Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Local picks

Italian food in Great Kills

Authentic Italian food that feels like a neighborhood staple instead of a tourist trap.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated April 2026
01
Da Damaso image 1
Da Damaso image 2
Da Damaso image 3
View all
Italian restaurant

Old school small Italian family restaurant offers southern style lasagna and creamy authentic carbonara. Rustic decor and genuine hospitality create a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Espresso and cannoli provide a classic Italian flair to finish the meal.

Lasagna stands out with its southern style, featuring bรฉchamel and hard-boiled eggs for rich flavor. Carbonara comes creamy and authentic, made the true Italian way. Espresso and cannoli finish the meal with classic Italian flair.

People are saying

"I found the food to be really good and authentic."

"It's so cozy here, like a family gathering, not a restaurant."

"I found the Italian food here to be really good and authentic."

Good to know

1

The restaurant is conveniently located only a short walk from the SIR Great Kills train station.

2

Parking is easy after 5pm.

3

The restaurant is BYOB (Bring Your Own Bottle).

02
Mimmo's Brick Oven Pizza & Trattoria image 1

Brick oven pizza shines with homemade mozzarella and a Sicilian pie. Cozy, elegant dining room suits both casual meals and intimate celebrations. Soft music and large windows create a warm, inviting atmosphere.

Pizza features homemade mozzarella and a Sicilian pie option. Pasta dishes come in huge portions with al dente spaghetti and thick sauces. Eggplant parm and chicken franchise heroes offer fresh ingredients and bold flavors.

People are saying

"I loved the brick oven pizza's amazing crust and flavor."

"The pizza here is delicious and consistently good."

"The Italian food here is mouthwatering and the staff is incredibly attentive."

Good to know

1

The venue accommodates up to 40 people for private events.

2

Credit card payments incur an additional fee at checkout.

3

Parking is limited and can be challenging during peak hours.

03
Anthony's Paninoteca image 1

Small sandwich shop offers Golfetta salami with rich flavor and fresh mozzarella. Monochrome decor and marble floors create a crisp atmosphere. Warm, friendly vibe fills the air with aromas of roasted meats and fresh bread, making it perfect for takeout.

Golfetta salami stands out for its perfect simplicity and rich flavor. Sandwiches layer mortadella, salami, ham, and provolone with precision, often complemented by fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers on crusty hero loaves.

People are saying

"I thought their sandwiches were amazing and really well done."

"The bread here is amazing, with great ingredients and super fresh."

"This Italian food is the best sandwich I've ever eaten."

Good to know

1

Sandwiches cost around $20, reflecting the quality of ingredients used.

2

Daily specials are available, with a different one each day.

3

Wednesday is pastrami day, featuring a special pastrami sandwich.

04
Frank and Sal Italian Market Staten Island image 1

Italian grocery store shines with authentic atmosphere and top-notch deli. Lasagna and eggplant parmesan deliver rich flavors while Parmigiano Reggiano cheese stays fresh. Friendly staff ensure smooth service in a clean, well-run space.

Lasagna stands out with its rich layers and fresh ingredients. Breadsticks and Italian sausage offer amazing flavor and perfect moisture. Cheese selections include Parmigiano Reggiano and Pecorino Romano, delivered fresh. Eggplant parmesan satisfies with authentic taste. Prepared foods like prosciutto bread and Sicilian peppers add variety.

People are saying

"The Market's cheese is perfectly packaged, cold, and delivered on time."

"You can taste the authentic Italian ingredients, especially the olive oil."

"The Italian food here has amazing gluten-free cannoli."

Good to know

1

The business offers free shipping without a minimum purchase amount.

2

The products from Frank and Sal Italian Market were still cold upon arrival.

3

They ship quickly, usually in 1-2 days.

05
Piccolino Ristorante NY image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy Italian spot shines with live crooner entertainment and a warm vibe. Classic dishes like shrimp scampi and veal parm impress, with gluten-free pasta cooked just right. Guests leave with a red rose, adding charm to the lively atmosphere.

Shrimp scampi, penne vodka, and veal parm with angel hair pasta stand out as classic Italian dishes here. Gluten-free pasta options come cooked to perfection and the portions, including added linguine, are generous.

People are saying

"The dinner here was perfect, from start to finish."

"It's so Kid Friendly; they let me decorate and bring entertainers."

"The Italian food here is delicious and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Valet parking is only available after 6 p.m.

2

Municipal parking across the street is very convenient.

3

The outdoor room for events is perfect for hosting occasions.

06
Goodfella's image 1
Pizza restaurant

Brick oven pizza shines with fresh mozzarella and a crisp crust. Fresh made pasta, especially ravioli, impresses alongside tender appetizers like Grilled Octopus Long Hots. A killer bar with big screens and local music creates a lively, inviting vibe.

Fresh made pasta stands out as a highlight, especially the ravioli. The Margherita and Puttanesca pizzas feature fresh mozzarella and a crisp, perfect crust. Appetizers like Grilled Octopus Long Hots and Smoked Burrata are tender and well seasoned.

People are saying

"I thought the pizza here was the best I ever had."

"The strip steak here is delicious and melts in your mouth."

"I loved their grandma square pies with shredded cheese."

Good to know

1

Happy hour runs Monday to Friday with half-priced bar pies.

2

The meatball Parm sub costs $18.

3

A $5 extra charge applies for debit or credit card payments.

07
Giulianaโ€™s Ristorante image 1
Italian restaurant

Old school Italian spot offers authentic flavors with fresh clams and creamy rigatoni. Cozy vibe shines with live Italian music and walls full of photos. Back rooms provide intimate space for small groups, making it perfect for classic, elegant dining.

Dishes feature authentic flavors with fresh ingredients like clams in the linguine and a creamy stuffed rigatoni. Desserts include cannoli with a homemade-style filling that stands out.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, full of authentic flavors."

"You have to try the cannoli; the filling is homemade and the best I've ever had."

"The Italian food here is delicious, especially the tender, flavorful pork chops."

Good to know

1

The pre-fix dinner is around $25 per person, including an appetizer and dessert.

2

Tips must be paid in cash; it's best to bring cash.

3

There is no parking on-site, so find local parking before arriving.

08
Patrizia's of Brooklyn image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian dishes shine with rich pasta flavors and crispy chewy pizza. Loud music fuels a lively atmosphere where guests often dance. Outdoor seating offers a casual vibe next to a parking lot.

Pasta dishes stand out with options like black ink pasta, short rib pappardella, and pasta fagioli, all cooked with rich flavors. The pizza offers a crisp and chewy texture, and starters include cheese croquette balls with herb-olive-oil and parmesan.

People are saying

"The food portions here are so generous, I took leftovers home."

"The party here feels like family, with attentive and friendly service."

"The Italian food here is served by super friendly and attentive staff."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended due to the restaurant's popularity.

2

Parking can be challenging; consider arriving early or using valet services.

3

Expect to wait outside during busy times, especially in colder weather.

09
Cole's Dock Side image 1
Seafood restaurant

Oceanfront seafood spot offers spicy rigatoni and seafood risotto with bold flavors. Enjoy live jazz music and magic shows by the bartender in a relaxed, elegant setting. Perfect for diners seeking calm pace and scenic views.

Spicy rigatoni stands out with its crispy chicken and bold flavor. Pasta dishes are consistently excellent and delicious, with highlights like chicken parmesan and seafood risotto adding variety.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be amazing and top quality."

"The seafood here is super fresh and delicious."

"You have to try their spicy rigatoni; it's a game changer."

Good to know

1

Cole's Dock Side has a happy hour featuring clams and oysters.

2

Mike performs a magic show during the dinner/magic show event.

3

Magic Mike performs every Friday night.

Discover more

Great Kills, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...