Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of US

Cookie and Ice Cream Sandwiches

Made for those who believe the only way to improve a classic cookie is to sandwich it around a generous scoop of ice cream.

Based on 825 Opinions
+822
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
The Baked Bear image 1
The Baked Bear image 2
The Baked Bear image 3
View all
Ice cream shop

Shop offers fresh-baked cookies aroma and customizable ice cream sandwiches in a clean, modern space. Atmosphere feels cozy and inviting with a fun, vibrant energy. Kids and families often enjoy the variety and friendly environment.

Warm cookies pair with cold ice cream to create delicious ice cream sandwiches. Freshly baked cookies come in daily homemade varieties that match well with inventive ice cream flavors for endless customization.

Homemade bakery cookies pair with a select group of ice cream flavors to create customizable ice cream sandwiches. Friendly staff craft each sandwich with care, making the cookie ice cream sandwiches notably delicious and unique.

People are saying

"Melinda made the best ice cream cookie sandwich I've ever had."

"The brownie ice cream sandwich was decadent and messy in the best way."

"The ice cream sandwich here is amazing, thanks to Bella's friendly service."

Good to know

1

Customers can customize their desserts with various cookies and ice cream flavors.

2

The establishment offers a unique selection of cookies and ice cream sandwiches.

3

Seating is limited inside, so plan accordingly during busy hours.

02
Schmackary's image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop offers a cozy atmosphere with a friendly, welcoming vibe that feels like a warm hug. Bright displays showcase an extensive variety of cookies, including egg-free and vegan options. The place feels comfortable and inviting, perfect for a relaxed sweet break.

Cookies combine crispy and soft textures with rich flavors. The blueberry cobbler cookie stands out as a popular choice among many.

Huge ice cream sandwiches feature classic chocolate chip and cookie dough cookies with tasty ice cream inside. These sandwiches stand out for their big size and delicious flavor.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and tasty."

"The atmosphere here feels so cozy and welcoming."

"I found the ice cream sandwich to be very tasty."

Good to know

1

Schmackary's offers a variety of cookie flavors that change monthly.

2

Vegan and gluten-free cookie options are available.

3

Parking is available, but the lot can be congested.

03
The Pastry Project - Bakery Window image 1

Window storefront offers a clean, well-organized takeout experience with no seating. Soft serve stands out as unique and highly praised, often selling out quickly and drawing lines even on weekdays. Lending library and community mission add a distinctive social impact to the spot.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out with a gooey texture and rich flavor. The oatmeal cookie offers a chewy bite that complements the variety.

Offers pan de muerto ice cream sandwiches with unique flavors like strawberry and orange/anise. The ice cream sandwiches taste even better than they look and stand out for their delicious quality.

People are saying

"Their soft serve ice cream is the best in the city."

"I thought this ice cream sandwich was awesome."

"I was a snob about these chocolate chip cookies."

Good to know

1

The soft serve is priced around $7, which is considered expensive for the area.

2

Expect long lines, especially on weekends, as they sell out quickly.

3

The bakery does not have seating available; it's strictly a takeout window.

04
Sweet Lich's image 1
Cookie shop

Cookie shop with Instagram chic decor and family-friendly design including a chalk wall and toy box for kids. Atmosphere feels warm and playful with seating by large windows and a cushioned sofa. Known for best cookies in town, creating a welcoming spot for families and cookie lovers alike.

Chocolate chip cookies stand out as some of the best in the area. These cookies have a unique taste and texture that make them amazing and highly memorable.

Cookie ice cream sandwiches stand out with their rich flavor and texture. You can even customize your own sandwich using their cookies, though prices are on the higher side.

People are saying

"These cookies are amazing, soft, and chewy."

"I thought the ice cream here was amazing and full of flavor."

"I found the ice cream sandwich incredibly delicious."

Good to know

1

Catering services are available for events like birthdays and corporate functions.

2

The shop maintains a clean environment for customers.

3

Sweet Lich's offers gluten-free cookie options.

05
The Good Batch Bakery image 1

Bright, cheery spot offers a calm vibe with thoughtful decor and a small shop warmth. Cookies shine with unique flavors like chai snickerdoodle and miso. Ice cream sandwiches pair soft, chewy cookies with rich flavors like pistachio honey butter and mango sticky rice.

Cookies come in classic and unconventional flavors like ube and cheddar. Varieties such as chai snickerdoodle, miso, and butter crunch stand out for their unique taste and texture.

Ice cream sandwiches feature soft and chewy cookies paired with rich ice cream flavors like pistachio honey butter, tahini chocolate chip, and mango sticky rice. Some include a gooey fudge drizzle and sea salt that enhances the taste.

People are saying

"The ice cream sandwiches here are pure dessert perfection."

"I'm obsessed with their amazing scones."

"I thought the ice cream sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

The shop closed an hour earlier than listed.

2

Good Batch has a deal where you can buy 5 cookies and get 1 free.

3

They have a great selection of non-vegan, vegan, and gluten-free pastries.

06
Stack Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Small ice cream shop with colorful decoration and a cute vibe. Offers customizable treats including homemade cookies and unique ice cream flavors like peppermint pie and ube. Atmosphere is fresh and clean, with limited seating and a late-night schedule.

Cookies come out warm and crispy with a soft, chewy center. They pair perfectly with ice cream in cookie sandwiches that blend melted ice cream and fresh cookies.

Freshly baked cookies sandwich cake batter ice cream for a rich, creamy texture. Customizing your own ice cream sandwich adds a fun, tasty twist to the classic treat.

People are saying

"The ice cream sandwiches here are amazing and huge."

"The staff is so patient and gentle with kids."

"The cookies here are fresh, crispy, and warm with a chewy center."

Good to know

1

The smallest cone with one scoop costs $8.

2

You can customize your treat in many ways.

3

The shop is open late for evening ice cream cravings.

07
Kween's image 1
Ice cream shop

Rolled ice cream is made fresh behind the counter, creating an engaging experience. Cozy space offers a low-key, chill vibe with happy energy and pretty creations. Customers enjoy unique, delicious flavors in a relaxed setting.

Chocolate chip cookies come warm and gooey, making a great base for ice cream sandwiches. The combo of cold mint chip ice cream with these cookies stands out. Peanut butter cookies are more average, while red velvet cookies include chocolate chips.

Chocolate chip cookies with mint chip ice cream create a standout ice cream sandwich here. The red velvet ice cream sandwich also offers a rich, sweet flavor that many enjoy.

People are saying

"I found the ice cream here to be amazing and delicious."

"The red velvet ice cream sandwich was so good."

"I really liked the red velvet ice cream sandwich."

Good to know

1

Prices range from $9.85 for kids cups to $11.85 for regular cups.

2

Kween's offers a large variety of flavors, mix-ins, and toppings.

3

They make everything fresh in front of customers.

08
Westside Creamery Sweet Spot image 1

Cozy family-owned dessert shop with a warm, welcoming vibe and a clean, visible kitchen. Offers artisan ice cream, fresh baked goods, and a wide sorbet selection. Outdoor seating and a book nook add to the inviting atmosphere.

A wide assortment of cookies stands out here, including pistachio cookies that are superb. Every cookie tastes fresh and homemade, not store-bought.

Delicious ice cream sandwiches stand out here. The concept of the Dubai Ice Cream Sandwich adds a unique twist to the classic treat.

People are saying

"The ice cream here is so rich, smooth, and bursting with flavor."

"I was already digging into the cookies 20 minutes after returning home."

"The oatmeal cookie ice cream sandwich is fresh and soft."

Good to know

1

Parking is available in the garage with validation.

2

Street parking is free nearby, but may require a short walk.

3

They offer multiple vegan options upon request.

09
Cry Baby Creamery image 1
Ice cream shop

Small shop with a dark gothic and mid-century vibe offers original flavors and amazing chocolate chip cookies. Atmosphere feels cute and modern, with a hidden gem quality. Ice cream is fresh and delicious, made in-house with local ingredients.

Cookies come in huge size with unique flavors like chocolate chip and guava. They have a thick, crispy outside and a gooey inside, making them a standout treat.

Pre-made ice cream sandwiches come in unique flavors like sticky fingers and box car. Vanilla ice cream fills these amazing sandwiches, making them stand out.

People are saying

"This ice cream is just unbelievably good."

"These cookies are amazing, genuinely some of the best I've had."

"The ice cream sandwiches here are amazing."

Good to know

1

Parking at Cry Baby Creamery can be challenging, so plan accordingly.

2

A single scoop costs $5, which is reasonable for the area.

3

They frequently change their ice cream flavors, offering unique options.

10
Aiskrimu Ice Cream Bar image 1

Ice cream shop offers a cozy atmosphere with vibrant decor in royal green and gold. The vibe stays chill and elegant, welcoming pets with outdoor seating and special treats. Flavors rotate regularly, featuring vegan and gluten-free options alongside inventive, high-quality soft serve.

Larger soft baked cookies come in flavors like oatmeal and snickerdoodle. They offer an oatmeal cookie sandwich with vanilla oat vegan ice cream and have toppings available.

Ice cream sandwiches come in fruity pebble, snickerdoodle, and vegan varieties. The ube ice cream sandwich is covered in Oreo pieces. They offer good value and work well for family desserts.

People are saying

"The ice cream sandwiches here are so yummy and a great value."

"I found the ice cream sandwiches to be very yummy and amazing."

"I loved the soft serve and amazing cookies."

Good to know

1

Aiskrimu Ice Cream Bar offers a variety of vegan and gluten-free options.

2

The menu features innovative flavors that change periodically.

3

Pints of ice cream, including vegan options, are available for takeout.

11
Peace Pie image 1
Ice cream shop

Colorful exterior and charming window setup create a welcoming scene. Atmosphere buzzes with anticipation and smiles as people enjoy handcrafted ice cream sandwiches featuring a huge variety of unique flavors. No seating or trash disposal on site, focusing on quick, flavorful treats.

Cookies come with a crispy, buttery crust that holds up well in ice cream sandwiches. They are simple but crisp and not stale, making them a solid base for the ice cream.

Massive, handcrafted ice cream sandwiches come in a large, well-curated selection with fun, unique flavor combinations. The quality stands out and makes the price worth it.

People are saying

"These desserts are creative, delicious, and a true highlight."

"The cookie here is so crispy and holds up well."

"I thought the ice cream sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

Peace Pie is cash only, which may complicate purchases.

2

Ice cream sandwiches cost $8 each, which some may find pricey.

3

There is no seating available for customers.

12
Just Baked image 1
Dessert shop

Fresh-baked cookies fill the air with a warm, inviting scent that matches the welcoming atmosphere and awesome energy. Music plays in the background while dog-friendly amenities add a thoughtful touch. The space feels simple but the focus on high-quality desserts stands out clearly.

Cookies come out freshly baked and warm, hitting a perfect sweet and slightly doughy spot. Varieties include white chocolate stuffed and Oreo-filled cookies, all nicely sized and high quality.

Massive ice cream sandwiches feature perfect cookies and rich ice cream. Brownies and rookies also stand out as exceptional treats.

People are saying

"These cookies are massive, soft, and flavorful."

"This Late Night Spot's cookies are so soft and delicious."

"The Ice Cream Sandwich here is massive and delicious."

Good to know

1

There is usually no wait at Just Baked.

2

Prices are reasonable, with small servings starting around $5.

3

Just Baked offers ice cream alongside their baked goods.

13
Bar Bludorn image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant offers a masculine, sleek interior with mid-century modern decor and warm wood accents. Atmosphere ranges from calm and relaxing to loud and lively, with most tables facing an open kitchen. The space feels secluded from the street despite corner location, creating a unique neighborhood vibe.

Chocolate chip skillet cookie stands out with its rich flavor and warm texture. Gluten-free cookie skillet tastes exceptionally good, making the lack of gluten barely noticeable.

Takes the form of a freshly made churro dipped in warm hot chocolate but served as ice cream. Stands out as a recommended dessert alongside chocolate cake.

People are saying

"The food here is absolutely excellent and delicious."

"The chocolate chip skillet cookie was a highlight."

"The ice cream sandwich is like a churro dipped in hot chocolate."

Good to know

1

Valet parking is available, but street parking can be challenging.

2

Happy hour is only available at the bar and patio.

3

Expect a packed bar during happy hour, so arrive early.

14
Supermoon Bakehouse image 1

Minimalist bakery offers a cozy outdoor seating area to enjoy salted chocolate chip cookies with rich flavor and creative twists like cranberry white chocolate macadamia nut. Big ice cream sandwiches feature strong ube and pandan flavors, making it a unique spot for sweet treats.

Salted chocolate chip cookies stand out with a rich, balanced flavor. Unique options like cranberry white chocolate macadamia nut and miso chocolate cookies offer a creative twist.

Big ice cream sandwiches feature strong ube and pandan flavors. Options include Ube Pandan and cookies with ube. The unique combinations stand out among typical ice cream treats.

People are saying

"The pastries here are amazingly creative and delicious."

"The Nutella croissant was pure bliss and generously filled."

"The ube ice cream sandwich cookie is amazing and delicious."

Good to know

1

They only accept cards and do not accept cash.

2

Check their working days and hours before visiting as they donโ€™t open every day.

3

Get there early as a line forms before they open.

15
Elio's image 1
Ice cream shop

Ice cream shop offers unique donut toppings and soft, rich cookies that blend chocolate and vanilla. Doughnut ice cream sandwiches let you build your own flavors, while cookie sandwiches stay cool without melting. Friendly vibe with a retro Pac-Man game and cozy seating.

Soft, rich cookies blend chocolate and vanilla flavors well. The white macadamia nut cookie pairs nicely with mora ice cream, showing care in preparation.

Doughnut ice cream sandwiches come with options to build your own doughnut flavors. Cookie ice cream sandwiches use real cookies and stay cool without melting quickly.

People are saying

"The ice cream staff here are so friendly and welcoming."

"The donut ice cream sandwich was delicious and amazing."

"The cookie ice cream sandwich just melts in your mouth."

Good to know

1

The dessert spot is open until 2AM on the weekend.

2

John Depp ice cream is 21+ only.

3

The ice cream sandwich costs $15.00.

16
Midnight Cookies & Cream Davie image 1

Cookie shop with cool aesthetic and pretty wall paintings creates a cozy, chill vibe despite loud music. The smell of fresh cookies fills the air, drawing in those seeking late-night treats. Limited seating encourages quick visits rather than long stays.

Cookies here stand out for their unique flavors like Cinnamon Toast Crunch and sโ€™more, often paired with creamy ice cream. They serve warm, sweet cookies late into the night with great customer service.

Gourmet cookies like red velvet and sugar cookie hold the ice cream in these sandwiches. Flavors include birthday cake and cookies and cream, offering a rich variety.

People are saying

"I found the cookies here to be amazing and delicious."

"I found the milkshakes to be absolutely delicious."

"I loved the monster ice cream sandwich."

Good to know

1

The shop is open until midnight, perfect for late-night cravings.

2

They offer a variety of cookie and ice cream combinations.

3

No bathroom is available for customers on-site.

17
Pasta|Bar image 1
Californian restaurant

Intimate kitchen counter seating surrounds chefs preparing innovative dishes, creating an immersive dining experience. Moody lighting and lively music set a vibrant, speakeasy-like atmosphere. Unique fusion cuisine and personalized touches like customized menus and Polaroid photos distinguish the setting.

Take-home cookies come with a Lunchbox that includes a mango yuzu popsicle and chocolates. Cookies are part of a delicious and inventive tasting menu with desserts.

Banana ice cream sandwiches come topped with caviar, blending playful and refined flavors. Desserts balance textures and tastes with a beautifully balanced presentation.

People are saying

"The Italian food here is technically flawless and deeply comforting."

"I loved the delicious and inventive tasting menu, including the take-home cookies."

"The intimate counter seating and chef explanations made the Ice Cream Sandwich special."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended, especially for special events like Valentine's Day.

2

The restaurant is located on the second floor, accessible via escalators.

3

Expect to pay around $300 per person for a full dining experience.

18
Crunchy B's image 1

Open, clean space offers a pleasant and inviting atmosphere with minimal seating. Fresh baked cookies feature crunchy edges and soft centers, paired with homemade ice cream. Pricing leans toward the higher side, reflecting a focus on quality and specialty flavors.

Cookies taste homemade and delicious with standout varieties like chocolate chip pecan, oatmeal, and sugar cookies. Texture ranges from crunchy yet soft in options like the honey almond cookie.

Homemade cookies and ice cream create a delicious ice cream sandwich. It stands out as a favorite menu item with a tasty combo of flavors.

People are saying

"These homemade cookies taste delicious and remind me of childhood."

"I loved their delicious, creamy homemade ice cream."

"The ice cream sandwich is delicious with homemade cookies and ice cream."

Good to know

1

Crunchy B's is open 7 days a week.

2

Six cookies cost $12, which may be considered expensive for their size.

3

The cookies are half the size of a palm, similar to mini cookies.

19
Sweet Treats Ice Cream Shop image 1

Ice cream shop offers free samples and a variety of unique flavors with an adorable interior and small outdoor seating. The atmosphere feels overpriced and touristy, with some merchandise and a flea market vibe nearby. It attracts those looking for a sweet treat near the beach but has a laid-back energy.

Cookies come homemade and wonderfully baked by the manager Anita, showing care in preparation. Some batches can be burnt, so quality varies.

Ice cream sandwiches here come with a delicious blend of flavors and textures. They offer a satisfying treat with every bite.

People are saying

"The ice cream staff here is so sweet and attentive."

"The staff here is so kind and patient with kids."

"I personally loved their delicious ice cream sandwiches."

Good to know

1

Free parking is available for customers.

2

The shop charges an extra dollar for cake cones, not listed on the menu.

3

Expect limited seating, so plan to visit during off-peak times.

20
Manhattan Beach Creamery image 1

Ice cream shop offers colorful decor and small outdoor seating with a nostalgic ambiance. It features a wide variety of flavors and creative ice cream sandwiches. Atmosphere is lively and pleasant, attracting those seeking a sweet treat near the beach.

Customization stands out with options for any cookie, any ice cream, and multiple toppings. Ice cream cookie sandwiches include house-made flavored ice cream and different types of cookies, creating a rich variety.

Made-to-order ice cream sandwiches come with a wide variety of flavors like Sea Salt Caramel and cookie dough. Cookies and cream ice cream adds a rich taste, and the sandwiches pair well with milkshakes.

People are saying

"I thought the homemade ice cream was rich and smooth."

"You can customize your ice cream cookie sandwich with any cookie and ice cream."

"I loved the made-to-order ice cream sandwiches."

Good to know

1

The shop offers a wide variety of ice cream flavors and products.

2

Expect long lines, but they move quickly.

3

Ice cream sandwiches can be customized with any cookie and ice cream.

21
Milk Sugar Love Creamery & Bakeshop image 1

Ice cream shop offers unique, creative flavors made with top-notch ingredients in a clean, bright, and warm space. The atmosphere stays chill and cool, with small tables and grab-and-go options. Flavors like Malted Cookie and Earl Grey stand out for their distinctiveness and quality.

Malted Cookie stands out with a perfect balance. Other flavors like Peanut Butter Cherry and Salted Caramel lean toward being too salty, but the cookies and soft baked goods remain delectable overall.

Peanut-chocolate stands out as a distinctive ice cream sandwich here. They sell these to-go frozen treats alongside ice cream cakes and baked goods.

People are saying

"The ice cream flavors here are truly unique and bursting with flavor."

"The ice cream here is rich, smooth, and phenomenal."

"I thought the ice cream cookie sandwich was the best I ever had."

Good to know

1

One scoop of ice cream costs around $6, which is considered expensive.

2

Toppings like sprinkles are an additional $2 each.

3

The portion sizes are small, especially for the price.

22
Insomnia Cookies image 1
Dessert shop

Small hole-in-the-wall dessert shop with warm, inviting atmosphere and freshly baked cookies. Offers late-night hours and vegan options, with a menu featuring ice cream sandwiches made from warm cookies. Limited seating and a visible back area add to the casual, quick-service vibe.

Warm, soft, and gooey cookies come fresh from the oven with a strong freshly baked aroma. Varieties like chocolate chunk and white chocolate macadamia nut stand out for their rich flavors.

Solid cookies wrap the ice cream, creating a transforming culinary experience with each bite. The ice cream sandwiches hold their shape well and offer a satisfying texture contrast.

People are saying

"These warm, heavenly cookies are the best I've ever had."

"The ice cream sandwiches here are a transforming culinary experience."

"The service at this Late Night Spot is quick and friendly."

Good to know

1

Most locations are open until 1am for walk-in and deliver up to 3am.

2

There are several vegan options and one gluten-free option available.

3

Expect a long line during peak hours, especially late at night.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...