Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Loved by locals

Key lime pie and caramel in the US

Made for those who believe that the tartness of key lime pie is only truly elevated by the deep, buttery sweetness of caramel.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Darlene's Ice Cream image 1
Darlene's Ice Cream image 2
Darlene's Ice Cream image 3
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop with warm, inviting scent of brownies and waffle cones fills the air. Space feels cheerful and welcoming with a cute, carefully crafted design. Offers vegan and gluten-free options alongside expertly made artisan ice cream and coffee drinks.

Offers a key lime pie flavor that stands out for its phenomenal taste and inventive approach. This flavor ranks among the most favored alongside unique options like coffee caramel crunch.

Salted caramel appears in a pretzel that tastes like the milk of Froot Loops. Coffee caramel crunch offers a perfect coffee flavor and texture. Red miso caramel pairs with sesame ice cream for a surprisingly delicious combo.

People are saying

"The ice cream shop's flavors are so creative and delicious."

"The coffee caramel crunch has the perfect amount of coffee flavor and texture."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was a must-try."

Good to know

1

They offer 16 rotating flavors, including unique options like Toasted Sesame and Lychee Sorbet.

2

Darlene's Ice Cream has vegan and lactose-free options available.

3

The shop is family-run by two talented Denver chefs.

02
Pop Pie Co. image 1
Pie shop

Pie shop offers cozy outdoor seating with heated lamps and a charming storefront featuring window counters. Atmosphere feels warm and welcoming, attracting groups and casual meetups with a positive vibe. Location on a busy street provides good people watching and a snug, inviting environment.

Flavor, texture, and crust of the key lime pie stand out as truly exceptional. Fresh pies are available, though some are pre-packed for convenience.

Salted caramel appears in several desserts, including a salted caramel apple pie that balances cinnamon and caramel well. Coconut salted caramel and caramel ala mode options offer super sweet flavors, often paired with ice cream for added richness.

People are saying

"The key lime pie's flavor and texture were truly exceptional."

"I couldn't stop eating the Key Lime Pie; it was delicious."

"You have to try the salted apple caramel crumb pie."

Good to know

1

Pop Pie Co. does not accept cash; they only take card payments.

2

Parking is challenging with only street parking available.

3

There are few tables inside, but plenty of outdoor seating.

03
Legacy Pie Co.- Wash Park image 1

Pie shop offers sweet and savory pies in a clean, minimalistic setting with no dine-in area, focusing on grab-and-go. Atmosphere feels cute and home-like with a friendly staff and a delicious smell upon entry.

Perfect balance of sweet and tart defines the key lime pie here. It comes gluten-free and stands out as absolutely incredible compared to other pies.

Bourbon caramel apple pies stand out with rich, sweet flavors. Small pies like honey maple pecan and s'mores also feature distinctive caramel notes.

People are saying

"I thought the pies here were amazing and delicious."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be absolutely incredible."

"I found the caramel pies to be amazing."

Good to know

1

Legacy Pie Co. offers both sweet and savory pies in full and individual sizes.

2

Gluten-free cherry pie and other gluten-free options are available.

3

The shop is designed for grab-and-go purchases with no dining area.

04
Eileen's Special Cheesecake image 1

Small bakery offers high-quality cheesecakes in a cozy, busy space with limited seating. Key lime pie flavor is popular and pairs well with raspberry lemonade. Salted caramel cheesecake delights with its melty texture and balanced sweetness.

Key lime pie appears as a popular flavor among several cheesecake options. It pairs well with drinks like raspberry lemonade and stands out among other flavors like salted caramel and Oreo.

Salted caramel cheesecake stands out with its melty texture and rich but balanced flavor. Caramel flavor appears in several cheesecakes, all light and full of flavor without being too sweet or heavy.

People are saying

"I found the cheesecake here to be divine and melt-in-your-mouth delicious."

"The salted caramel cheesecake is surprisingly refreshing."

"The Key Lime Pie is light, fluffy, and delicious."

Good to know

1

The shop is small and has no seating, so you will probably have to take your order to go.

2

Each cheesecake is freshly homemade on-site.

3

The prices are very expensive for non-New Yorkers in relation to the size.

05
Bright Ice Scoop Shop Water St image 1

Cozy ice cream shop with unique flavors and generous portions creates a welcoming vibe. Bright, clean space includes outdoor seating and offers reusable tasting spoons for samples. Atmosphere feels fresh and inviting, appealing to families and casual visitors alike.

Key Lime Pie ice cream stands out with a bright, tangy flavor. It competes closely with other unique options like lemon caramelized ginger and oat of this world.

Sea salt caramel stands out with its rich flavor and pairs well in a sugar cone or with marshmallow cookies. Salted caramel ice cream offers a delicious balance of sweet and salty notes.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are so creative and delicious."

"You have to try the sea salt caramel ice cream; it's delicious."

"I found the Key Lime Pie ice cream to be exceptional."

Good to know

1

The shop offers many unique flavor options not found in typical ice cream shops.

2

Generous portions of ice cream are served at reasonable prices.

3

Dairy-free options are available for those with dietary restrictions.

06
Mia's Brooklyn Bakery image 1

Bakery offers cozy indoor seating and a quiet backyard garden with beautiful lighting for a relaxed atmosphere. Space feels crowded and noisy inside, with tables placed closely together. Outdoor area provides a calm spot to enjoy desserts and drinks away from the bustle.

Creamy texture stands out with a perfect balance of sweet and tart flavors. Consistently described as perfect and enjoyable by many.

Salted caramel cake stands out with a rich flavor that works well warm or cold. Cheesecakes come in several varieties including caramel, pecan caramel, and classic, all with a smooth, creamy texture.

People are saying

"I found the cake here to be amazing and delicious."

"The salted caramel cupcake was excellent, a real chef's kiss."

"I found the Key Lime Pie to be so creamy and perfect."

Good to know

1

Mia's is open until midnight on weekends and 10 PM on weeknights.

2

Expect a 15-minute wait for to-go desserts during peak hours.

3

Parking near the bakery is challenging, with limited metered spaces.

07
Pie Snob Chandler image 1

Pie shop offers ample indoor seating and an extensive variety of pies and cheesecakes. A 24-hour pie vending machine provides convenient access, though it sometimes stops working due to heat exposure. The atmosphere feels comfortable and homely, inviting casual visits throughout the day.

Tart and delicious, the Key Lime Pie features a good filling with a bright, flavorful taste. It stands out alongside other desserts like turtle cheesecake and razzleberry pie.

Caramel shines in the caramel apple pie, which features a homemade caramel flavor and a perfect crumble topping. This pie stands out as a unique and delicious treat.

People are saying

"I thought the apple pie and chocolate cream pie were amazing."

"The caramel apple pie was delicious and a unique masterpiece."

"The Key Lime Pie here is tart and delicious."

Good to know

1

The pie vending machine is often out of order due to its eastern exposure.

2

Parking is available on site for easy access.

3

They offer pie by the slice, allowing you to try different flavors.

08
14 Prime image 1
Steak house

Upscale steakhouse with elegant design and ambient lighting creates a sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere. Guests receive personalized touches like floral arrangements and complimentary champagne upon arrival. The space features a notable bar and spacious seating, fostering a lively but warm environment.

Finishes with key lime pie that includes blueberries and is well-made. The pie has a strong incredible flavor that stands out.

A caramel cloud arrives as a surprise from the pastry chef after espresso. It stands out as a unique, sweet finish to the meal.

People are saying

"The steak here is served with flawless, attentive service."

"The Key Lime Pie here is served with such personal, attentive service."

"The warm bread with miso honey butter made me feel at home."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for special events like 14 Prime.

2

Guests should place cocktail orders ahead of time for events.

3

The restaurant offers personalized experiences for special occasions.

09
Carnegie Diner & Cafe image 1

Upscale diner with cramped seating and dim lighting creates a classic yet hectic atmosphere. Live music and a small patio add to the vibe, while bottomless mimosas and standout dishes like the burger and French toast draw attention. Crowds fill the space, making it lively but noisy.

Not too sweet or tart, the key lime pie has a buttery flaky crust and contains no coconut. It comes highly praised for its balanced flavor and is often chosen over other desserts.

French toast comes with caramel, bacon, sugar walnuts, and sweet mascarpone. Caramel macchiato offers a smooth, sweet coffee flavor. Fresh squeezed orange juice pairs well with the caramel dishes.

People are saying

"The food here is a peaceful escape from busy routines."

"The caramel French toast is delicious and tasty."

"I thought the Key Lime Pie was delicious."

Good to know

1

Make reservations for Easter Sunday to ensure a spot.

2

Unlimited mimosas for $20 are available every day all day.

3

Bottomless mimosas and waffles are available on Sunday morning.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...