Atly Logo
New Yorkers 1st Choice
Guide to the US

Pepper steak sandwiches

A pepper steak that is substantial enough to anchor a meal but served in a sandwich format that does not fall apart.

Based on 641 Opinions
+638
User
User
User
Updated May 2026
01
Giamela's Submarine Sandwiches image 1
Giamela's Submarine Sandwiches image 2
Giamela's Submarine Sandwiches image 3
View all

Sandwich shop offers fresh ingredients and large portions with a focus on pepper steak subs and family-style meals. Atmosphere is basic and clean with a neighborly feel suited for takeout or casual dining. A steady flow of takeout orders reflects its popularity despite a modest seating area.

Pepper steak subs stand out with a red bell pepper sauce that adds rich flavor. The sandwich pairs well with turkey or egg, making it a delicious and satisfying choice.

Sandwiches come with huge portions and a meaty, juicy profile. Options like the pepper steak and monster sandwiches offer great taste and filling sizes with fast service.

People are saying

"I thought the pepper steak sandwich was fire."

"The pasta portions here are huge and a great value."

"These sandwiches are delicious and crazy big."

Good to know

1

Bring cash as credit cards may not be accepted for all transactions.

2

Expect a busy atmosphere, especially during lunch and dinner hours.

3

The parking lot is small, so plan to arrive early or consider takeout.

02
My Philly image 1
Cheesesteak restaurant

Old school corner store vibe with a small diner setup creates a cozy, no-frills atmosphere. Sandwiches are authentic Philly cheesesteaks with generous portions and flavorful meat, served in a spot that feels like a neighborhood hangout. The place offers vegetarian options and quick takeout service.

Well seasoned pepper steak offers exceptional flavor and spices. Options include half portions with extra cheese, fries, and soda for take-out.

Philly cheesesteak sandwiches come with overflowing tender meat and a great meat-to-bun ratio. They sit in a super fresh, soft roll with melted cheese, making each sandwich huge and flavorful.

People are saying

"I thought this was the best Philly cheesesteak sandwich ever."

"I thought this was the best Philly cheesesteak sandwich ever."

"The pepper steak here was phenomenal."

Good to know

1

The restaurant makes orders fresh on the spot.

2

My takeout was ready within 10 minutes.

3

The Philly costs around $16 and does not include a side of fries or a drink.

03
Giamela's image 1
Sandwich shop

Small sandwich shop with an expanded dining area offers a warm and inviting atmosphere. Known for generous portions and unique sandwiches, especially Pepper Steak and Pastrami varieties. Locals frequent the spot for its affordable prices and hearty toppings.

Pepper steak comes cooked and seasoned perfectly with extra cheese and juice available. This sandwich is a classic go-to that never disappoints and stands out as very tasty.

Meat-heavy sandwiches stand out here, especially the Pepper Steak and pastrami options. The Italian deli sandwich and meatball sandwich also get a lot of attention for their flavor and size.

People are saying

"I had to eat the sandwich like a taco because the toppings kept falling out."

"I found the pepper steak sandwich to be amazing and worth the trip."

"The Italian food, especially the lasagna and pizza, is delicious."

Good to know

1

Giamela's does not have a bathroom for customers.

2

There are no high chairs available for families.

3

The restaurant has a small parking lot on the left side of the street.

04
DeFranko's Submarines image 1

Small, run-down shack with limited indoor seating and outdoor picnic tables creates a cozy, old-school mom-and-pop vibe. Atmosphere feels like a nostalgic hole-in-the-wall with a chill, intimate energy. Crowds gather during meal times, making it best to visit early or late.

Pepper steak sandwich stands out with a delicious flavor and is often recommended. Some versions include steamed onions, but occasionally the sandwich can be mostly pickle and dry.

Submarine sandwiches stand out for their large size and generous fillings, especially the pastrami which is a favorite. Options like the chicken salad sandwich also offer solid variety with delicious, well-made cold subs.

People are saying

"I found the pastrami sandwich to be one of the best I ever had."

"It's a small outdoor space with picnic tables."

"I found the pepper steak sandwich delicious and planned to return."

Good to know

1

Expect long wait times during meal hours; arrive early or late.

2

Parking is available in the back, but seating is limited.

3

There is a $7 minimum for card payments.

05
Calozzi's Cheesesteaks image 1
Cheesesteak restaurant

Walk-up window with outdoor picnic tables offers no indoor seating and an industrial corner shop vibe. Atmosphere is minimal, with background sounds of nearby traffic and industry. Sandwiches are known for authentic Philly-style cheesesteaks made with Amoroso rolls and classic toppings.

Pepper steak stands out for cutting through greasiness with a satisfying flavor. It earns consistent praise as a favorite choice and pairs well with other dishes like the mushroom steak sandwich.

Steak sandwiches come Philly-style with spicy peppers that stand out. Bread quality is key, making each sandwich big and delicious.

People are saying

"I thought the cheesesteak sandwiches here were amazing and the best."

"The bread here is fantastic, holding up the whole cheesesteak."

"I really loved the Pepper Steak here."

Good to know

1

There is no indoor seating; only outdoor picnic tables are available.

2

Street parking is the only option and can be limited.

3

Calozzi's Cheesesteaks does not accept cash; credit cards only.

06
Baldinos Giant Jersey Subs image 1

Old-school sub shop with 1970s decor and a classic New York deli vibe. Atmosphere feels nostalgic and authentic but somewhat cramped and dimly lit. Known for high-quality sandwiches with standout bread and fresh ingredients.

Pepper Steak comes in a sandwich and sub form, both packed with flavorful meat. The #11 Pepper Steak serves as a satisfying, filling option often paired with pasta salad.

Sandwiches come in giant sizes, even half portions are large. The #25 sandwich stands out as a signature choice. Quality and price are unmatched compared to other sandwich shops.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are amazing, fully loaded, and huge."

"I loved the old school vibes and decor here."

"The Pepper Steak sandwich is phenomenal and flavorful."

Good to know

1

Expect longer wait times during lunch and dinner hours due to popularity.

2

Limited parking is available, so arrive early to secure a spot.

3

The restroom is clean and well-maintained for customer use.

07
DP CHEESESTEAKS image 1
Restaurant

Restaurant inside a gas station offers drive-thru window and booth seating with easy parking access. Atmosphere is functional and clean, catering to travelers, locals, and workers. Known for delicious cheesesteak sandwiches with fresh bread and generous toppings.

Cherry pepper steak stands out with its spicy cherry peppers and creamy whiz topping. This dish combines heat and richness in every bite.

Cheesesteak sandwiches come with sautรฉed onions and are saturated with cheese whiz for rich flavor. Options include 5-inch and 12-inch sizes, and sandwiches get remade if the order is wrong.

People are saying

"These sandwiches are truly incredible and delicious."

"The food here is delicious and always hot."

"The Pepper Steak here was delicious."

Good to know

1

Parking is available on the side street with easy access to the highway.

2

The restaurant is located in a gas station, making it a convenient quick eat.

3

The takeout process is easy and efficient.

08
Vicky's Local Deli image 1

A deli with freshly baked bread aroma and authentic Hispanic food creates a welcoming atmosphere. It serves generous portions of sandwiches, salads, and pupusas with reasonable prices. The place feels like a clean, neighborhood staple with a focus on hearty, satisfying meals.

Platter options include pepper steak and rice. The pepper steak pairs with meat and cheese pupusas for a notable combo. Some find the pepper steak less impressive compared to other spots' pupusas.

Cuban sandwich stands out with a rich mix of flavors. Breakfast sandwiches and hot beans and rice add variety to the menu.

People are saying

"The deli food here is so fresh and delicious."

"I thought the pepper steak was to die for."

"I loved the delightful explosion of flavors in their sandwiches."

Good to know

1

The deli offers a variety of breakfast platters at reasonable prices.

2

Expect good portions for the price at this local deli.

3

The deli maintains a clean and immaculate environment.

09
Cha Cha Tang image 1
Cantonese restaurant

Dimly lit space with cozy booths and red accents creates a speakeasy vibe that feels relaxed and romantic. Busy but not loud, it attracts groups for family gatherings or nights out. Stylish interior contrasts with a tiny, less comfortable bar area, while outside seating offers an expansive option.

Sauce on the black pepper steak is delicious and it comes with broccoli rabe instead of the usual Chinese broccoli. The dish includes four pieces, one per person, and is priced near $60.

The duck sandwich stands out with rich flavor that commands a pause. A burger-style sandwich exists but tends to be overcooked.

People are saying

"The food at these dinner spots is delicious, especially the Peking duck."

"The duck sandwich here is so good it makes you pause."

"I loved the Black Pepper Steak; it had a delicious sauce."

Good to know

1

The Mid-Autumn Festival Dinner features a variety of menu items.

2

Reservations are recommended for special events like the Mid-Autumn Festival Dinner.

3

The kitchen closes early, so plan to arrive before closing time.

10
McCoco's | The Best Caribbean Family Restaurant & catering image 1

Caribbean restaurant offers a fun atmosphere with phenomenal live music and a beautiful back patio. The space features island-themed decor and TVs showing island views, creating a welcoming vibe. Guests enjoy refreshing mojitos and authentic dishes like mofongo and empanadas.

Pepper steak comes out perfect with a rich flavor. It pairs well with other dishes like churrasco and empanadas for a solid meal.

Sandwiches feature meats with mayonnaise and choices like Swiss or sliced cheddar cheese. Options include the Cubano sandwich with tostones and the McPaisa or pernil sandwich, all noted as delicious.

People are saying

"I found the food here to be delicious."

"I found the pepper steak to be perfectly seasoned and cooked."

"I thought the sandwich was really good."

Good to know

1

Reservations are recommended on weekends due to high demand.

2

Expect long wait times during peak hours, especially on weekends.

3

The restaurant adds an automatic gratuity for parties of two or more.

11
The SoulFood Lounge 2 image 1
Soul food restaurant

Small soul food restaurant offers an intimate atmosphere with an all-black aesthetic and live music featuring jazz and saxophone. The vibe stays laid back and refreshing, suited for quiet dinners or date nights. Space is limited, creating a cozy but sometimes cramped setting.

Rich Boy sandwich stands out as scrumptious while the salmon pesto sandwich falls short. Shrimp Rich Boy comes with undercooked French fries and tastes just alright.

People are saying

"The American Food here, like the turkey leg, is off the bone and delicious."

"The pepper steak here is flavorful and expertly prepared."

"The Rich Boy sandwich was absolutely scrumptious."

Good to know

1

Reservations are necessary to secure a spot inside the restaurant.

2

Parking can be difficult, often requiring a walk from 1-3 blocks away.

3

The restaurant has a 'No Share Policy' for events like 'The Grand Tasting'.

Discover more

United States

Area guide
Loading Map...