Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Best of US

PB&J sandwich spots

A peanut butter and jelly sandwich that treats the classic combination as a serious craft rather than a quick, thoughtless meal.

Based on 542 Opinions
+539
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
PB&J with Tay image 1
PB&J with Tay image 2
PB&J with Tay image 3
View all
Sandwich shop

Antique decor and vintage plates create a cozy, home-like setting that feels like stepping back in time. Laidback and friendly energy fills the space, welcoming small groups and families with books and games for kids. Watching sandwiches made fresh adds a personal touch to the relaxed, eclectic atmosphere.

Unique recipe tweaks make the peanut butter and jelly sandwiches stand out with enhanced flavor. Service is fast and the atmosphere feels warm and welcoming.

Peanut butter and jelly sandwiches stand out as exceptionally delicious and well-crafted. The Razz sandwich offers a unique, divine flavor that complements the menu.

People are saying

"I loved their delicious Peanut Butter And Jelly sandwiches."

"You have to try the award-winning banana pudding."

"These sandwiches are outstanding and not your typical PB&J."

Good to know

1

The restaurant does not provide ADA access due to stairs to the second floor.

2

Anyone in a wheelchair or with a disability may find access difficult.

3

There is plenty of parking available nearby.

02
The District Bites and Brew image 1

Neighborhood restaurant and bar offers a modern, clean space with a big bar and plenty of seating. Atmosphere stays casual and fun, featuring pool tables, shuffleboard, and live music nights. The vibe is family-friendly and welcoming, with games and activities for all ages.

Deep fried peanut butter and jelly sandwiches come with powdered sugar and stand out as a crispy, sweet treat. The PBJ Press offers a classic take with a rich peanut butter and jelly blend. Desserts include a variety of PBJ-inspired options like mini churros and vanilla bourbon gelato.

Chicken sandwiches come with thin cut fries and sometimes a fried pickle on top. Options include a chicken caprese and a southern style chicken sandwich.

People are saying

"The food here is amazing and outstanding."

"I found the chicken caprese sandwich and fries delicious."

"You have to try the fried Peanut Butter And Jelly with powdered sugar."

Good to know

1

Happy hour drink prices are available during weekdays from 4-7pm.

2

Trivia night happens every Tuesday at 8pm with a lively host.

3

Half-price whiskey is offered on Fridays, making it a great night to visit.

03
Big Mikeโ€™s Sandwich Co. image 1

Smart looking sub shop with a clean interior offers an engaging experience where staff prepare food in front of customers. The atmosphere is refreshing and lively, enhanced by a fun food hall eating area. Known for huge sandwich portions, fresh fried chicken sandwiches, and smash burgers, it draws a crowd seeking generous, flavorful meals.

Deep frying turns the peanut butter and jelly sandwich into a crispy, rich treat. This version feels like a more grown-up twist on the classic.

East coast-style sandwiches like the Chopped Italian and Ribeye come in huge portions with fresh bread and meat made in-house. The sandwiches pair with crispy fries and offer great value for the price.

People are saying

"I thought the Ribeye sandwich was the best I ever had."

"This sandwich is packed with flavor and tastes so fresh."

"The deep-fried Peanut Butter And Jelly sandwich is amazing."

Good to know

1

Credit cards are the only accepted payment method; no cash is accepted.

2

The average meal costs around $20, including a sandwich, fries, and drink.

3

The sandwich portions are large, making it a good value for the price.

04
The Side Chick image 1
Halal restaurant

Halal restaurant offers cozy atmosphere with great vibes and a blessed food experience. The place attracts those seeking top-rated chicken sandwiches and smash burgers. It often runs out of menu items due to high demand.

Sliders with peanut butter and jelly come melted and soft, creating a unique texture. The PB&J sliders pair well with other items like mac n cheese sliders and jalapeรฑo burgers.

Chicken sandwiches stand out with huge, tender fried chicken and creative toppings like mac n cheese and Hot Cheetos. The MJ and dirty chicken sando sandwiches also deliver bold, memorable flavors.

People are saying

"I thought the food here was amazing and tasted so fresh."

"This chicken sandwich is the best I've ever had."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly sliders just melt in your mouth."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended to avoid long wait times during peak hours.

2

The food truck often runs out of popular menu items, so arrive early.

3

The restaurant is fully halal and well signposted for easy identification.

05
da Toscano image 1
Italian restaurant

Italian spot shines with cozy atmosphere and dim warm lighting. Sandwiches on fresh focaccia impress, especially the tender Porchetta. PB&J Bombolone offers a bold mix with foie gras and peanut butter, creating a unique texture.

PB&J Bombolone features a foie gras filling mixed with peanut butter and jelly. This combination creates a hamburger-like texture that may not appeal to everyone.

Sandwiches come on fresh baked focaccia with creative flavors. The Porchetta sandwich offers a very tender meat and a good size.

People are saying

"I'd return just for the exceptional Italian food desserts."

"The Porchetta sandwich here is excellent and the meat is so tender."

"The Peanut Butter And Jelly bombolone was unforgettable."

Good to know

1

Make a reservation before visiting to ensure a table.

2

The Porchetta pop-up is available at lunchtime on Thursday, Friday, and Saturday.

3

The restaurant has a 90-minute limit for meals, which is mentioned in the small print on their website.

06
Urban Luxe Cafe image 1
Coffee shop

Coffee shop with modern decor and eclectic, edgy design creates an upscale, chill environment. Live entertainment includes open mics, poetry, and music, fostering a creative and welcoming atmosphere. Space serves as a community hub with diverse food options and a vibe that supports local artists.

Fried peanut butter and jelly sandwiches stand out with a grown-up twist. The dish pairs well with a coffee flight, making it a mind-blowing choice.

Fried peanut butter and jelly and plant based meatball sandwiches stand out with rich flavors and authentic textures. Grilled cheese pairs well with sweet potato pie ice cream for a unique combo.

People are saying

"This cafe hosts live music, open mics, and performances."

"The sandwiches here have a relaxing and hip vibe."

"The fried Peanut Butter And Jelly sandwich was excellent."

Good to know

1

Urban Luxe Cafe hosts live entertainment events every weekend, including karaoke and comedy nights.

2

Open mic nights occur every Thursday, providing a platform for local talent.

3

Family fun events are held monthly, making it a great spot for community gatherings.

07
Hamburger America image 1
Hamburger restaurant

Vintage burger diner with retro-modern design and old school American vibe fills a small space packed with eager diners. Formica counters and sizzling flattops create a nostalgic atmosphere where the burger assembly line is visible from the counter. Outdoor seating and a bar add variety to the lively, crowded setting.

Hot Ham Sandwich stands out as a favorite with rich flavor. Classic double smash and fried onion burgers offer unforgettable bites. Grilled cheese with a patty inside adds a unique twist to the sandwich lineup.

People are saying

"The American Food here is simple, delicious, and perfectly satisfying."

"I thought the burger was among the best I ever had."

"I thought the burger and fries were spectacular."

Good to know

1

You order food and pay upfront, which makes the process easy and efficient.

2

Be warned that lines can be long on certain days at George Motzโ€™s restaurant.

3

Opening time is the best time to visit to avoid crowds.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...