Outdoor seating dominates with a cute private garden and plenty of tables creating a calm, cozy atmosphere. Friendly service complements a rustic vibe where bakers work behind a wall of sourdoughs and bagels. Music ranges from Italian jazz to classic rock, enhancing a relaxed, hipster feel.
Everything bagels come with a seasoned crust and smoky seeds. The Everything Bagel with the Works pairs well with fresh, non-fishy lox. Both sourdough and everything bagels are available.
Pizzas have a strong aroma that stands out when passing by. Bagels and pizzas both show freshness and quality in their preparation.
"Their sourdough bread is consistently exceptional and tasty."
"The Everything Bagel has a perfect chew with a good crust."
"I found the pizzas here to be amazing."
Good to know
Finding parking can be a huge challenge, especially on weekends.
I suggest going early and on a weekday to avoid long lines.
The bakery offers vegan cream cheese, accommodating dietary restrictions.
Bagel shop offers fresh, chewy bagels with a wide variety of flavors and generous spreads. The atmosphere feels cozy and inviting with plenty of seating. It serves as a community hub with occasional special events and a lively, bustling environment.
Toasted everything bagels come with cream cheese options like plain or olive. The bacon, egg, and cheese on an everything bagel offers a hearty breakfast choice.
Great surprise comes from the wide variety of pizza options available alongside hot heroes. The menu also includes bagels and desserts, making it more than just a pizza spot.
Good to know
Goldberg's offers a wide variety of bagels, sandwiches, and healthy options.
Prices are reasonable for the Hamptons, with items around $17.50.
Expect long lines during peak hours, especially on weekends.
Industrial design with large tree-framing windows creates an airy, welcoming atmosphere filled with natural light. The space feels spacious and comfortable, suited for relaxing, working, or enjoying live music and poetry readings in the evening. Seating options include espresso bar and table seating, supporting both social and solo visits.
Everything bagels come loaded with lots of toppings and a super flavorful seasoning that highlights caraway seeds. Large schmears like scallion cream cheese and Calabrian chili spread complement the bagel well.
Ridiculously good crust stands out on their pizza, which pairs well with other menu items like the Chicago style Lox Bagel sandwich. Pizza slices come in various sizes and are served alongside excellent beers during jazz nights.
Good to know
Jazz nights are held every Friday from 4-6pm with no cover charge.
The bakery often sells out of bagels before lunchtime on weekends.
Parking is available on the street near the bakery.
Classic deli style with old world charm and Yankees baseball theme sets a nostalgic tone. Atmosphere feels homey and New Yorkish, offering both dine-in seating and to-go options. Bagels stand out as best in town, with hot, delicious varieties and authentic New York egg sandwiches.
Well-seasoned and addictive everything bagels come with options like scallion cream cheese or classic cream cheese. Sandwiches include turkey, bacon, egg, and cheese on everything bagels.
Crispy crust and perfectly cooked slices define the New York style pizza here. The menu includes a variety of options like Margherita and a special with sausage, mushrooms, and onions, all delivered hot and fresh.
Good to know
Breakfast costs $5 and includes coffee.
They added a full pizza menu with delivery and expanded late hours.
Day-old bagels are available by the half dozen.
Small space fills quickly with a comforting, peaceful vibe despite crowding. Bagels and pizza stand out for freshness and taste, with fresh bagels and delicious pizza as highlights. Pricing lacks transparency and seating is limited, reflecting a neighborhood with few food options.
Everything bagels come perfectly toasted with options like scallion cream cheese, avocado, and bacon. They pair well with sides such as home fries or can be served on a roll.
Freshness stands out with the chicken caesar salad pizza offering a tasty, crisp experience. Staff are consistently friendly and kind, enhancing the overall pizza experience.
Good to know
The restaurant has no menu available, making it hard to know prices.
Prices vary daily for the same items, so ask before ordering.
A slice of pizza costs $4.50, which is on the higher side.
Small shop with authentic New York style and a local vibe offers excellent bagels and a wide variety of options. Atmosphere feels fast and friendly despite limited seating and a packed, bustling environment. The space has a quaint, deli-like interior that feels genuine and unpretentious.
Everything bagels come soft but not too soft with a flavorful mix of toppings. Popular choices include spreads like jalapeño and chives cream cheese, and they work well with bacon, egg, and cheese.
Pizzas have a great crust and solid flavor. Pizza bagels stand out as amazing and get praise from kids.
Good to know
The shop opens early and has free parking available in front.
The business is cashless, so bring a card for payments.
The shop closes at 2 pm and sells out of popular items quickly.
Bagel shop offers freshly baked, large bagels with a variety of flavors in a warm, cozy atmosphere. Space inside feels cramped but inviting, with a friendly and casual vibe that becomes lively when busy.
Balanced flavor with poppy, sesame, and garlic defines the everything bagel. It pairs well with lox, tomatoes, onions, and capers for a classic combo.
Kosher pizza stands out with fresh, addictive flavors made all day by Danny. Options include classic New York style with a variety of toppings alongside other offerings like sushi.
Good to know
Bagels & Co. is Kosher and has reliable certification ensuring high standards.
They’re not open on Saturdays.
The place won't toast and dress the bagels for you.
Large space with a factory-like setup and a wall of freshly baked bagels creates a bustling atmosphere. Loud music and crowds contribute to a chaotic vibe, while outdoor seating offers a more relaxed option. Known for vast cream cheese spreads and gluten-free bagels, it combines quick service with a welcoming environment.
Everything bagels have a balanced seasoning that stands out. They pair well with scallion or jalapeno cream cheese and work great toasted with salmon or lox.
Pizza bagels come crispy and loaded with toppings, offering a unique twist on traditional bagels. The giant pizza bagel serves as a huge, delicious option that works well for sports events or sharing.
Good to know
On Wednesdays, buy three bagels and get one free.
Wednesdays are particularly busy, so expect long lines.
Order ahead through Uber Eats to skip the long wait.