Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Buffalo wings and Italian food in the US

Made for those who refuse to choose between their craving for spicy wings and their preference for traditional Italian fare.

Based on 702 Opinions
+699
User
User
User
Updated
01
2 Brother's Pizza image 1
2 Brother's Pizza image 2
2 Brother's Pizza image 3
View all

Open kitchen with a giant turning pizza oven creates a modern and clean setting. Big screen TVs show muted games and music videos, while an outdoor dog-friendly patio offers relaxed seating. The vibe is inviting and lively, blending family-friendly energy with craft beer and quality pizza.

Buffalo wings come in an 8-piece serving with a great amount of meat and a very tasty sauce. They appear alongside other items like garlic Parmesan wings and pizzas.

Pasta dishes stay moist and full of flavor even after two nights in the fridge. The Legacy pie combines pesto, signature pizza sauce, and alfredo sauce for a unique taste. Sandwiches like the Italian and pastrami come alongside antipasta salad and wings.

People are saying

"The staff here makes you feel so welcome and at home."

"These Buffalo Wings are juicy, flavorful, and a good size."

Good to know

1

Lunch specials are available from Monday to Friday between 11 AM and 2 PM.

2

They charge $1.99 for each topping and $4.00 extra for vegan cheese.

3

The restaurant is clean and family-friendly.

02
Best Pizza & Brew image 1
Best Pizza & Brew image 2
Best Pizza & Brew image 3
View all

Open layout combines sports bar vibe with in-house brewery and multiple TVs showing extreme sports. Loud music and narrow walkways create a lively but sometimes chaotic atmosphere, especially during games. Patio seating with heat lamps offers a cozy outdoor option for dining and drinks.

Boneless and traditional buffalo wings come with a strong flavor and pair well with other items like pizza and garlic knots. Wings often arrive alongside a hazy IPA, making for a solid combo.

Burrata Sausage Hot Honey pizza stands out with its perfect sweet spot and rich flavor. Other notable dishes include goat cheese pesto and buffalo chicken pizza, along with a tasty marinara sauce.

People are saying

"The Italian food, especially the Burrata Sausage Hot Honey pizza, is usually to die for."

"The Buffalo Wings were crispy and a little spicy."

Good to know

1

Happy hour special runs from 2 to 4 pm on weekdays for $2.50 a slice.

2

They offer $6 margaritas on Tuesdays as part of their specials.

3

The restaurant has very limited seating, so arrive early.

03
Johnny's The Bronx Pizza image 1
Johnny's The Bronx Pizza image 2
Johnny's The Bronx Pizza image 3
View all

Small pizza spot with old-school New York vibe and cozy seating, including some tables with umbrellas outside. Atmosphere stays super chill and welcoming, even when busy with people and street activity. Known for quality, fast service and reasonably priced pizzas that offer a lighter, fresh taste.

Large, juicy chicken wings come drenched in lots of buffalo sauce. These buffalo wings stand out for their size and flavor.

Fresh mozzarella sticks start the meal with a crisp bite. The pizza sauce strikes a great balance between acidity and sweetness. The tiramisu stands out as a rich, satisfying dessert.

People are saying

"This Italian food is authentic New York style and the pizza slices are really large."

"The buffalo wings here are large, juicy, and have a really good flavor."

Good to know

1

Parking is street parking with plenty of spots around.

2

Expect a wait time of up to 1 hour for delivery.

3

The restaurant has limited dine-in seating available.

04
Ace's Pizza image 1
Ace's Pizza image 2
Ace's Pizza image 3
View all

Wood-paneled walls and retro 90s decor set a nostalgic vibe with Detroit style pizza and lively music. Buffalo wings are perfectly spicy and meaty, while squared pizzas offer a cheesy texture like lasagna. Burrata slices bring consistent flavor that pairs well with spicy toppings.

Buffalo wings have a perfect amount of spice and come nice and meaty. They taste good enough to order again.

Squared pizzas come with a very cheesy texture, almost like lasagna. The burrata slices are consistently flavorful and pair well with spicy toppings like pepperoni and chili oil.

People are saying

"Their Italian food, especially the hot burrata pizza, is insane."

"The hot burrata pizza is spicy and delicious."

"The garlic breadsticks are airy and crispy with great sauce."

Good to know

1

You have to order online on their website since they do not use delivery apps.

2

No reservations are accepted, so arrive on time.

3

The place gets busy on weekends, so come early or be prepared to wait.

05
P.S. Kitchen image 1
P.S. Kitchen image 2
P.S. Kitchen image 3
View all

Vegan restaurant offers spicy buffalo wings perfect for sharing and pairs well with crafted cocktails. Cozy atmosphere with modern decor and outdoor terrace enhances dining. Italian dishes like rich lasagna and linguini shine with fresh, balanced flavors.

Buffalo wings have a spicy kick and a good texture. They work well for sharing with the table and pair nicely with cocktails.

Lasagna stands out with rich, fresh flavors and perfect preparation. The pasta sauce blends well, complementing dishes like Linguini Alfredo and vegan options such as linguini and crab cakes.

People are saying

"Some say the lasagna and pasta taste good, others find them bland or small."

"The Italian Food here is great and the service is really good."

"I loved the tiramisu and panna cotta for their creamy, rich flavors."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended, especially for dinner during show nights.

2

The weekend brunch is popular and can get busy.

3

Every purchase at P.S. Kitchen supports social causes.

06
Justino's Pizza image 1
Justino's Pizza image 2
Justino's Pizza image 3
View all

Pizza restaurant offers ample space with tiny tables and a warm, authentic atmosphere. Energy shifts from calm and quiet to bustling during peak hours. Music adds to the inviting vibe, and the place stays open late.

Buffalo wings come with a balanced seasoning that stands out in the appetizer sampler. They pair well with calamari and mozzarella sticks, making the sampler enjoyable.

Fresh basil, tomatoes, and mozzarella shine on the Margherita pizza. Pasta dishes like penne vodka and chicken Parmigiano come in good-sized portions. Appetizers include calamari and mozzarella sticks, while desserts feature tiramisu and cheesecake.

People are saying

"I enjoyed the mozzarella sticks but some dishes fell short."

"The pasta portions were big and the penne vodka was amazing."

"The Italian food's pizza slices were large and satisfying."

Good to know

1

Justino's can get busy during peak hours, so it's wise to plan accordingly or make a reservation.

2

The establishment closed at 4:00 PM.

3

The restaurant does not charge customers extra for using a bank card instead of cash.

07
Deninoโ€™s Pizzeria & Tavern image 1
Deninoโ€™s Pizzeria & Tavern image 2
Deninoโ€™s Pizzeria & Tavern image 3
View all

Old-school pizza restaurant with a rustic atmosphere and loud, lively energy. Space includes a bar, two dining rooms, and an outdoor seating area. Known for friendly vibe and classic murals that create a welcoming, familiar setting.

Buffalo wings come out nice and crispy with a solid buffalo flavor. The buffalo cauliflower offers a similar spicy kick and both stand out as really good options.

Fresh mozzarella cheese stands out across dishes like the fresh mozzarella pie and eggplant tower with tomato and balsamic. The penne alla vodka pasta and clam pasta offer solid Italian classics, while the pizza features savory prosciutto that is not too salty.

People are saying

"The Italian food's penne alla vodka pasta is really good and creamy."

"The buffalo wings are crispy outside and juicy inside."

"The Italian egg roll really stood out."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is cash only, so bring cash for your meal.

2

Expect to street park nearby due to limited parking options.

3

They only serve full pizzas, not slices for takeout.

08
Red Bamboo image 1
Red Bamboo image 2
Red Bamboo image 3
View all

Small basement restaurant offers a cozy vibe with creative, artistic decor and visual harmony. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, lively when full but intimate due to clear plastic barriers between tables. Known for allergen-free vegan options that impress even non-vegans.

Barbecue and Buffalo wings come with amazing sauces and a vegan bleu cheese dressing option. Celery with dip pairs well with the BBQ buffalo wings.

Tiramisu stands out as moist and delicious, noted as a vegan version that impresses. The Chicken Parmesan features a nice sauce and gets positive mentions. The bolognese also delivers solid flavor.

People are saying

"I loved the barbecue Buffalo wings; they were tasty."

"I love the buffalo wings and the celery dip is a must."

"I loved the chicken parmesan and its sauce."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is 100% vegan.

2

One main dish is enough per person due to the abundant portions.

3

The prices on appetizers are absolutely insane, some $17 or more.

09
University Ave Pizzeria image 1
University Ave Pizzeria image 2
University Ave Pizzeria image 3
View all

Interior features clean, inviting design with multiple TVs showing sports and movies creating a lively atmosphere. Seating accommodates both small and large groups, supporting social gatherings. The setup emphasizes sports viewing, making it a popular spot for fans.

Buffalo wings have a great flavor but often come overcooked and only half tossed in sauce.

Pizza and pasta stand out with excellent flavors. Cheese stuffed bread comes with pesto and marinara sauces. Homemade meatballs pair well with marinara, and Alfredo sauce mushroom pasta offers a rich taste.

People are saying

"This Italian food's pizza crust is thin, flavorful, and crispy."

"The Buffalo Wings here had a great flavor."

Good to know

1

Ordering online on WebWednesday with the discount code gets a large pizza for under $10.

2

Students receive a free drink and garlic knots with a pizza order when showing ID.

3

They accept Apple Pay for convenient payments.

Discover more

United States

Area guide