery."

"The almond and raspberry croissants were delicious."

Good to know

1

The cafe offers free WiFi, which is fast and reliable.

2

Prices for meals range from $20 to $30, which may be high for some.

3

The cafe welcomes children, making it family-friendly.

Discover more

Phoenix, Arizona

Area guide
Loading Map...