Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks in New York

Italian grocery stores

You need a place that stocks authentic Italian ingredients while serving as a reliable grocery store.

Based on 788 Opinions
+785
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Frank & Maria's Italian Market image 1
Frank & Maria's Italian Market image 2
Frank & Maria's Italian Market image 3
View all
Gourmet grocery store

Vintage-style market offers fresh Italian staples with butcher and pasta stations. Atmosphere feels family-run and welcoming, serving a diverse local crowd. Known for high-quality meats and fresh mozzarella, it supports quick, authentic meals.

Fresh mozzarella stands out with its creamy texture and rich flavor. The homemade sausage pairs well with the mouth-watering lasagna, offering classic Italian tastes.

Fresh groceries come with carefully curated beef aged under close watch. The store offers specialty items like Guancale and affordable bacon, serving a diverse local crowd year-round.

People are saying

"The food here is so fresh and delicious."

"You have to try the homemade mozzarella; it's delicious."

"The beef and bacon at this grocery store are amazing."

Good to know

1

Frank & Maria's Italian Market offers a wide selection of meats, cheeses, and Italian products.

2

The market is well-kept and extremely clean, providing a pleasant shopping experience.

3

They have fresh groceries available, ideal for quick, one-pan meals.

02
Sapori Del Vallo image 1
Grocery store

Small space with wood-fired pizza and fresh baked bread creates a welcoming ambiance filled with authentic Italian atmosphere. Live Italian music and bilingual conversations add lively cultural energy. Offers genuine Italian groceries and simple, unpretentious dining.

Fresh pasta dishes and wood-fired pizzas come made to order with quality ingredients. The selection includes authentic imported meats, cheese, and olive oil, plus breads and sweets made on site like tiramisu.

An authentic Italian market offers cold pressed olive oil and a variety of Italian groceries. Prosciutto bread stands out as a market favorite.

People are saying

"The pasta here is made fresh to order by Italians using family recipes."

"The pizza here is made in a wood fire oven, just like in Naples."

"This Italian grocery store has amazing pizza and pasta."

Good to know

1

The store closes at 5:00 PM.

2

All products are from Italy or made on premises.

3

The pizza is offered at a great price.

03
Italian Street Market image 1

Small Italian grocery store with fresh mozzarella, imported Italian products, and daily sandwiches ready at the register. Atmosphere feels homey and welcoming with shelves stocked with unique items like Calabrian specialties. Only cash is accepted, and the place stays quiet without crowds.

Prosciutto and mortadella stand out with dynamite flavor. Fresh-made mozzarella and Parmesan cheese add rich, authentic taste. Sandwiches often feature sweet spicy peppers and extra virgin olive oil.

Fresh pastries, homemade sauces, and authentic deli items create a genuine Italian food experience. The tiny market offers delicious premade sandwiches and specialty Italian products not found in regular stores, accepting only cash.

People are saying

"I thought the bread here was amazing."

"The Italian food here has amazing bread and dynamite prosciutto."

"I found this little Italian market to be an absolute gem."

Good to know

1

The market only accepts cash; bring your own for purchases.

2

Daily sandwiches are available at the register for quick bites.

3

Expect a great selection of fresh meats, cheeses, and breads.

04
Di Palo's Fine Foods image 1
Italian grocery store

Small Italian grocery store with an old-worldly feel and clean, well-organized interior. Atmosphere is warm and inviting, bustling yet intimate, filled with the aroma of hams and cheese. Offers a finest selection of authentic Italian specialty products, including rare cheeses and cured meats.

Fresh mozzarella stands out with its delicate, milky texture made in-house. Prosciutto di Parma, burrata, ricotta, and handmade pasta like bucatini complement the selection of cheese and cold cuts.

Offers a clean environment and a heartwarming atmosphere with a focus on Italian specialty foods.

People are saying

"This family-run deli is a generational experience with stories and rare meats."

"I tried the best prosciutto Iโ€™ve ever had here."

"Their fresh Italian food, especially the mozzarella and prosciutto, is the best."

Good to know

1

Plan for 20-30 minutes for service in best case scenarios.

2

Customers need to put up with the lines of tourists at DiPalo's.

3

You can place an order on the phone and pick it up once itโ€™s ready.

05
Serra Provisions image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store combines authentic charm with a covered outdoor patio featuring picnic tables. Atmosphere feels welcoming and inviting without background music, creating a relaxed vibe. Known for artisan pizza and sandwiches baked in a stone oven, it draws those seeking genuine Italian flavors.

Homemade pasta stands out with its fresh, organic quality that changes the pasta game. The Rossa and Amatriciana dishes deliver strong, authentic flavors. The Caprese with Prosciutto and hot peppers offers a unique, bold twist on a classic.

Offers a gourmet Italian market with unique specialty foods and high-quality ingredients like homemade pasta.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here were the best I've ever had."

"The Italian food here, especially the pizza, is outstanding."

"The pizza at this grocery store is authentic and reminds me of Italy."

Good to know

1

There is no parking lot, so street parking is necessary.

2

Credit cards and mobile payments are accepted.

3

The shop features a cheese-free pizza option called Rossa.

06
Pasta Fresca Ravioli image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store offers homemade fresh pasta and fresh mozzarella with a classic Brooklyn charm. The atmosphere feels friendly and welcoming, with a clean and well-organized layout. Early visits are common due to high demand for fresh baked bread and specialty items.

Fresh homemade pasta stands out, especially the ravioli and penne. The store also offers fresh mozzarella, Italian bread, and cookies that are highly praised.

Offers a typical Italian grocery store layout and atmosphere with a focus on authentic products. Known for its Pasta Fresca Ravioli selection.

People are saying

"Their cookies, especially the lemon drop ones, are out of this world."

"I thought the Italian food sandwiches were excellent and customizable."

"This grocery store is a staple, with everything tasting wonderful."

Good to know

1

You must arrive early or the bread sells out.

2

Everything is made fresh on site in their kitchen.

3

The place is impeccably clean.

07
Savino's Quality Pasta image 1

Fresh handmade pasta and mozzarella define the space, creating an authentic Italian market vibe. The atmosphere feels like a neighborhood staple with homemade sauces, affordable prices, and top-quality ravioli. Regulars come for authentic Italian groceries and fresh pasta that rivals Italy itself.

Fresh, house made pasta stands out with options like Gorgonzola ravioli that are flavorful enough to skip sauce. Classes teach pasta making alongside serving homemade sauces like pesto, vodka, and arrabbiata, all at reasonable prices.

Offers a high-end Italian market vibe with a great selection of fresh pasta, sauces, and imported pantry staples. Fresh mozzarella comes at fair prices for the city.

People are saying

"I found the fresh pasta here to be delicious and authentic."

"I loved the Gorgonzola ravioli; it was super flavorful."

"I found the fresh pasta and homemade sauces to be the best Italian food in town."

Good to know

1

Customers should order what is being made fresh on the counter.

2

Savino's Quality Pasta offers frozen pasta for take-home meals.

3

Catering services are available for events and gatherings.

08
Uncle Giuseppe's Marketplace image 1
Gourmet grocery store

Huge gourmet grocery store offers fresh pizza, full bakery, and sushi bar with on-site chefs. Welcoming atmosphere features live music and delightful smells, creating a pleasant place to browse. Shuttle and golf cart services assist shoppers, adding convenience to the experience.

Sunday Sauce Starter features hot and sweet Italian sausage, beef and pork braciole, loin of pork, and beef chuck. Fresh pasta and fresh mozzarella stand out for quality and flavor.

A well staffed and clean grocery store with a wide variety of products and a very organized layout. Staff greet customers warmly and assist with carrying groceries to cars.

People are saying

"The grocery store's stuffed shells are honestly the best I've ever had."

"The staff here is so kind and helpful with my sandwich orders my sandwich."

"The fresh stuffed shells with their blend of cheeses are the best I've ever had."

Good to know

1

The store offers a 2 for $22 deal on Wednesdays and Fridays.

2

Seniors can get discounts on Wednesdays if they sign up for mail ads.

3

Cleanliness is a priority, with the store being well-organized and odor-free.

09
Emiliano's Market image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian grocery store offers an intimate, warm atmosphere with vibrant decor and friendly energy. Indoor and outdoor seating create a relaxed vibe where fresh, authentic products and handmade mozzarella stand out. The space feels like a neighborhood hub with a welcoming, family-like environment.

Fresh mozzarella is handmade daily, showcasing authentic craftsmanship. Pastas like ravioli with pumpkin sauce and linguine with clams balance flavors well, avoiding overpowering garlic. Ciabatta bread and soups complement the Italian food offerings effectively.

Offers a solid selection of imported Italian goods and groceries. Sandwiches and paninis stand out, alongside freshly squeezed orange juice made to order.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are delicious, made with fresh, high-quality ingredients."

"The sandwiches at this grocery store are piled high with fresh, premium ingredients."

"I'll come back for the Rosa sandwich's prosciutto."

Good to know

1

You might stumble on a Panettone sale at Emilianoโ€™s.

2

Customers should order ahead to grab sandwiches to go.

3

There is limited seating available indoors and outdoors.

10
Frank & Sal Italian Market Brooklyn image 1

Italian grocery store with a small layout and a meat counter offers a friendly atmosphere and cozy, inviting vibe. It features fresh mozzarella, authentic Italian foods, and a butcher counter with pristine meats. The market stands out for imported pasta and next day cheese delivery.

Fresh mozzarella and parmigiano reggiano stand out for their quality. The garlic focaccia is fragrant and rich, while the Italian imported pasta, including whole wheat options, offers more flavor than typical American pasta.

Offers authentic Italian goods with fresh meats and vegetables that last longer than typical markets. Staff provide pristine cuts and maintain high-quality Italian standards throughout.

People are saying

"This Italian food is the real deal, especially the fresh mozzarella."

"The deli's fresh mozzarella is creamy, soft, and reminds me of Italy."

"I found this Italian grocery store to be the best for quality ingredients."

Good to know

1

The store offers next day delivery for cheese orders.

2

They accept SNAP payments, making it accessible for more customers.

3

The butcher counter provides fresh meats, including high-quality steaks and sausages.

11
Tavola Italian Market image 1

Backyard patio offers a quiet, leafy garden setting with outdoor seating surrounded by greenery. Indoor space feels cozy and fresh, creating a relaxed atmosphere. Italian products and made-to-order paninis attract those seeking authentic flavors and a calm place to enjoy food or work.

A large tiramisu stands out as a highlight at the end of the meal. The menu offers a wide selection of pasta and a Caprese salad that surpasses most local versions.

Italian pantry products stand out with a wide selection. Frozen meals and fresh sandwiches add convenience and variety. The Italian food market greets shoppers right at the entrance.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches were delicious and tasty."

"I loved this grocery store for its fresh sandwiches with imported meats."

"The Italian Food sandwiches here are simply delectable."

Good to know

1

Customers are charged a 20% tip for items they picked up themselves.

2

Tavola offers an extensive list of sandwich options.

3

The cost of the panini was $17.50.

12
Frank and Sal Italian Market Staten Island image 1

Italian grocery store offers an authentic Italian atmosphere with a top-notch deli and excellent selection of condiments. The place maintains a clean and well-run environment with friendly staff and smooth service. It stands out for high-quality products and careful packaging for shipping.

Lasagna stands out with its rich layers and fresh ingredients. Breadsticks and Italian sausage offer amazing flavor and perfect moisture. Cheese selections include Parmigiano Reggiano and Pecorino Romano, delivered fresh. Eggplant parmesan satisfies with authentic taste. Prepared foods like prosciutto bread and Sicilian peppers add variety.

Offers a wide selection of Italian cheeses including Locatelli and parmesan, all delivered fresh and cold. Provides authentic Italian products like taralli with consistent excellent customer service.

People are saying

"The Market's cheese is perfectly packaged, cold, and delivered on time."

"This grocery store's cheese is the best I could imagine."

"The Italian food here has amazing gluten-free cannoli."

Good to know

1

The business offers free shipping without a minimum purchase amount.

2

The products from Frank and Sal Italian Market were still cold upon arrival.

3

They ship quickly, usually in 1-2 days.

13
Rosario's image 1

Italian deli and pizzeria with old-school charm and a homey, neighborhood vibe. Offers fresh mozzarella and authentic Italian groceries alongside bar-style seating mostly for takeout. Atmosphere feels authentic and welcoming, reminiscent of classic New York spots.

Fresh mozzarella and ricotta get made on-site daily, offering a super fresh taste without extra salt. The Italian market stocks authentic pastas, canned tomatoes, and olive oil alongside these homemade cheeses.

Offers affordable cheese priced lower than supermarkets and a selection of Italian imports like pasta and canned goods. The grocery area includes fresh mozzarella and quality chicken cutlets alongside sandwiches.

People are saying

"I thought this pizza was among the best in the city."

"I tried the pizza and it was phenomenal."

"I found the pizza here to be the best."

Good to know

1

A cheese slice costs $3.50, and an 18-inch cheese pie is around $20.

2

The deli section has a variety of meats and homemade mozzarella.

3

Prices on sandwiches and pizza are very fair.

14
Pastosa Ravioli Company image 1
Italian grocery store

Small Italian grocery store offers an astounding variety of fresh pastas, ravioli, and Mediterranean foods. Delicious aromas fill the space, creating an inviting atmosphere. The shop maintains an old school charm with a meticulously clean environment and a wide selection of high-quality deli items.

Fresh pastas come in a wide variety with a large selection of house brand ravioli, including regular and butternut squash. The store offers fresh mozzarella, prosciutto bread, and quality meats alongside many Italian specialties and sauces.

Offers premium Italian products with prices slightly above typical supermarkets. Functions as a local grocery market focused on quality items.

People are saying

"I found the food to be delicious and always fresh."

"This grocery store has amazing homemade specialties and fresh pastas."

"You have to try the fresh ravioli; they have so many varieties."

Good to know

1

The store offers a large selection of cooked items.

2

They have a wide variety of items including ravioli and Italian specialties.

3

Prices are slightly higher than a supermarket but reflect premium quality.

15
Beyar's Market image 1
Supermarket

Supermarket offers a large selection of premium cold cuts and freshly stocked deli items with authentic Italian fare like homemade mozzarella. Atmosphere feels clean and polite, nestled in a residential neighborhood with accessible parking. Prices tend to be higher than average, but quality and freshness remain consistent.

Mozzarella slices come fresh and plain, echoing traditional Italian American style. Trays of lasagna, chicken cutlets, and chicken francese arrive freshly made and on time, with the chicken cutlet wrap featuring roasted peppers and fresh mozzarella standing out.

Offers a great little supermarket feel with a wide selection that covers almost everything needed. Stands out as a hidden gem compared to larger supermarkets and online options.

People are saying

"The sandwiches here are ridiculously huge and delicious."

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the homemade mozzarella."

"I loved the deli's prepared meals and salads for a quick grocery run."

Good to know

1

Beyar's Market has accessible private parking available for customers.

2

The deli counter offers a large selection of freshly stocked items.

3

Prices at Beyar's Market are generally higher than average.

16
Martoni Gourmet image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian restaurant offers a cozy and lively atmosphere with a wine bar and authentic imported ingredients. Large, flavorful panini and rich gelato create a true taste of Italy. Family-friendly vibe complements the warm, inviting setting.

Tender meatballs come with a tangy marinara sauce that doubles as a dip for sandwiches. Paninis like the panini con prosciutto and specialty sandwiches pair well with espresso. Imported goods include pasta, tapenade, cookies, and olive oil.

Small size and cute layout define the grocery store. It offers a great market experience with a focused selection.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be authentic and made with care."

"This Italian food brought me back to Rome with its memorable paninis and burrata."

"The Grocery Store's food is incredible, fresh, and authentic."

Good to know

1

Martoni Gourmet offers a variety of imported Italian goods including pasta and olive oil.

2

Reservations are recommended for larger groups to ensure seating availability.

3

Credit cards are accepted, but cash is preferred for smaller purchases.

17
Travelers Poets & Friends image 1
Italian restaurant

Warm, inviting space blends upscale Italian decor with a cozy, intimate vibe. Offers outdoor seating and an attached Italian market with fresh pasta and sauces. Atmosphere feels like sharing drinks and meals in a friend's home.

Freshly baked focaccia bread and handmade pasta stand out here. The bolognese and pistachio rigatoni offer authentic Italian flavors, while the tiramisu features rich mascarpone.

Fresh pasta sold by the pound stands out in the small upscale Italian market. The grocery section features local produce and secret staff ingredients, blending everyday items with unique finds.

People are saying

"I devoured the pasta; it was the best I'd had this side of Italy."

"This lunch spot has amazing fresh pasta and authentic Italian pizzas."

"The food at this grocery store is great and tasty."

Good to know

1

Happy hour drinks are $10 aperols from 4-7pm on weekdays.

2

A 4 piece band plays live music on Sundays.

3

The establishment is closed on Sundays and Mondays.

18
La Bella Marketplace image 1

Supermarket offers an extensive Italian specialty selection with freshly made products like cheeses and baked goods. Atmosphere feels like shopping in Italy, with well-organized aisles and a varied food assortment. Staff often speak languages other than English, adding to the authentic vibe.

Offers an authentic Italian-market vibe with a large variety of pastas, olive oil, and canned goods. Fresh mozzarella, ricotta, and prepared foods like stuffed artichokes and focaccia highlight the selection.

Offers a mix of small supermarket essentials and Italian specialties. Stocks fresh vegetables alongside a variety of products.

People are saying

"The pasta selection here is incredible and so flavorful."

"This Italian grocery store has an authentic selection of imported products."

"I found authentic Italian food and imported goods I couldn't find elsewhere."

Good to know

1

The store sells expired products, some past their expiration dates.

2

The store can sell expired goods up to 6 months after the expiration date.

3

The aisles are well organized and easy to navigate.

19
Durso's Pasta & Ravioli Company image 1
Italian grocery store

Italian deli and grocery offers handmade pasta and freshly prepared dishes with a warm, family feel and inviting aromas. The space features hanging prosciutto and a great cheese counter, creating a classic, old-school vibe. It attracts those seeking quality Italian specialties and catering options.

Fresh pasta and ravioli come handmade and crafted in-house with skill. The menu features homemade sauces like marinara and bolognese, plus Italian specialties such as lobster ravioli and chicken parmesan.

Small size fits a local Italian grocery and deli. Layout and atmosphere match a classic Italian deli and grocery feel.

People are saying

"The fresh pasta here is delicious and handmade."

"I love their fresh, handmade Italian pasta and sauces."

"The fresh pasta at this grocery store is high quality and affordable."

Good to know

1

There is parking available right outside the store.

2

The deli offers top of the line meats and sandwiches.

3

The ordering process at Durso's is very simple and quick.

20
Faiccoโ€™s Italian Specialties image 1

Deli-style shop with no indoor seating and a mean looking butchery at the front creates a chaotic yet authentic Italian American atmosphere. The vibe is warm and welcoming, evoking an old-school neighborhood feel with laid-back energy. Outdoor tables offer limited seating, while the space feels full of character and history.

Italian dishes feature fresh prosciutto, veal parmesan, and sandwiches with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers. Chicken cutlet sandwiches come with pesto and homemade sun-dried tomatoes. Prosciutto balls stand out as a notable appetizer.

A true Italian grocer with a timeless feel, serving the local community as a major Italian supermarket.

People are saying

"This Italian Sandwich is the best I ever had."

"The Italian cold cuts sandwiches here are amazing and so fresh."

"I thought the Italian subs here were large and yummy."

Good to know

1

Using cards incurs a 3% fee; cash is preferred.

2

One sandwich can feed 2-3 people, making it a good value.

3

You need to grab a ticket to order.

21
Cipollina Gourmet Italian Market image 1

Store resembles an old Italian market with authentic imported goods and a cozy, welcoming atmosphere. It draws people seeking high-quality Italian specialty foods and fresh-made sandwiches with imported meats. The vibe is calm and charming, offering a genuine taste of Italy without high prices.

Fresh cheese and good pesto stand out alongside a nice sun-dried tomato spread. Lobster ravioli and various panini with mortadella, prosciutto, and salame offer solid Italian options, plus cannoli and other desserts add variety.

Offers a wide Italian grocery inventory with authentic products like real Italian cookies and biscuits. Prices vary, with some items like biscuits being overpriced. Service is great and the grocery section is delightful.

People are saying

"I thought the sandwiches here might be the best in the world."

"It felt like a mom and pop Eataly with authentic Italian food."

"I found the Italian grocery inventory to be great."

Good to know

1

Cipollina Gourmet offers top-tier Italian products that are hard to find elsewhere.

2

Expect a $8.00 credit limit for purchases.

3

There is a significant fee for credit card transactions not indicated on signs.

22
Sergimmo Salumeria Whitestone image 1
Italian grocery store

Small Italian grocery store with a classic salumeria style and authentic imports creates a cozy, home-like atmosphere. Friendly, family vibe fills the spotless space with welcoming aromas. Known for fresh mozzarella made on location and flavorful hot sandwiches that avoid heaviness.

Fresh mozzarella stands out with its soft texture and perfect saltiness. The Mortadella hero features a generous amount of mortadella and mozzarella. Sauces like marinara and bolognese pair well with chicken parmesan, and trays loaded with cheese blends like mozzarella, fontina, and asiago support hearty Italian dishes.

Old-school Italian vibe shines through with great deli sandwiches and a variety of Italian groceries. Fresh pasta sits in a fridge, and deli orders come thinly sliced and separated with paper.

People are saying

"This Italian deli has amazing meats, cheese, and bread."

"This old-school Italian grocery store has amazing deli sandwiches."

"The Mortadella hero had a generous amount of mortadella."

Good to know

1

The Mortadella hero costs $20.

2

There is plenty of on-street parking available for 75 cents.

3

Sergimmo offers hot lunches every day.

Discover more

New York

Area guide
Loading Map...