Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Top picks in Dyker Heights

Italian food

Authentic Italian food that feels like a neighborhood staple instead of a tourist trap.

Based on 579 Opinions
+576
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Pasta Fresca Ravioli image 1
Pasta Fresca Ravioli image 2
Pasta Fresca Ravioli image 3
View all
Italian grocery store

Offers fresh homemade pasta like ravioli and penne, paired with fresh mozzarella and Italian bread. Known for classic Brooklyn charm and a friendly atmosphere. Early visits recommended for fresh baked bread and specialty treats.

Fresh homemade pasta stands out, especially the ravioli and penne. The store also offers fresh mozzarella, Italian bread, and cookies that are highly praised.

People are saying

"Their cookies, especially the lemon drop ones, are out of this world."

"Their fresh pasta is out of this world."

"I thought the Italian food sandwiches were excellent and customizable."

Good to know

1

You must arrive early or the bread sells out.

2

Everything is made fresh on site in their kitchen.

3

The place is impeccably clean.

02
Mama Rao's image 1
Italian restaurant

Cozy Italian spot offers homemade pasta like Penne Siciliano and Rigatoni Bolognese. Intimate, calm vibe with beautiful interior makes dining special. Perfect for events with a private party room and standout dishes like penne alla vodka.

Homemade pasta stands out with dishes like Penne Siciliano and Rigatoni Bolognese showing clear freshness and quality. The penne alla vodka and fresh bread complement the menu well.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing, with unique flavors and great quality."

"The food here is amazing and served piping hot."

"I adored the ravioli bolognese; it was very filling."

Good to know

1

The clam pasta costs $26.

2

Parking can be a challenge if not using valet.

3

The restaurant does not allow changes to the menu, such as substituting ingredients.

03
Faicco's Pork Store image 1

Old-school butcher shop offers classic Italian charm with a wide selection of fresh meats. Italian sausages, especially broccoli rabe varieties, shine for grilling or pasta. Authentic atmosphere blends traditional flavors with a Brooklyn twist.

Italian sausages stand out here, especially the broccoli rabe and regular varieties that work well grilled or in pasta. Fresh mozzarella, pesto, and rice balls also feature prominently in the selection.

People are saying

"I thought their sausage was the best, perfectly seasoned and full of flavor."

"I thought the food here was fantastic and top shelf."

"I thought the Italian food sausage was the best."

Good to know

1

The store accepts credit cards and mobile payments for convenience.

2

Parking is available on the street, but it can be limited during busy hours.

3

Expect a wait during peak lunch hours, especially on weekends.

04
Annabelle's Pastaria image 1
Italian restaurant

Exposed brick walls create a warm old world feel in a cozy space with authentic Italian cuisine. Fresh homemade pasta like pear ravioli and mushroom lasagna shine alongside classic dishes. Attentive service keeps the atmosphere subdued and inviting.

Fresh homemade pasta stands out with dishes like pear ravioli and mushroom lasagna. The menu features a variety of pastas including rigatoni Bolognese and pesto, alongside classic chicken parmigiana.

People are saying

"The made-to-order fresh pasta here is absolutely delicious."

"I thought the desserts were all top notch."

"The fresh pasta here is delicious, especially the bolognese."

Good to know

1

A gratuity of 20% is added for groups of 4 or more people.

2

The restaurant offers gluten-free options due to the owner's celiac disease.

3

There is hardly any wait time at this place.

05
Cavatappi NYC image 1
Italian restaurant

Small, elegant Italian spot offers burrata and Nonnaโ€™s Bolognese in a cozy, dimly lit space. Beautiful art and lively music create a sophisticated yet relaxed vibe. Tables seat four, blending luxury with comfort for a perfect dining experience.

The menu features burrata, Nonnaโ€™s Bolognese, and gluten-free pasta options. Dishes like prosciutto and burrata sandwich with balsamic glaze and linguine vongole highlight the Italian offerings.

People are saying

"The fried calamari is so crispy, light, and perfectly cooked."

"It's a small, cozy spot with a warm, inviting atmosphere."

"The seafood linguine and rice balls are amazing Italian food."

Good to know

1

Reservations are highly recommended because the restaurant is very popular.

2

The restaurant will now be opening at noon for lunch every day.

3

There was more than ample parking when I arrived, which seems to be a rarity anywhere in the city.

06
Krispy Pizza- Brooklyn, NY image 1

Neighborhood spot serves authentic pizza with fresh mozzarella and rich sauces like pesto and vodka. Cozy booths create a welcoming atmosphere perfect for casual dining. Unique bites like the prosciutto rice ball add an Italian twist to the menu.

Pizzas feature fresh mozzarella and rich sauces like pesto and vodka, with standout options like the Grandma pie and pesto roni. The prosciutto rice ball combines crispy texture with cheese and rice for a unique bite.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best pizza in New York City."

"I loved the old school vibe and classic pizza place feel."

"I loved the sweet margherita and the subtle vodka sauce pizzas."

Good to know

1

Customers should order in advance because the place is always busy.

2

You get 6 slices, knots, and 3 drinks for around $40.

3

The penne alla vodka pizza is only sold by the pie and not slices.

07
Parc Oasis image 1
Oyster bar restaurant

Oyster bar offers a cozy yet vibrant atmosphere with dim lighting, perfect for gatherings. Italian dishes shine with mushroom chicken pasta as a must-try. Cocktails like lychee martini add a unique twist to the lively, sometimes loud, setting.

Mushroom chicken pasta stands out as a must-order dish. The pasta dishes range from delicious to slightly salty, with seafood pasta and steak pasta also featured among the options.

People are saying

"The oysters here are super fresh and flavorful."

"I loved the unlimited dining and drinks promotion."

"I loved the pasta and tea at this Italian Food spot."

Good to know

1

The premium AYCE & drink price for adults is 108.88 and for children is 38.

2

The standard AYCE price for adults is 62.88 and for children is 28, with an additional 10 for all you can drink.

3

Reservations are recommended due to the restaurant's busy nature.

08
APIZZA: Dyker Pizza Company image 1

Small, clean space offers a cozy, family atmosphere with nostalgic decor. Excellent pizza features hot honey and pesto toppings alongside classic Margherita. Pasta dishes like fusilli alla vodka come with generous portions and light sauce.

Pasta dishes like fusilli alla vodka with pancetta come with a light sauce and generous portions. Pizzas include varieties topped with hot honey, pesto, and classic Margherita, all paired well with slices of Sopressata and Prosciutto.

People are saying

"You have to try their sourdough pizza; it's amazing."

"The salad was fresh and very tasty."

"The pizza crust here is perfectly cooked and crispy."

Good to know

1

The restaurant only accepts cash.

2

You have to buy an entire pie to dine in.

3

Prices are reasonable, with meals under $100.

09
La Bella Marketplace image 1

Supermarket shines with fresh mozzarella and a strong Italian product selection. Narrow aisles lead to standout deli and seafood counters. Bright, peaceful space feels tight but comfortable for shopping.

Fresh mozzarella and ricotta come straight from the store, often still warm. A wide selection of authentic Italian cheeses, meats, pasta, and uncommon vegetables fills the shelves.

People are saying

"I loved their deli department; the imported cold cuts were great."

"I found this grocery store to be the best in the area."

"The Italian food here has amazing, fresh mozzarella."

Good to know

1

La Bella Marketplace offers a wide variety of Italian products and fresh produce.

2

The deli and seafood departments are standout features of La Bella Marketplace.

3

Weekly sales provide great discounts on various products.

10
Maria's Pizza image 1
Pizza restaurant

Cozy space with intimate tables offers a comforting vibe for authentic New York pizza lovers. Unique corn meal crust makes the pizza crisp and flavorful. Eggplant parmigiana feels homemade with generous portions, paired well with pasta or salad.

Eggplant parmigiana tastes like homemade with great portions and comes with pasta, potato croquette, or salad. Pizza and penne vodka stand out as delicious dishes, though linguine with white clam sauce may not meet expectations.

People are saying

"I thought Maria's Pizza was one of my favorite pizza spots in NYC."

"I was genuinely obsessed with their penne vodka slice."

"Their pizza and penne vodka are so delicious."

Good to know

1

The deal for 2 cheese slices is 6 dollars.

2

The pizzeria offers delivery, dine-in, and take-out options.

3

The current posted health grade is 'A' on the door.

Discover more

Dyker Heights, New York

Area guide
Loading Map...