Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of Scottsdale

Unique jewelry stores

Jewelry that reflects a distinct point of view instead of the same mass-produced inventory found everywhere else.

Based on 813 Opinions
+810
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Cornelis Hollander Jewelry Designs image 1
Cornelis Hollander Jewelry Designs image 2
Cornelis Hollander Jewelry Designs image 3
View all

Store offers an elegant yet approachable atmosphere with a quiet, one-on-one experience that feels welcoming and personal. Jewelry features masterful craftsmanship and unique, custom designs that stand apart from typical chain stores.

Beautifully crafted jewelry stands out here, with a focus on high-quality pieces. The staff provides exceptional service for custom work and resizing needs.

Designs show strong creativity and passion for crafting pieces that stand out. Rings and settings often get transformed into unique statement pieces tailored to each customer.

People are saying

"This Ring Store made my heirloom engagement ring look new again."

"This jewelry store brought my custom design ideas to life."

"They create unique jewelry with outstanding craftsmanship and artistic touches."

Good to know

1

Cornelis Hollander specializes in custom jewelry design and appraisal services.

2

Expect high-quality craftsmanship and unique designs tailored to personal stories.

3

The store offers CAD images to ensure perfect engagement ring designs.

02
Galicia Fine Jewelers image 1

Jewelry store offers unique, elegant designs with in-house craftsmanship and fast turnaround. Atmosphere feels welcoming and professional, enhanced by a friendly dog greeter. Selection spans a wide price range with reasonable prices and standout custom options.

Custom jewelry here matches exactly what people dream of, with rings turning out better than imagined. Staff like Lisa provide personalized service over many years, and the selection offers unique, high-quality pieces that feel truly individual.

Jewelry here stands out with unique and elegant designs that break from the usual. They offer one-of-a-kind pieces and even work creatively with old jewelry to craft something new.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so knowledgeable and professional."

"This Ring Store made my perfect, custom wedding ring."

"I found gorgeous and unique jewelry designs here."

Good to know

1

They offer custom jewelry services and have a great selection in store.

2

The repair service is efficient, with quick turnaround times.

3

Expect a wide price range for quality gifts and unique pieces.

03
Sunrise Jewelry & Gallery image 1

Vintage design fills the space with one-of-a-kind pieces and unique Southwestern jewelry. The atmosphere stays relaxed and welcoming, drawing people who appreciate high-quality, authentic jewelry. The store also features exciting exhibits including sculptures and pottery.

A huge selection of unique Southwestern jewelry fills the store, with many high-quality pieces to choose from. Friendly staff spend time helping try on multiple cuffs and rings, creating a welcoming atmosphere.

Beautiful, unique Southwestern jewelry fills the store with high-quality pieces that stand out for their distinct designs.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so friendly and helpful."

"The staff at this Ring Store are so helpful and sweet."

"I found the most beautiful, unique jewelry pieces here."

Good to know

1

The store has a huge selection of quality jewelry.

2

Credit cards are accepted for purchases.

3

Parking is available nearby for easy access.

04
The Estate Watch & Jewelry Company image 1

Store offers an elegant layout with luxurious ambiance and quality gemstone displays. Atmosphere feels welcoming and comfortable, with friendly, knowledgeable staff and complimentary beverages. Services include full jewelry and watch repair, restoration, and appraisal.

Excellent service and a wide selection define this jewelry store. Staff members like Jill and Emily provide helpful, trustworthy assistance, making it a place people return to for watches and rings.

Many unique pieces stand out in the jewelry and watch selection. Staff offer unique service alongside a wide range of high-quality estate pieces.

People are saying

"The staff at this jewelry store are so helpful and trustworthy."

"I found gorgeous vintage jewelry with an eclectic selection."

"I found so many beautiful and unique jewelry pieces here."

Good to know

1

They throw Christmas parties every holiday season, perfect for festive gatherings.

2

The Estate Watch & Jewelry Company offers top-notch customer service and exquisite jewelry.

3

My ring was returned to me on the same day for quick service.

05
Scottsdale Fine Jewelers image 1

Showroom offers a relaxed atmosphere with beautiful jewelry selection and excellent craftsmanship. Staff handle repairs and adjustments with quick turnaround and fair pricing. The space feels inviting and unintimidating, welcoming a diverse clientele.

Custom jewelry design includes anniversary bands made from original diamonds and family rings. Jewelry repairs happen quickly and with care. Staff guide customers to perfect earrings within specific price points.

Custom pieces stand out with perfectly unique designs. The shop specializes in unique custom jewelry that gets approval before work begins.

People are saying

"I found the staff at this Ring Store incredibly friendly and helpful."

"They custom designed my unique engagement ring with a Neon Blue Paraiba Tourmaline."

"This jewelry store's staff is so helpful and knowledgeable."

Good to know

1

Repairs are completed in about an hour for most services.

2

Prices for repairs are competitive compared to other shops.

3

The store offers quick evaluations for jewelry.

06
Platella Jewelers image 1
Jewelry store

Store showcases unique handmade jewelry with exceptional craftsmanship and one-of-a-kind designs. Atmosphere feels modern and clean, inviting personal connections beyond transactions. Owner's personal care and artistry create a distinctive experience not found in typical jewelry shops.

Jewelry pieces show brilliant craftsmanship and unique selection. Personal care and service remain exceptional throughout visits.

Jewelry here features one-of-a-kind designs crafted by the owner, offering pieces you won't find elsewhere. The shop delivers unique handmade jewelry with exceptional craftsmanship and personal care.

People are saying

"Hugo designed the most incredible custom wedding ring, making small adjustments for perfection."

"Hugo crafts unique jewelry art that feels like family heirlooms."

"Hugo designs one-of-a-kind custom jewelry pieces that get compliments."

Good to know

1

Platella Jewelers offers unique handmade jewelry pieces that deliver a 'wow factor.'

2

Custom engagement rings are available at Platella Jewelers.

3

Hugo, the owner, provides personalized service and custom designs.

07
Grey Wolf Gallery image 1
Native american goods store

Store showcases handcrafted Native American art with a wide variety of jewelry, pottery, and wooden pieces. Atmosphere is respectful and supportive of local indigenous artists, featuring fair and straightforward pricing without haggling. Staff provides knowledgeable details about materials and artists, creating a genuine shopping experience.

Offers a fantastic selection of semi-precious stone and silver jewelry with unique, beautiful pieces. Pricing is straightforward, and customization like turning a necklace into bracelets is available.

A wide variety of unique, well-made pieces fills the store, including exceptional vases and earrings. The jewelry selection stands out as both beautiful and unique.

People are saying

"I found unique, well-made pieces with staff who were knowledgeable and helpful."

"The owners are superb and knowledgeable about the local tribes and artists."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so knowledgeable and kind."

Good to know

1

Prices are fair and straightforward, with no haggling required.

2

The staff is knowledgeable about the artists and materials used in the pieces.

3

Items are ethically sourced directly from Native American artists.

08
Oliver Smith Jeweler Flagship image 1

Spacious, elegant showroom offers wide selection of fine jewelry and luxury watches, including custom designs and pre-owned timepieces. Atmosphere feels warm and professional with knowledgeable staff providing pressure-free service. On-site repair and manufacturing add convenience and expertise to the experience.

Expertise in fine jewelry and timepieces stands out with a wide selection and original designs. Quality meets value with excellent pricing and personalized service from knowledgeable staff.

Offers one-of-a-kind designs alongside elegant classics and modern statement pieces. Helps create unique custom pieces from personal diamonds for a truly unforgettable experience.

People are saying

"The staff at this Watch Store are so knowledgeable and helpful."

"This jewelry store's staff is so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The staff's genuine support makes this place truly unique."

Good to know

1

They have a wide selection of jewelry and watches, both new and pre-owned.

2

Expect competitive pricing on luxury watches and fine jewelry.

3

Custom design and repair services are available on-site.

09
Spice Scottsdale image 1

Boutique space offers charm bar with many options for making personalized jewelry. Atmosphere stays super cute and chill, with a focus on trendy gifts and local merchandise. Popular spot for girls' day trips and casual, creative shopping experiences.

Offers a hands-on experience to make custom charm bracelets and necklaces. Staff provides helpful guidance while crafting jewelry with a variety of charm options for necklaces, keychains, bracelets, and earrings.

Many items come from local artists and show unique designs. Jewelry stands out as especially distinctive and fun.

People are saying

"It's so much fun making your own bracelet with tons of cute charms."

"I loved making my own charm bracelets at this jewelry store."

"I found the jewelry here to be super unique and memorable."

Good to know

1

No reservation is needed to visit the shop.

2

They have a great selection of charms, chains, and jewelry-making materials.

3

The store accommodates groups, making it perfect for bachelorette parties or girls' day trips.

10
Finer Custom Engagement Rings & Diamonds image 1

Office space combines elegant design with intimate atmosphere that supports personalized service. Customers engage in a seamless custom jewelry process featuring detailed craftsmanship and reasonable pricing. The environment fosters trust and transparency uncommon in larger retailers.

Custom engagement rings get detailed attention with expert craftsmanship and personalized design. Staff offer patient, accommodating service for both buying and selling jewelry.

The team sources unique stones and offers one-of-a-kind designs that turn initial ideas into breathtaking pieces. Jewelry here includes draw-dropping, custom engagement rings that stand out.

People are saying

"This Ring Store made my dream engagement ring exactly to my vision."

"This jewelry store's service is so attentive and helpful, they make the whole process special."

"I found the perfect unique stone and planned the design down to the smallest detail."

Good to know

1

The process of buying custom jewelry is seamless and well-organized.

2

Expect fair pricing compared to other jewelers in the area.

3

You can view various stone shapes during your first meeting.

11
Native Art Market image 1
Artistic handicrafts

Space showcases authentic Native American art and jewelry with live flute music and performances adding to a joyful, heartfelt atmosphere. Visitors find high-quality handmade crafts directly supporting Indigenous artists and communities.

Handcrafted jewelry by Native American artisans features turquoise earrings and unique bracelets with detailed artist and stone origin cards. The collection offers diverse, authentic craftsmanship suitable for various budgets.

Unique shopping features include high-quality Native gifts like the Manuelito sticker and exquisite jewelry. The market offers distinctive crafts and art that capture Native American culture.

People are saying

"You'll learn fascinating stories behind the art in these galleries."

"I found the handmade Native American jewelry to be amazing."

"It's a unique shopping experience filled with handcrafted Native American art."

Good to know

1

The store is the only Native American-owned shop in Old Town Scottsdale.

2

All items are authentic and made by Native American artisans.

3

Purchases support local artists and the community.

12
NightRider Jewelry image 1
Jewelry store

Artisan jewelry showcases unique designs and high-quality craftsmanship with extreme detail. The atmosphere reflects a family-oriented approach across multiple locations, emphasizing personalized care like item cleaning. Jewelry pieces stand out for their quality compared to well-known brands.

Jewelry here stands out for its unique, extremely detailed designs and high quality craftsmanship. Staff provide friendly, patient service that makes shopping feel personal and enjoyable.

Pieces show extreme detail and high quality craftsmanship. Jewelry stands out with its unique designs.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so patient and helpful."

"Nick and Silver were so patient and helpful at the Jewelry Store."

"Shopping with Jennica felt like hanging out with a friend."

Good to know

1

NightRider offers artisan jewelry made in the USA.

2

The store has a reputation for great prices on artisan jewelry.

3

Customer service is prioritized, especially when issues arise.

13
Rocks CRYSTALS & Fossils image 1

Shop offers a wide variety of unique crystals, fossils, and jewelry displayed with care and attention. Atmosphere feels peaceful and inviting, with a beautifully laid out space that highlights each piece's natural beauty.

Offers a great selection of high quality jewelry, including beautiful gems and stones. Finds include crystals, rings, and wrist bracelets.

Extensive assortment includes unique crystals, beautiful fossils, and distinctive table art. Many pieces stand out for their beauty and rarity.

People are saying

"I found something beautiful with the help of the friendly and knowledgeable staff."

"I found beautiful gems and jewelry here."

"This place is so kid friendly, my kids loved exploring the collection."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a unique selection of high-quality stones and crystals.

2

Expect to find distinctive table art and seasonal items.

3

Items are displayed with care, enhancing their natural beauty.

14
Over the Top Consignment Shoppe image 1

Shop offers an eclectic collection of high-end crystal, china, and jewelry with pieces from brands like Daum, Lalique, and Tiffany. Warm and welcoming atmosphere invites browsing through carefully selected, pristine items. The environment feels like a hidden gem for collectors and jewelry lovers.

Inventory includes high-end jewelry, unique one-of-a-kind pieces, and collections from David Yurman and John Hardy. The owner is friendly and knowledgeable, offering great prices and consignment options.

Shop offers unique crystals and one-of-a-kind pieces that stand out. Quality remains top-notch throughout the collection.

People are saying

"Liz made the consignment process smooth and pleasant."

"Liz at this Jewelry Store is so friendly and knowledgeable about her pieces."

"Liz's unique pieces made my heart happy."

Good to know

1

The shop features a wide variety of high-end jewelry, crystal, and antiques.

2

Expect to find unique pieces from brands like David Yurman and Tiffany.

3

Prices are fair for the quality of the high-end items available.

15
Wild West Trading Post image 1

Gift shop offers beautiful jewelry and unique pottery pieces with an authentic Wild West vibe. Playing music adds to the inviting atmosphere, while on-site ring sizing and silver polishing gloves provide thoughtful touches.

A wide selection of unique silver rings with inset turquoise and coral stands out here. The owner offers free ring sizing on-site and is open to making alterations to fit preferences and budgets.

Beautiful and unique pottery pieces by Sharon Penn stand out. The store offers a variety of gorgeous home goods and distinctive jewelry from different origins.

People are saying

"The owner of this Ring Store is so sweet and gave us a great deal."

"I highly recommend this jewelry store for great quality."

"The staff here is so friendly and knowledgeable, it's truly unique."

Good to know

1

The owner offers over 50% off on select turquoise rings.

2

Ring sizing is provided for free by the owner.

3

Discounts are available on some of the best items.

16
Truly Blessed Jewels - Scottsdale image 1

Jewelry store offers a chic and clean space with a welcoming atmosphere and beautiful, polished setup featuring many options. The vibe is warm and calming, making it ideal for couples, friends, and family to share meaningful moments. Complimentary champagne and personalized touches enhance the experience.

Permanent jewelry options include bracelets and earrings with customization available. Pricing covers a range of budgets and the store offers on-site services for groups.

Offers a one-of-a-kind experience for groups with permanent jewelry making. Features dainty, unique Roxie hoops and matching rings. Creates a fun and unique bonding atmosphere.

People are saying

"The Jewelry Store team is so kind and professional."

"This jewelry-making experience was super fun and memorable."

"The staff here is so kind and helpful picking out unique pieces."

Good to know

1

The store offers a variety of permanent jewelry options, including bracelets and anklets.

2

Prices for jewelry are considered great by many customers.

3

The place is wheelchair accessible for visitors with mobility needs.

17
Gaea Rare | Crystals, Jewelry, Decor, Gifts (Greenway Hayden Loop) image 1

Shop offers museum-quality crystals, unique fossils, and local artisan jewelry in a warm, inviting atmosphere. Classes on sound healing, chakras, and jewelry making add an educational layer. Displays include rare specimens like lemurian and apophyllite crystals, creating a space rich in energy and stories.

Beautiful crystals and jewelry from local artisans fill the store. Personalized chakra bracelets can be created with helpful guidance, alongside an amazing selection of rocks, fossils, and antiquities.

A wide variety of unique crystals, quartz, and natural rocks fills the shop. It features gems, fossils, meteorites, and dinosaur eggs from around the world, including lemurian and apophyllite crystals.

People are saying

"I found the shop's unique pieces to be beautiful and captivating."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so nice and knowledgeable."

"It's so Kid Friendly, my children had a great time and received gemstones."

Good to know

1

The store has a unique selection of gems, fossils, meteorites, and dinosaur eggs sourced globally.

2

Prices are reasonable for the quality of crystals and jewelry offered.

3

Educational literature on the healing properties of stones is available at the front.

18
Scottsdale Pawn Shop image 1

Small shop packed with vintage treasures and an eclectic collection including Native American jewelry and firearms. Atmosphere feels chill and nostalgic, with organized displays and a friendly, mom-and-pop vibe. Prices are fair and competitive, attracting those hunting for unique pieces.

Offers a great selection of jewelry including Native American pieces with competitive prices. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable, making buying and selling smooth.

Aisles fill with vintage and unique treasures that bring a sense of nostalgia. The selection includes one-of-a-kind pieces and a collectible range of firearms priced well.

People are saying

"The staff at this Jewelry Store are so friendly and helpful."

"I got a beautiful antique gold ring at a great price."

"I found so many unique treasures, like vintage jewelry and quirky collectibles."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a unique selection of Native American jewelry.

2

They accept both cash and credit card payments.

3

Parking is convenient and readily available.

19
Gold House image 1
Jeweler

Boutique jewelry store showcases unique, high-quality pieces with custom design options and a classy western flair. The atmosphere feels personal and inviting, with constantly updated inventory reflecting current fashion trends. Many items serve as heirloom-quality legacy pieces not found elsewhere.

Unique Murano glass jewelry and exquisite silver and gold pieces stand out here. The store offers custom-made gold and gemstone jewelry with outstanding craftsmanship and personable service.

Jewelry here stands out with unique designs not found in other stores. Staff work closely to create or find pieces that express your personality with a personal touch.

People are saying

"I found the most unique and high-quality jewelry pieces at this store."

"I always find unique items I must have here."

"The Ring Store staff are super helpful and genuinely want you thrilled."

Good to know

1

Gold House offers unique, high-quality jewelry with a personal touch.

2

They also do custom work and can bring your design ideas to life.

3

The quality and craftsmanship of the jewelry are outstanding.

20
North Scottsdale Pawn Shop image 1

Clean, organized space offers a wide selection of jewelry, musical instruments, and firearms. Atmosphere stays chill and welcoming, with a sense of safety and no riffraff. Located in a tucked-away strip mall, it feels like a hidden spot with unique, well-priced items.

Unique pieces and affordable prices stand out in the jewelry selection. Staff shows knowledge about diamonds and gold, making the service reliable.

Many unique pieces appear here, especially in jewelry and vintage items. Prices stay affordable across these distinct finds.

People are saying

"George at this Jewelry Store is so kind and helpful."

"The Ring Store staff, George and Jerry, were so knowledgeable and helpful."

"The owner's knowledge about jewelry is really helpful."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a wide selection of jewelry, firearms, and musical instruments.

2

Expect a clean and organized shopping environment during your visit.

3

The store is located in a safe neighborhood strip mall.

21
Maverick's of Scottsdale image 1
Western apparel store

Western apparel store offers curated high-end clothing with a wide selection of boots, hats, and jewelry. Atmosphere feels intimate and welcoming with a professional, polished display. Hat bar includes customization options like freehand designs and branding.

A huge selection of jewelry stands out alongside Western apparel and antiques. Pieces range from artistic to classic styles, offering variety in design and craftsmanship.

Unique hand-stitched Louis Vuitton bags and western products stand out here. The selection includes unique pieces and fun clothing with a distinct style.

People are saying

"Gabe at the Footwear Store helped me find my dream red boots."

"I found the clothing pieces here to be so unique and fun."

"I found fantastic pieces of jewelry here."

Good to know

1

Maverick's offers a wide selection of cowboy boots, hats, and clothing.

2

They provide options for large hat sizes, which many stores lack.

3

Maverick's hosts special events like girls' night for a fun shopping experience.

22
Shane Co. image 1
Jewelry store

Jewelry gallery offers a welcoming, personalized atmosphere with expert consultants who do not work on commission. Displays are beautifully arranged, creating an inviting space where browsing feels casual and easy. Lifetime warranty and high-quality selection set it apart from other jewelers.

High-quality jewelry and trustworthy service define this jeweler. Staff provide clear education on rings and diamonds, helping with important purchases like engagement and wedding rings.

Each ring features a distinct design that stands out. Staff members like Stacy, Robyn, and Derek help highlight styles that feel truly personal and unique. The whole process offers a fun and memorable experience.

People are saying

"The staff at this Ring Store are so helpful and knowledgeable."

"They made me feel comfortable and welcomed right away."

"The staff at this jewelry store are so patient and helpful."

Good to know

1

Every item they sold carries a lifetime warranty.

2

Shane Co. offers a great variety and quality of rings.

3

The ring shopping experience is casual and easy.

23
Anticus - Fine Art, Books, Jewelry, & Design image 1

Gallery combines fine art, books, jewelry, and design in a thoughtfully curated space. Warm, inviting atmosphere feels like a family environment with positive energy and an upbeat neighborhood. Displays include international artists, sculptures, and unique collections that create a joyful and eclectic experience.

Unique jewelry pieces sit alongside hand-painted Disney cells and hauntingly beautiful giclees, creating an artistic mix. Jewelry shopping here offers a blend of art and craftsmanship.

Phillip curates a unique collection of books and artwork. The selection offers distinctive finds that stand out on every visit.

People are saying

"I found amazing sculptures and other artworks here."

"The people at the Galleries were so friendly and helpful."

"The staff here are so friendly and always able to help."

Good to know

1

The gallery hosts book clubs and art walks regularly.

2

Reservations are recommended for workshops to ensure a spot.

3

Parking is available nearby, but it can fill up quickly during events.

Discover more

Scottsdale, Arizona

Area guide
Loading Map...