Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

Consignment shops

Consignment shopping that feels like a curated closet search instead of digging through a donation bin.

Based on 493 Opinions
+490
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
DeFrenS Consignment Furniture, Home Decor and Gifts image 1
DeFrenS Consignment Furniture, Home Decor and Gifts image 2
DeFrenS Consignment Furniture, Home Decor and Gifts image 3
View all

Consignment shop offers a beautifully curated mix of high-quality antiques, unique furniture, and artwork. Atmosphere feels friendly and welcoming, with creative workshops adding a community vibe. Prices remain reasonable, making it a hidden gem for discovering treasures.

Beautiful and Brutalist furniture stands out among the pieces. Items are always interesting and of high quality.

Offers a wide range of furniture, home decor, and gifts with consistently high quality. Serves as a reliable spot for diverse consignment finds.

People are saying

"I found so many unique furniture and home wares here."

"I found so many unique and cool items at this consignment shop."

"I found interesting items, especially the Brutalist furniture."

Good to know

1

The store offers a wide variety of unique furniture and home decor items.

2

New items arrive frequently, ensuring a fresh selection for visitors.

3

Prices are reasonable, making it accessible for budget-conscious shoppers.

02
McShane's Exchange Consignment image 1

Bright, beautifully curated consignment shop with an artful layout and upbeat music sets a relaxed, friendly atmosphere. Offers a great mix of designer and affordable items, including unique vintage pieces and well-sized selections. Dressing rooms add convenience to a calm, well-organized shopping experience.

Selection includes unique and creative items like jewelry and coats. Pieces feel fun and interesting, offering something for everyone.

Offers a great selection of designer clothes with a wide range of styles and price points. The store is well organized and carries sizes up to L and XL, making it easy to find quality items and luxury consignment pieces.

People are saying

"I found really cute women's clothing in great shape."

"I found so many unique, quality designer pieces at this consignment shop."

"I found so many unique and interesting pieces here."

Good to know

1

The store offers a great selection of designer and affordable items.

2

Items are well-organized and easy to browse.

3

The store frequently updates its inventory with new stock.

03
Cooky's Thrift & Consignment image 1

Shop offers well-organized space with unique vintage items and beautiful furniture downstairs. Atmosphere feels comfortable and relaxing with a warm vibe. Window displays stand out as a distinctive feature.

Interesting finds appear throughout the store with lots of unique items at reasonable prices. The helpful proprietors add to the engaging shopping experience.

Offers a hidden gem vibe for consignment shoppers. Carries unique items like authentic fur coats among thrift finds.

People are saying

"The owner Robert at this thrift store is so warm and insightful."

"Robert was so helpful and funny during our consignment shopping."

"Robert's lively personality made for an interesting shopping experience."

Good to know

1

The store is well-organized and has a lot of one-of-a-kind things.

2

Expect to find a huge variety of items at reasonable prices.

3

The shop offers a unique selection of vintage clothes and jewelry.

04
Rebound Consignment Furniture image 1

Furniture store offers a wide variety of high-quality, unique preloved pieces with a well-curated selection that changes frequently. The atmosphere feels fresh and eclectic, attracting those seeking one-of-a-kind finds at honest prices.

Selection features unique furniture pieces that stand out. Prices remain great while offering an interesting variety.

Many consignment items include eclectic, fun, modern, and old pieces. Furniture tends to be high quality but expensive. Assistance with shipping quotes is available.

People are saying

"The staff at this furniture store is so friendly and helpful."

"Jeanne was so helpful with my consignment design ideas and shipping."

"I found interesting and unique pieces here."

Good to know

1

Rebound offers a wide variety of well-maintained, unique furniture pieces.

2

The store frequently updates its inventory with new items.

3

Purchasing and delivery processes are seamless and easy.

05
Beacon's Closet image 1
Second hand store

Store feels cramped and crowded with narrow aisles and tightly hung clothes, making browsing challenging. Music plays loud jazz, creating a vibrant and funky atmosphere. Organization is neat, with clothes sorted by color, and the selection includes unique vintage pieces.

Varied clothes with lots of labeled brands create an interesting mix. The store's curation offers many good prices on unique pieces.

Offers a high-end consignment selection with a vintage focus. The shop has a cute, curated vibe that stands out among thrift stores.

People are saying

"I found so many unique designer women's clothing pieces at amazing prices."

"I found so many interesting clothes and shoes here."

"I found it to be one of the best high-end consignment stores."

Good to know

1

Beacon's Closet allows you to sell items for 50% in store credit or 30% in cash.

2

Beacons has a new fitting room policy that requires customers to prioritize their first 6 items.

3

The store offers the best resale value for vintage items.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...