Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
the US' best

Cherry Pie

A slice of cherry pie that tastes like it came from a home kitchen rather than a mass-produced factory line.

Based on 481 Opinions
+478
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
First Slice Pie Cafe Manor image 1
First Slice Pie Cafe Manor image 2
First Slice Pie Cafe Manor image 3
View all

Cozy cafe offers train views and a chill vibe perfect for a casual break. Their Michigan Cherry Pie shines with rich, balanced fruit flavors. Sandwiches are varied and satisfying, making it a great spot for lunch or dessert.

Michigan Cherry Pie stands out with its rich cherry filling and balanced sweetness. It pairs well with their apple pie, both offering a phenomenal fruit flavor.

People are saying

"The French silk pie here is my favorite dessert."

"I loved their zesty and tasty Cuban sandwich."

"I loved their Michigan Cherry Pie; it made me happy."

Good to know

1

Sandwich prices range from $10 to $13.

2

Limited seating is available, so plan to arrive early.

3

Parking is challenging; consider parking a few blocks away.

02
Achatz Handmade Pie Company image 1

Shop fills with divine aroma of fresh pies and baked goods. Handmade cherry pie stands out with delicious flavor. Clean, tidy space offers a wide variety of fruit, cream, and meat pies, making Pie day lively and busy.

Handmade cherry pie offers a delicious and satisfying flavor.

People are saying

"I found the pies here to be so delicious."

"The lobster pot pie was incredible and delicious."

"I found the cherry pie to be delicious."

Good to know

1

Achatz Handmade Pie Company sells a variety of homemade pies, cookies, and frozen soups.

2

Prices for pies are higher due to the use of local ingredients.

3

Pies are made fresh daily, with some flavors available only seasonally.

03
Honeypie Bakeshop image 1

Small space fills quickly with a warm, cozy vibe. Cherry pie offers a tartness balanced by cold custard and a good crust made from graham cracker, perfect for those with nut allergies. Late hours and focus on dessert and coffee create a relaxed, casual experience.

Warm slices of cherry pie come with a tartness balanced by cold custard, creating a perfect mix. The pie has a good crust and blends sweetness with slight acidity.

People are saying

"I was assured they could make the pie with a graham cracker crust."

"I was so disappointed to miss out on dessert because they changed the pie crust."

"The cherry pie's tartness and sweetness with cold custard is a perfect combination."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended for special dietary requests, especially for allergies.

2

Pies cost $8.50 each, with slices being small for the price.

3

The shop offers a pie of the month, which changes regularly.

04
Winston Pies image 1
Pie shop

Pie shop shines with freshly baked aroma and a welcoming atmosphere. Cherry pie boasts a perfect balance of sweetness and flaky crust. Outdoor seating complements the gluten-free and vegan options for a quality experience.

Cherry pie features a perfect balance of sweetness and a flaky crust. Small pies offer a satisfying portion that many enjoy regularly.

People are saying

"The pie crust here is perfectly buttery and delicious."

"The pies here are heavenly, with a perfect balance of sweet and flaky crust."

"I had Cherry Pie that was unlike any I had before."

Good to know

1

Winston Pies offers gluten-free and vegan options without sacrificing taste or texture.

2

The price of the slices is $10.00 each.

3

A whole pie costs $59.

05
Petee's Pie Company image 1

Cozy space with intimate vibe and sweet, buttery aromas welcomes pie lovers. Sour cherry pie shines with amazing flavor and perfect tartness. Quiet atmosphere enhances the nostalgic feel for a homestyle dessert experience.

Sour cherry pie stands out with its amazing flavor and delicious tartness. The American cherry pie offers a phenomenal balance of sweet and sour that makes it a dream dessert.

People are saying

"The American Food here, especially the pies, is amazing."

"The banana cream pie here is unreal in flavor."

"I thought the cherry pie was one of the best I've ever eaten."

Good to know

1

Pies are sold by the slice or whole.

2

Prices for pies range from $7.25 to $8 per slice.

3

There is limited seating in the pie shop.

06
The Flaky Apple Pie Co image 1

Pie shop shines with flaky crusts and rich cherry filling that pleases skeptics. Offers gluten-free and vegan options, plus ready-to-bake pies perfect for freezer storage. Classes add a fun, educational twist to learning pie making.

Rich cherry filling wins over even cherry pie skeptics. Family favorites include the Cherry Pie alongside Chicken Pot Pie and Nutella turnovers. Plans often include ordering more pies like the Cherry Pie for special occasions.

People are saying

"I thought the pie was flaky, delicious, and not too sweet."

"The pies here are outstanding for dinner."

"I've never liked cherry pie until I tried this one!"

Good to know

1

Pre-ordering by November 5th is necessary to ensure availability.

2

Brooke offers gluten-free and vegan pies for dietary needs.

3

The pie making class is fun and provides easy-to-follow instructions.

07
The Wooden Spoon Kitchen and Bakery image 1

Cozy family restaurant offers a warm atmosphere and adorable decor perfect for relaxing. Cherry pie shines as a notable dessert, pairing well with hearty meals like chicken fried steak. Entertainment options keep the family-friendly vibe lively all day.

Cherry pie stands out as a notable dessert option. It pairs well with hearty meals like chicken fried steak and comes available for takeout.

People are saying

"The food here was always great and fresh."

"This lunch spot's burgers with fried green tomatoes are amazing."

"I found the cherry pie to be exceptional."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is only open for lunch from Monday to Thursday.

2

Expect long wait times on weekends due to high demand.

3

Desserts are available, and it's advisable to ask about options.

08
Bubby's image 1
American restaurant

American restaurant buzzes with loud music and close seating. Sour cherry pie shines with tart flavor, hailed as the city's best. Bright indoor and covered outdoor spaces add a chic vibe, while a retro photo booth in the basement offers unique charm.

Sour cherry pie stands out with its nice and tart flavor and is often called the best in the city. It pairs well with English breakfast tea and is considered excellent by many.

People are saying

"The food here is authentic, comforting American cuisine."

"These pancakes are fluffy, thick, and perfectly golden."

"I thought the sour cherry pie was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Bubby's does not take reservations on weekends for brunch.

2

Expect to wait at least 30 minutes to an hour on weekends.

3

Bubby's only accepts walk-in customers.

09
Polly's Pies Restaurant & Bakery image 1

Old school diner with a fresh baked smell and an open air kitchen featuring stainless steel appliances. Cherry pie shines with fresh cherries and a crispy crust, sweetened just right. Locals love sitting outside with dogs, enjoying fresh pies and pastries.

Fresh cherries and a crispy crust define the cherry pie here. It comes sweetened to perfection and is often served as a satisfying dessert slice.

People are saying

"I found the pie to be delicious and fresh."

"The breakfast service here is friendly and fast."

"The Cherry Pie has fresh cherries and a crispy crust."

Good to know

1

Expect a 30-minute wait for pickup orders during busy times.

2

The restaurant offers a special Bingo event every Wednesday.

3

The Prime Rib costs $19.99, providing a hearty meal option.

10
Noble Pies image 1
Pie shop

Small shop offers cozy atmosphere with quiet backyard seating. Cherry pie shines with fresh, flaky crust and delicious taste. Vegan options add variety to the carefully curated menu.

Cherry pie stands out as a favorite with a delicious taste that impresses consistently. It comes in styrofoam packaging for easy takeout.

People are saying

"I found the pies here to be amazing and delicious."

"I found the pies at this Local Spot to be perfection."

"The cherry pie was beyond delicious."

Good to know

1

The pies cost $8 per slice.

2

Expect a wait on weekends due to the shop's small size.

3

Call ahead on Mondays to confirm hours if you're not local.

11
Tortoise Supper Club image 1
American restaurant

Elegant supper club offers a cozy vibe with live jazz music and dark wood decor. Cherry pie shines with bright, tart cherries and soft texture. Private room with bar adds intimate vibes amid lively crowd.

Bright, tart cherries fill the pie with a soft, flavorful texture. The dessert stands out for its freshness and balanced tartness.

People are saying

"The food at these dinner spots was spectacular and delicious."

"I enjoyed the amazing jazz music during my visit."

"The cherry pie was the perfect way to finish the meal."

Good to know

1

Reservations are required for private events and should be made well in advance.

2

Happy hour runs from 4-6pm on weekdays with discounted drinks and appetizers.

3

Valet parking costs $16 for three hours, making it convenient for guests.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...