Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in the US

Pet stores

You take the health and happiness of your animals seriously and only shop where the standards for pet care are as high as your own.

Based on 444 Opinions
+441
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
KMA Aquatic Pets image 1
KMA Aquatic Pets image 2
KMA Aquatic Pets image 3
View all
Tropical fish store

Tanks display healthy exotic fish including rare species like Moray eels and clown loaches in a clean, well-maintained setting. The atmosphere stays calm and welcoming, attracting enthusiasts seeking unique aquatic options and expert advice.

Wide selection of healthy fish and aquatic plants creates a cool vibe. Fish are lively and add to the overall awesome experience.

Very clean and well-maintained, this pet store specializes in aquatic pets. It stands out as a unique option for fish enthusiasts in the area.

People are saying

"The staff here are so nice and helpful with fish."

"The fish here are super alive and really cool."

"The owner really knows his stuff about the fish and products."

Good to know

1

They have a great variety of freshwater and saltwater fish.

2

The fish appear healthy and well-cared for.

3

The store is clean and well-maintained.

02
Reptile Island 3 image 1
Reptile store

Reptile store offers a large selection of reptiles and supplies with reasonable prices and healthy, well-cared-for animals. The atmosphere is clean and fresh, making it inviting for families and children to learn about reptiles. Quick visits are common, supported by a convenient layout and a fun turtle feeding program.

Arachnids section features many cool tarantulas and a huge scorpion. Reptile Island 3 offers a lot of interesting animals and pet supplies for enthusiasts.

Offers reasonable prices that are cheaper than most reptile and pet stores. Caters well to exotic pet enthusiasts with a cool and unique selection.

People are saying

"It's so kid friendly; the staff is patient and makes my kids feel comfortable."

"This pet store has a huge selection of reptiles and other cool animals."

"It's cool how many different reptiles and species they have."

Good to know

1

Reptile Island 3 has a large selection of reptiles and related animals.

2

All animals in the store look healthy and well cared for.

3

Prices are reasonable, often cheaper than most reptile and pet stores.

03
Pet Kingdom image 1
Tropical fish store

Tropical fish store with a wide selection of freshwater and saltwater fish, reptiles, and aquarium supplies. The atmosphere is cool and mellow with an unusual presence of an on-site rooster. Offers healthy fish and uncommon species not found in chain stores.

Tons of cool fish and a reptile exhibit make this place stand out. The environment feels laid back and mellow with lots of interesting animals to see.

Varieties of reptiles, fish, and unique pets appear here that chain stores lack. This store offers a wide range of supplies and animals beyond typical commercial options.

People are saying

"The staff here is super helpful with choosing fish."

"I found Pet Kingdom to be the best pet store I visited."

"It's a cool place with always something interesting to see."

Good to know

1

They have a shot clinic every Sunday run by ShotsForPets.

2

Pet Kingdom offers a wide variety of healthy freshwater and saltwater fish.

3

The store has a good selection of reptile supplies.

04
Fish World Aquarium image 1
Tropical fish store

Spacious tropical fish store with 2000-gallon tank and wide variety of exotic fish. Atmosphere feels inviting and clean, with tanks kept well maintained and fish arriving healthy. Frequent new stock and rare species create a unique selection not found elsewhere.

A really cool setup for all the tanks stands out here. The place features interesting displays that make it feel unique and engaging.

Selection of exotic and common fish stands out compared to average pet stores. Bettas receive better care and are not kept in small containers like in many chain stores.

People are saying

"The staff here are so friendly and knowledgeable about fish."

"It's a cool place with a lovely variety of aquarium creatures and plants."

"The staff at the Pet Stores were so helpful and friendly."

Good to know

1

The aquarium has a wide variety of unique and exotic fish.

2

All fish are well-maintained and arrive in perfect health.

3

Prices for fish and supplies are very competitive.

05
DFW Reptarium image 1
Reptile store

Wide variety of reptiles and exotic animals live in beautiful enclosures that inspire natural setups. Energetic and friendly atmosphere welcomes people to interact with animals and enjoy lively conversations. Unique offerings include exotic animal boarding and a gift shop featuring local products.

Wide variety of animals and enclosures creates a cool atmosphere. Creatures like the Axolotl stand out, and the animals appear very well cared for and chill.

Offers fair pricing without over-inflation common in larger stores. Focuses on reptiles and exotic pets, standing out in that specialty.

People are saying

"It's a cool place with a wide variety of animals and enclosures."

"This Local Spot has a great selection of happy, healthy reptiles."

"The staff at this pet store are so knowledgeable and helpful."

Good to know

1

DFW Reptarium offers birthday party packages with interactive animal experiences.

2

Reservations are recommended for birthday parties to ensure availability.

3

The store has a wide selection of reptiles, amphibians, and exotic pets.

06
The Reef Aquarium Shop image 1
Tropical fish store

Aquarium shop features well-organized saltwater and freshwater tanks with many planted and beautifully maintained aquariums. Atmosphere is peaceful and comfortable with great lighting and a clean environment. Unique offerings include an outdoor driftwood selection and presence of a macaw parrot adding to the experience.

Lots of cool tropical plants and unique items fill the shop. Friendly staff add to the cool atmosphere, making it a neat spot to explore even without buying anything.

Clean and well-kept, this pet store offers better quality fish food and water chemicals than big box stores. It stocks more exotic freshwater fish, including varieties like Pearl Goramies not found elsewhere.

People are saying

"They had a great selection of freshwater and saltwater fish."

"The Aquarium staff are so knowledgeable and helpful."

"I found exotic freshwater fish here, unlike other pet stores."

Good to know

1

The Reef Aquarium Shop has a great selection of both freshwater and saltwater fish.

2

Prices for fish and supplies are reasonable compared to big box stores.

3

The shop is known for its cleanliness and well-maintained habitats.

07
The Fish Hut of New Jersey image 1
Tropical fish store

Wall-to-wall tanks showcase vibrant tropical fish in a clean, well-organized space. The atmosphere feels friendly and welcoming, attracting both beginners and experienced hobbyists. Specialized selections include hard-to-find African cichlids and colorful species like Chili Rasboras.

Seeing them sex the cichlids for an all-male tank stands out. The store has a large selection of freshwater fish and equipment and stays very organized.

Tanks stay clean and bright, standing out from other pet stores. Employees at big box stores often refer people here for fish.

People are saying

"The staff's fish advice was so helpful and never pressured me."

"The staff at this pet store are so helpful and knowledgeable."

"Pete gave me a fantastic experience and knew his stuff."

Good to know

1

The store has a wide selection of both freshwater and saltwater fish.

2

They offer hard-to-find African cichlids that are popular among hobbyists.

3

The tanks are well-maintained and feature both community and specialty fish.

08
Discover Aquatics Shop image 1

Aquarium shop showcases immaculate tanks and an expansive coral selection with unique saltwater and freshwater fish. The space feels spotless and well-organized, creating a pleasant browsing experience. Shelves hold a wide range of equipment for both saltwater and freshwater setups.

Huge open coral reef tanks catch the eye right away. The shop features cool oddities and fish like dwarf rasboras that stand out for their unique look and health.

Specializes in fish and pets, offering a better selection than chain stores. Betta fish are available for purchase here.

People are saying

"The staff here are so knowledgeable about fish and always happy to help."

"I found unique fish at this pet store that I haven't seen elsewhere."

"The staff here is so cool, really kind and helpful."

Good to know

1

Discover Aquatics Shop offers a wide variety of both saltwater and freshwater fish.

2

The shop has a large selection of corals and live plants for aquariums.

3

Prices at Discover Aquatics Shop are competitive for the quality of livestock.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...