Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Italian Grocery Stores in the US

You prefer to source your Italian ingredients from a market that understands the value of a well-stocked grocery store.

Based on 628 Opinions
+625
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
D. Coluccio & Sons image 1
D. Coluccio & Sons image 2
D. Coluccio & Sons image 3
View all
Italian grocery store

Warehouse-style layout hosts authentic Italian imports with unique regional products like Puglian wild onions. Atmosphere feels practical and unpretentious, focusing on quality goods at fair prices. Offers fresh pizza and specialty items like cannoli shells and unparalleled ricotta cheese.

Offers a wide range of specialty pasta and authentic Italian cheeses including large Parmesan blocks. Stocks unique Italian imports like wild onions from Puglia, aged balsamic vinegar, cannoli shells, and dried baccala.

Offers Italian specialty groceries with prices better than supermarkets. Provides a lovely shopping experience focused on quality and value.

People are saying

"I found unique pasta brands I'd never seen before."

"I found authentic Italian food and unique imported goods here."

"I found unique Italian imports and specialty pasta I couldn't find elsewhere."

Good to know

1

D. Coluccio & Sons specializes in Italian products.

2

The store is closed on Sundays in July and August.

3

Weekly specials are posted every Monday.

02
Hakata Japanese Market image 1
Japanese grocery store

Small Japanese market offers fresh sushi and authentic onigiri with unique packaging for convenience. Simple layout creates an inviting atmosphere reminiscent of Tokyo, attracting locals seeking reasonably priced Asian staples and prepared foods.

Small Japanese market offers a fantastic grocery selection with fresh sushi and authentic Japanese goods. Prices stay reasonable for Asian staples that are hard to find elsewhere.

People are saying

"The onigiri here is so delicious and fresh."

"The sushi here is always incredibly fresh."

"The onigiri at this grocery store are so flavorful and fresh."

Good to know

1

The market offers a 50% discount on onigiri after 7 PM.

2

Prepared foods are 50% off in the evening.

3

You can order freshly made hand rolls in the center of the store.

03
La Bella Marketplace image 1

Supermarket offers an extensive Italian specialty selection with freshly made products like cheeses and baked goods. Atmosphere feels like shopping in Italy, with well-organized aisles and a varied food assortment. Staff often speak languages other than English, adding to the authentic vibe.

Offers an authentic Italian-market vibe with a large variety of pastas, olive oil, and canned goods. Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, and prepared foods like stuffed artichokes and focaccia highlight the selection.

Offers a mix of small supermarket essentials and Italian specialties. Stocks fresh vegetables alongside a variety of products.

People are saying

"The pasta selection here is incredible and so flavorful."

"This Italian grocery store has an authentic selection of imported products."

"I found authentic Italian food and imported goods I couldn't find elsewhere."

Good to know

1

The store sells expired products, some past their expiration dates.

2

The store can sell expired goods up to 6 months after the expiration date.

3

The aisles are well organized and easy to navigate.

04
Beyar's Market image 1
Supermarket

Supermarket offers a large selection of premium cold cuts and freshly stocked deli items with authentic Italian fare like homemade mozzarella. Atmosphere feels clean and polite, nestled in a residential neighborhood with accessible parking. Prices tend to be higher than average, but quality and freshness remain consistent.

Mozzarella slices come fresh and plain, echoing traditional Italian American style. Trays of lasagna, chicken cutlets, and chicken francese arrive freshly made and on time, with the chicken cutlet wrap featuring roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella standing out.

Offers a great little supermarket feel with a wide selection that covers almost everything needed. Stands out as a hidden gem compared to larger supermarkets and online options.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are ridiculously huge and delicious."

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the homemade mozzarella."

"I loved the deli's prepared meals and salads for a quick grocery run."

Good to know

1

Beyar's Market has accessible private parking available for customers.

2

The deli counter offers a large selection of freshly stocked items.

3

Prices at Beyar's Market are generally higher than average.

05
Claro's Italian Markets image 1

Small Italian market with nostalgic atmosphere and authentic old-school vibe. Crowded and lively, especially on weekends, with classic deli setup and Italian aromas filling the air. Offers a wide variety of imported Italian specialties and fresh baked goods.

Dishes like lasagna, Italian sausage, and meatballs come with rich, authentic flavors. The market offers a wide selection of homemade sauces, fresh pastas, deli meats, and cheeses that taste genuine and fresh.

Busy supermarket area offers a wide selection of Italian groceries. Deli meats get proper cuts and are well packed, unlike typical grocery stores. Employees are friendly and open to socializing during slow browsing.

People are saying

"Their sandwiches are authentic, made with lots of fresh, high-quality meats."

"This Italian grocery store has authentic, flavorful items you can't find elsewhere."

"I found so many authentic Italian specialty pastas and sauces here."

Good to know

1

Ample parking is available behind the center for easy access.

2

Expect longer wait times during lunch hours; plan accordingly.

3

The market offers a wide selection of authentic Italian products.

06
Bay Cities Italian Deli & Bakery image 1

Traditional Italian deli combines market, cafรฉ, and quick-stop in a bustling, cozy atmosphere with authentic Italian grocery offerings. Outdoor seating includes stone picnic tables for enjoying sandwiches. The vibe recalls Little Italy in Manhattan with a quaint, small-town charm.

Meatball Subs come with meatballs, spaghetti sauce, and parmesan cheese. The hot bar offers meat-filled lasagna priced at $8. Sandwiches like the Godmother and Don Lorenzo feature Italian cured meats and fresh bread with rich toppings.

Italian grocer with a cute deli counter stands out here. The grocery store offers a solid selection of Italian goods.

People are saying

"The Godmother sandwich with the works is the best choice."

"You have to try their signature sub, the Godmother."

"You have to try the Godmother sandwich; it's amazing Italian food."

Good to know

1

They accept only cash and debit card.

2

You need to grab a ticket with a number and wait until they call out the numbers.

3

Expect long wait times, especially during peak hours.

07
Tin Building by Jean-Georges image 1

Market space blends elegant, tidy decor with a peaceful atmosphere reminiscent of a 1920s-1930s fish market. Variety includes fine dining restaurants, cozy bars, and specialty shops like a florist and cheese shop. Quiet energy suits those seeking a refined, calm food hall experience.

Pasta comes with a kick of spice and a chewy, sophisticated texture. Bread options include delicious focaccia and outstanding ciabatta.

Fresh food markets offer produce from local farms often better than organic options. Specialized ingredients appear regularly, and the prepared foods and bakery items avoid common additives like Crisco.

People are saying

"This market has an excellent selection of high-quality food products."

"I found this grocery store to be a stylish food market with an excellent selection."

"The Italian food here, especially the focaccia and ciabatta, is out of this world."

Good to know

1

The Tin Building is currently only open Thursday - Sunday from 12 PM to 5 PM.

2

Make sure you make reservations online to avoid long wait times.

3

Plan ahead and arrive early as it gets crowded around noon on weekends.

08
Eataly - Flatiron image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Italian market and dining space combines multiple restaurants, specialty counters, and rooftop seating under one roof. Atmosphere ranges from warm and inviting to loud and bustling, with a mix of casual shoppers and diners. Frequent demonstrations and sample bars add an interactive element to the experience.

Good pasta to go stands out here. The Tiramisu arrives unwrapped at the table creating a lava effect.

Offers a comprehensive supermarket with a wide variety of quality ingredients and fresh products. Includes items not typically found in Italian supermarkets and features clean, friendly staff.

People are saying

"It's an amazing Italian grocery store with high-quality, hard-to-find products."

"The Italian food here is so fresh, especially the pasta."

"I found the pistachio and hazelnut gelato to be the best."

Good to know

1

Pizza by the slice costs between $7-12.

2

You walk along to pick what you want to eat and drink.

3

The location is tucked away in the back left corner by La Pizza.

09
Whole Foods Market image 1
Grocery store

Grocery store combines stunning design with a bar overlooking Bryant Park and a hot bar with seating upstairs. Space feels cramped and confusing, but offers amenities like a microwave and fresh organic produce. Seating areas provide great park views, though some spots appear neglected.

Wide choice of fresh vegetables, meats, and pasta lets you compose your own dish in a cardboard box. Buffet includes Italian food, pasta, meat, chicken, salads, and vegetables at competitive prices.

Large and beautiful layout offers a wide range of products from daily necessities to deli items. High-end selection and everything needed for grocery shopping exists here.

People are saying

"I found a good variety of healthy and tasty food options here."

"This grocery store is so well-stocked with fresh produce and delicacies."

"I loved the wide variety of Italian food, especially the pasta and meats."

Good to know

1

The self-service buffet tray is billed by weight, not by unit.

2

Lunch options are available for around 15 USD.

3

Restroom entry requires a code from your receipt.

10
Agata & Valentina image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Gourmet grocery store offers narrow, maze-like aisles filled with top-of-the-line products and fresh prepared foods. Atmosphere feels sophisticated and crowded, attracting shoppers seeking rare and luxury items. Prices run high, reflecting the upscale selection and specialty focus.

Fresh pasta stands out with homemade quality and a preference over regular pasta. Vegetable lasagna and gelato also feature as notable dishes. Some fresh ravioli come with a cornstarch coating to prevent sticking, and cooking instructions on pasta labels use a small 6-point font.

Selection includes fresh produce, meats, and fish with very good quality. The store offers a high-end supermarket experience with a great variety of products.

People are saying

"The food here is so fresh and delicious."

"I found it to be a great gourmet grocery store."

"The fresh pasta here is amazing, better than regular pasta!"

Good to know

1

Prices at the deli are very high.

2

Buying produce late Sunday or early Monday means you might get low grade items.

3

The supermarket does not offer restrooms for customers.

11
Zabar's image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Gourmet grocery store with old-world charm and an edgy omni-deli ambiance filled with the aroma of specialty cheeses and coffee. Crowded with serious shoppers, the atmosphere can feel tense but remains a local institution known for its unique bakery and extensive gourmet cookwear upstairs.

Fresh bread and melty cheese come together in a tasty prosciutto sandwich. The selection includes pasta, cured meats, and focaccia bread directly from Italy, plus marinara sauce and spicy salami available for order.

Supermarket feels like a deli on steroids with an authentic atmosphere. Cheese and side dish variety stands out in this beautiful grocery store.

People are saying

"I thought the bagels here were the greatest ever."

"The grocery store has a huge variety of specialty items and fresh food."

"I loved the Italian food, especially the pasta and cured meats."

Good to know

1

Parking is abysmal, so plan accordingly.

2

There is no restroom available for customers.

3

The #1 subway stop is right next to Zabar's for easy access.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...